‘The only ‘team’ that was being helped during this briefing was the Republican Party team’

As if the administration didn’t have enough problems, the controversy surrounding the politicization of the General Services Administration seems to be yet another debacle gone horribly awry.

We learned on Monday that GSA Administrator Lurita Alexis Doan and White House Deputy Political Director Scott Jennings joined in a videoconference in January to discuss how the agency could be used to help Republican congressional candidates nationwide. Jennings delivered an obviously-partisan PowerPoint presentation, which Doan followed by asking GSA political appointees how they could “help ‘our candidates'” in the 2008 elections.

As one might imagine, Democrats on the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee had a few concerns about this, and called Doan to testify under oath in an open hearing today. It really didn’t go well for the administration — Doan probably would have been better off resigning instead of humiliating herself the way she did today.

Here’s a clip from this morning’s House government reform committee hearing, investigating General Services Administration Chief Lurita Doan.

In this clip, Rep. Bruce Braley (D-IA) grills her on a PowerPoint presentation (pdf) given by Karl Rove’s deputy Scott Jennings to GSA personnel in January. The slides (13 pages) detailed which seats were “House Targets” and which “Senate Targets”, which states were “Republican Offense,” and which “Republican Defense.” After the presentation, Doan reportedly asked other employees how the agency could help “our candidates.” The GSA, remember, is the government’s contracting agency, in charge of almost $60 billion each year. All of this seems like a clear violation of the Hatch Act, which prohibits using federal resources to aid political parties.

Loan doesn’t have a good answer for Braley’s questions, stuttering out “I don’t recall”s and something about how the meeting was a “brown bag lunch” for the purpose of “team building.”

Braley completely took her apart. It was quite an impressive display.

He’d show Doan a series of slides, prepared by Karl Rove’s office, with a list of candidates who were identified as “vulnerable” or “targets.” Doan would deny that she even understood what the slides meant.

Braley asked, “Can you tell us what, if anything, these slides have to do with the GSA’s core purpose of procuring supplies and managing federal buildings?”

Doan replied, “This brown-bag luncheon, I believe, has been mischaracterized. This is a meeting, that is a team-building meeting.”

This wasn’t persuasive. “This was a partisan political briefing; it occurred on GSA property, during work hours, and it had nothing to do with the GSA mission. You identified ‘team building’ as one of the purposes of this meeting. Can you explain to the taxpayers of this country how holding this partisan political briefing helped with team-building?”

Doan couldn’t explain. It didn’t matter — she was busted. The Hatch Act explicitly prohibits partisan campaign activities on federal property and Doan’s GSA obviously violated it.

“I think the American taxpayers have a very good reason to wonder whether the only ‘team’ that was being helped during this briefing was the Republican Party team,” Braley concluded.

Watch the video. It’s as thorough a takedown as I’ve ever seen. I kind of hope the administration tries to defend what happened here, because at this point, Doan and the GSA have been caught red-handed.

Update: Wow: “Listening into the live webcast of the GSA hearings just now, the camera was down, but the audio was still up and you could here GSA Administrator Lurita Doan griping about the investigation and telling one of her people to take her glass, cause she doesn’t want ‘them to have my fingerprints. They’ve got me totally paranoid!'”

I’m not a government employee. I had never heard of the Hatch Act. But you’d think they would have. I doubt these idiots even knew they were breaking the law. Total Bush Administration incompetence, from the top to the bottom.

  • A beautiful video. Popcorn for everyone!

    You can tell she’s thinking “how the F*** did I get myself into this?”

    I wonder how many other stooges like her are going to be fried soon.

    Lotta people gonna decide to spend more time with the family.

  • I really hope the Democrats don’t pursue this. It’s not what the public wants to see. —Comment by memekiller

    No the public does not want to see this, but it happened, and should serve as a metaphor for what has been happening to our public trust. It is not pleasant for a civil servant to be so caught, but what is the alternative? Business as usual?

  • Braley was known in Iowa as an effective litigator – I’m glad to see him put his cross-examination skills to the task of public service.

  • When I was on the Burlington City Council twelve years ago, I was denied a job at the friggin’ food shelf because of the Hatch Act.

    You do not speak for the public, Memekiller #3, and I for one believe it is in the public interest to pursue accountability always.

