Walter Reed scandal forces third major resignation

You did a heckuva job, Kiley.

The Army forced its surgeon general, Lt. Gen. Kevin C. Kiley, to retire, officials said Monday, making him the third high-level official to lose his job over poor outpatient treatment of wounded soldiers at Walter Reed Army Medical Center.

Kiley, who headed Walter Reed from 2002 to 2004, submitted his retirement request on Sunday, the Army said in a statement.

Kiley had been a lightning rod for criticism over conditions at Walter Reed, including during congressional hearings on Walter Reed last week. Articles by The Washington Post described substandard conditions and bureaucratic delays at the facility overwhelmed with wounded from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

I’d add that Kiley has been “a lightning rod for criticism” because he deserved it. As the WaPo reported, it was Kiley who largely ignored complaints about conditions at Walter Reed, and even downplayed the controversy, insisting that the problems in Building 18 “weren’t serious and there weren’t a lot of them.” Kiley lived right across the street from Building 18, where war wounded were “housed among mice, mold, rot and cockroaches,” but neglected to help. In one instance, Kiley even ignored the concerns of a congressman’s wife, who urged him to help a wounded soldier lying in his own urine.

Given this, it was encouraging to hear that NBC reported that Kiley may be demoted in retirement, by at least one rank.

I have to admit, this is the first Bush scandal in six years in which it seems responsible officials are being held to account.

On Mar. 1, Army Secretary Francis Harvey fired Maj. Gen. George Weightman, who was the current head of Walter Reed.

On Mar. 2, Defense Secretary Robert Gates fired Army Secretary Harvey, because he’d given Weightman’s job to Kiley.

On Mar. 12, acting Army Secretary Pete Garem fired Kiley.

Newsweek reports this week that Gates is directing the clean-up.

When the Post first published its stories, Bush’s chief of staff, Josh Bolten, called Robert Gates, the new Defense secretary. Bolten, who replaced Andy Card a little more than a year ago, is a results-oriented pragmatist. So is Gates. The two men agreed that swift action was called for. A senior White House official, who requested anonymity discussing the president’s private conversations, tells NEWSWEEK that Gates called President Bush and said: “I’m going to hold people accountable. I don’t know how high it will get. But it will be high.” Bush responded, the official says, “Do what you need to do.”

As Atrios put it after Harvey was fired, “This is the first time in the entire Bush administration that we’ve had anything which even felt remotely like a genuine ‘accountability’ moment.”

I’m just glad something could get the Bush gang’s attention. It took them long enough.

Demoted one rank? Boo friggin hoo. What does a soldier have to do to earn a dishonorable discharge or a court martial these days? If that isn’t an option his arse should be shipped to Iraq put on IED detection.

However, I am of course delighted that this smug fuckwit is history.

  • i’ve said it before. this robert gates is starting to impress me. “i’m going to hold people accountable…” i’m surprised bush didn’t fall off his chair, and cheney didn’t have a heart attack when they heard that.

  • just bill–unfortunately, accountability (like other things) tends to flow downhill. So BushCo won’t be “demoted” until ’08.

  • “Coverup Kiley” gets his accountability moment.

    yay.

    Too bad the blogs beat the “real” media to this story by about a week.

    Die, suckas.

  • Anybody ever hear of “the buck stops here”? What about ol’ “support the troops” himself? I guess he figures soldiers (healthy handsome ones) are just good for backdrops at his photops and nothing more.

  • Yet another example of the a horribly run government institution. I can’t wait for a nationalized healthcare system so we can all lie in utter disgrace like our fallen heros have the last few years at these hell holes.

    It’s time for private citizens to step up and make donations to a charity of their choice which supports recovering soldiers and their families, to offset some of the wrongs of this scandal.

  • TAIO, I am sure this guy was hoping to get all 4 stars and the difference between retiring disgracefully at two stars or retiring at fours stars, is immense. He may not be a household name, but the circle he runs in are sure to know him.

    The real culprit, Bush, gets to look like the good guy in all of this and Rumsfield is taking no flak for what happened on his watch.

    Kiley is the…. not scapegoat, but he burdened most the responsibility, when in fact only some of it falls on his lap.

    You pretty much need to commit a felony to get a court martial and/or dishonorable discharge. There are about 6 levels of discharge and dishonorable is the lowest.

  • no, jrs jr. it is not time for private citizens to step up and make donations to a charity. that’s the government’s responsibility, and it should live up to it. you idiots always think private charities are the way to solve all of governments’ problems.

  • “Yet another example of the a horribly run government institution”Jrs Jr.

    You are about a week too late with your misrepresentation of public health care.

    See The Carpetbagger Report:

    “The right settles on a response to the Walter Reed scandal”
    Monday, March 5th, 2007
    http://www.thecarpetbaggerreport.com/archives/10111.html
    “Clinton was responsible for making VA hospitals among the best in the country”
    “. . . .problems at Walter Reed were triggered by — you guessed it — privatization.”