  • All federal employees know about the Hatch Act. I have often been canvassing for candidates and ran into Federal Employees who have said they would like to help, but are concerned about the restrictions of the Hatch Act.

    It is highly unlikely that someone would reach such a high positon in the Federal Govt. and be unaware of the Hatch Act. Maybe she thought there would be no oversight of her activities. Hmmm, perhaps the fact that there has been no oversight for 6 years had something to do with that.

  • I kinda agree with memekiller (or his/her channeled version of Stengel). I think the public would rather see an impeachment hearing!

    But maybe that’s next month’s feature.

    More popcorn?

  • I for one, also speaking as a citizen, entirely concur with Memekiller. What’s past is past, and the Democrats need to move on. Payback is fine and dandy for Republicans, but America expects the Dems to bend over and take it like the San Francisco Liberals they are. If the Republicans wanted to politicize the GSA a few months ago, our hands our tied. It’s already happened. Water under the bridge. If they try it again, we can stop them from doing it, but the moment it’s stopped, the investigation has got to cease. We shouldn’t live in the past and the best we can do is shake our fists in the air and grumble. That’s my opinion as a citizen.

    But as a former (short-time) GSA employee, I say they need to fry.

  • Shooting Republicans in a barrel – fun fun fun!!

    As my great-granduncle told me early on: “The only good Republicans are pushing up daisies.”

    Watching them get put in the casket and lowered into the ground is sooooo satisfying.

  • From C&L:

    Doan was on CREW’s Most Corrupt Admin list

    http://www.citizensforethics.org/files/execcorruption/reports/Doan.pdf

    In December 2006, Ms. Doan proposed cutting $5 million from the budget of GSA’s Office of the Inspector General (“IG”) for reviewing government contracts for fraud and waste. Her proposal included shifting some responsibility for contract reviews to small private auditors.4 In recent years, IG audits have helped the agency recover billions of dollars from fraudulent contracts.5 According to Ms. Doan, however, the IG’s work is “intimidating to the workforce.”6 Ms. Doan has also criticized GSA Inspector General Brian D. Miller for not supporting her plan to streamline the agency’s contracting efforts, stating: “There are two kinds of terrorism in the US: the external kind; and internally, the IGs have terrorized the Regional Administrators.”7

    (apologies for the pdf garbage)

  • If there was ever a Big Deal in Federal employment, it’s the Hatch Act. I remember when I was 16 and going out to knock on doors for John Kennedy, my father was worried that he – a Federal employee – could get in trouble for my doing so.

    This is really huuuuuuge. You couple it with Alphonso Jackson at the Small Business Administration giving money to Bush supporters only, and you have these fuckers by the short hairs, as they say.

  • Speaking as a 28-year veteran of the federal judicial system, this lady is toast and all her transparently absurd denials will not save her.

    The sound you hear is the house of cards consisting of all the morons placed in government by the Bush administration tumbling down in a thunderous crash.

    They’re fine as long as nobody is looking, but once they’re busted their total incompetence shines through like a fireball in a clear night sky.

    May they all rot in Leavenworth for years to come.

  • What are the penalties for violations of the Hatch Act, besides losing their jobs? I mean, odds are that they’ll fall into something comfortable once their asses get canned…

  • See http://www.osc.gov/documents/hatchact/HA%20presentation%20(federal)_files/frame.htm for an HTML PowerPoint presentation detailing the do’s and don’ts that are covered by the Hatch Act (the OSC website also includes other docs at http://www.osc.gov/library.htm). There are two levels of coverage but both seem to be concerned with this type of activity (see slide 18). Seems that the OSC (Office of Special Council which “is an independent investigative and prosecutorial agency in the Executive Branch”) should have been involved in either keeping this activity from happening or punishing those who violate it.

  • I happened to watch a bit of this hearing today. What a pathetic sight one Ms. Doan. To think that she was intrusted with the public good, and then to hear her “lack of any meaningful memory” in regard to the commission of her office, is to watch in horror as I realize the Bushies don’t care one iota about our nation and its heritage. -Kevo

  • Here’s a good question: How the hell is the lazy MSM going to keep up with all of these Republican scandals?

    C-SPAN may have to create a “C-SPAN 4” just to cover all of the lying Bushies.