  • You are so fucking stupid, Jr. Universal health care is not “nationalized health care”. Maybe we should recruit some HMOs to go over and set up shop in Iraq so the soldiers can drop by and get their health care needs taken care of by private doctors.

  • Gridlock #7 – You don’t suppose Halliburton moving to Dubai has anything to do with the fact that the UAE has no extradition treaty with the US do you?

  • “that’s the government’s responsibility, and it should live up to it.”

    No shit, Billy Boy. But the sad truth is that big, wonderful government has done a horrible job these last few decades taking care of injured soldiers — first the Vietnam Vet’s treatment and now this.

    At least I know my donated dollar is going to a justfied cause… who the hell knows where that same dollar would go once deposited into the US Treasury. They certainly haven’t gone to helping the fallen heros based on the recent evidence unsurfaced.

  • You are so fucking stupid, Jr. Universal health care is not “nationalized health care”.

    Dale — Who said it was???

  • This scandal needs to come home to roost with Bush (and with the all the thieving lying incompetent Republicans that have been been enabling him).

    Bush is the Commander in Chief. This is not just a nice title, nor does it mean that his responsibilities end with sending our soldiers off to war. He caused this by insisting on a war and refusing to plan for it properly, and by trying to nickle and dime the soldiers in order to pay for tax cuts for his rich buddies, so he owns this mess.

    For decades, the thieving lying incompetent Republican party has been tooting its own horn in terms of being patriotic and pro-military and has been questioning everyone else’s patriotism. However, they are the only people who had the responsibility and the power to find out about this and do something about it., so they are responsible. May they gag on their hypocrisy.

  • jrs, jr……..you’re pathetic. it’s your republicrook party that has been responsible for the terrible treatment that all vets have received. and it’s your republicrook party that has managed to destroy our economy and raid the treasury.

  • This is not a defense of Kiley, but what troubles me about all of this is that it’s the direct result of policies put in place by the Bush administration. First: They went to war — not just any war, but a war of choice. Second: Having decided on that move, they rejected all efforts to plan fully for the war. Third: They over-rode Army objections (in the case of Walter Reed outpatient healthcare, at least) and instituted a privatization of services, giving that contract to political friends.

    I don’t honestly believe it’s fair to fire or demote officers (or put top brass in the position where they have to resign) whose job has been made difficult or impossible by their civilian bosses. I’d feel a whole lot better if firings started at the top — in all cases, not just in Washington and in politics — unless we’re sure the ranks have deliberately defied a good policy.

  • …wonderful government has done a horrible job these last few decades… -JRS Jr.

    The direct and foreseeable result of repeatedly electing those into office who do no believe in government.

    The Democrats will fix it.

  • A query for Jrs Jr:

    Since the government is so incompetent when it comes taking care of soldiers after they are wounded, do you think it should get out of the business putting them in harm’s way?

    ****

    Thanks for the info ScottW. Hopefully Kiley being booted won’t end the inquiries up the chain of command.

  • JRS Jr — You’ve been spending to much time studying rocks. Time to look at the living things among us.

  • Put the blame WHERE IT BELONGS WITH THE CONGRESS – THEY CUT THE BUDGET FOR THE VETERANS AND DEFENSE – not Bush – you can’t run the hospitals on prayer and fumes. You need money and CONGRESS kept Cutting the Budget- ask any veteran… of any war – Walter Reed has 1st rate docs, but last year, they were on the HIT LIST TO BE DOWNSIZED -THAT’S CONGRESS FOR YOU- and there’s a WAR GOING ON????

  • I GUESS THE SAYING S…ROLLES DOWN HILL. THE OTHER OFFICERS THAT NEED TO BE CHECK ARE THE UNIT COMMANDERS THAT DIDN’T REPORT IT UP THE CHAIN. WALTER REED HAVE DIFFERT UNITS THAT HAVE SUP-UNIT THAT WORK THEIR SOILDERS COMMANDER NEED LOOK AT.

  • It’s a truism, I know, but isn’t it odd how the ignorant need to SHOUT THEIR VIEWS?

    As for JSR jr’s urging everyone to donate to the health care system of their choice, how about taking the same approach elsewhere: rely on private charity to provide police and fire protection, sewage removal, clean water, pure food, safe drugs, well-engineered buildings, national railroads, international airports? That’s how they did it in “the good old days”, isn’t it? Caveat emptor?

  • I’m just glad something could get the Bush gang’s attention.

    From the flippant response that was reported here, “Do what you need to do” it sounds like the credit lies with Gates, not with them.

    And as for an explanation for trolls like JRS JR, take a look at this free online book, The Authoritarians.

  • Comments are closed.