  • I am one of “the public,” and I want to see every one of these Republican tools who put party before polity flogged up and down the DC Mall in sackcloth and ashes.

  • It’s a week for good video. Yesterday we had McCain getting smacked down live from Baghdad, today we have this truly remarkable performance. It’s a bad day when your best defense is that multiple witnesses can’t agree on just which exact words you used to promote agency support for Republican candidates.

    Ms. Doan should rest easy about leaving glasses around. I’m sure that, if ‘they’ want her fingerprints, the intake facility when she goes to jail will do quite nicely for getting them.

  • Clearly, the lying thieving incompetent Republicans have left no stone unturned in politicizing everything in an effort to further the Republican cause. We have recently seen how Libby, Rove, and Cheney put party interests ahead of national security. We’ve seen how Harriet Miers and Alberto Gonzales value “loyal Bushie” behavior over everything else, which suggests (as every should already know) that that is why Bush so strongly supported them for the Supreme Court. We’ve seen that anything less than prostituting your office to get Democrats and save corrupt Republicans gets you put on the blacklist if you are a US Attorney. Now the General Services Administration is shown to be run by a Republican lackey for strict partisan advantage.

    The other day, CB ran a quote from a senior democrat to the effect that “We’ve only had subpoena power for the last six weeks and every tree that we’ve barked up so far has had a cat in it – imagine where we’ll be after six months.” I thought he was exaggerating, but it really does look like they could investigate any mid- to high-level Bush appointee and find inappropriate to illegal behavior. Yeah for subpoena power!

  • The point that N.Wells @ 23 makes is right on. What all these recent revelations prove is exactly what many of us have been saying all along: that lawlessness for the sake of partisan gain is systemic in this administration. The antics at Justice and GSA, censorship at NOAA, NASA, EPA, DHHS, etc., are all part of the same thing.

    We are at the point where each new scandal should not be seen in the press as an isolated event nor the fault of a few individuals, but further proof of the viral infection that modern conservative thought has injected into the executive branch.

  • What are the penalties for violations of the Hatch Act, besides losing their jobs?

    I had the same question, and looked up the Hatch Act in Wikipedia. Apparently there can be both civil and criminal penalties associated with violating it. I believe Doan is in real legal jeopardy. She’s a relatively small fish, though, so she may be able to cut a deal if she agrees to flip on higher-ups.

    The blatant violation of the Hatch Act is only part of the story, however. Bear in mind that this stuff occurred this past January – only a few weeks back, well after the Dems had taken both House and Senate. Doan and the rest must have known that committees like Waxman’s would be coming around with subpoenas and very hostile questions, yet they continued with this obviously illegal meeting anyway. Stupid, arrogant, or just so corrupt they can’t help themselves?

  • “The blatant violation of the Hatch Act is only part of the story, however. Bear in mind that this stuff occurred this past January – only a few weeks back, well after the Dems had taken both House and Senate. Doan and the rest must have known that committees like Waxman’s would be coming around with subpoenas and very hostile questions, yet they continued with this obviously illegal meeting anyway. Stupid, arrogant, or just so corrupt they can’t help themselves? ”

    Given their memories or what they are, I just think they forgot.

  • What is really needed is structural remedies to prevent this crap from happening again – one branch voluntarily yielding its power to another, changing of bills in conference, public campaign finance, perhaps even mandatory voting laws, there’s more I’m sure.

    While I’m in agreement that some of this is water under the bridge, crimes need to be paid for.

  • Looks like we might have a reason to keep Gitmo open. I propose we take all the soldiers who’ve gotten screwed over by this administration—extended tours of duty, curtailed rotations home, filthy, roach-infested quarters at Walter Reed, and everything else like that—and let them be the “guards.”

    Geneva Conventions? Hey—these dunderheaded ReThugs will not be classified as “prisoners of war.”

    Sound familiar, ya filthy little Bushite rats?

  • I am so darn tired and fed up with hearing people say- it happened in the past and we need to forget it and move on..etc etc. There have been a great deal of potentially illegal acts that have occured the past 6 years and they do need to be investigated and charges brought when appropriate. A crime is a crime whether a Republican does it or a Democrate. If the American public continues to believe that the Federal Government is full of crooks, then we need to do something to bring accountability to the government. I think it is the business of Congress to investigate and have more oversight into the other branches.

  • Comments are closed.