Again with the Girl Scouts

Guest Post by Morbo

James Dobson of Focus on the Family just can’t hide his disdain for the Girl Scouts. His propaganda arm, Family News in Focus, attacked them yet again July 31, claiming that girls are leaving the Scouts in droves for a Christian fundamentalist alternative called American Heritage Girls.

Somehow I doubt it. The Girl Scouts have been around since 1912 and aren’t likely to be knocked off by fundamentalists poseurs.

To most people, the Girl Scouts are as American as apple pie. What is Dobson’s beef with the organization, anyway? He claims he’s mad at the Scouts for dropping the word “God” from their oath. But that’s not what happened. The word “God” was merely made optional. Girls can still say the original oath if they want to, and my guess is most do. A non-theistic oath is available for those girls who are non-religious or have some other objection to taking a religious oath.

I think this is all a cover. What’s Dobson is really mad about is that the Girl Scouts teach self-reliance. Through scouting, girls learn valuable skills that enable them to engage the world with confidence. Scouting teaches girls that there is nothing a modern woman cannot achieve.

Such girls are not likely to fall for fundamentalist claptrap — that their true role, determined by the Bible, is to stay home, tend to the house, raise children and defer to their husbands on all important issues. Thus, the Girl Scouts’ sin is not making “God” optional; it’s that they dare to tell girls to dream, aspire and achieve.

Dangerous stuff, indeed.

Don’t forget that the Girl Scouts, unlike the Boy Scouts, don’t discriminate on the basis of theism (or lack thereof) or sexuality. Aside from making young women into independent, self-sufficient purveyors of their own destiny, that they’re not sanctioning descrimination drives the CFA, and others of their ilk, crazier than they already are.

  • The AHG eh? Look, the initials can be switched to spell HAG.

    OMG! They’re going to turn girls into witches!

    I say the latest round of screeching is not driven by “God optional” oaths or the fact that GS teaches girls to be self-reliant. They’ve always done the latter, why freak out about it now?

    This is yet another desperate bid for attention from FotF along with a chance to shill for the AHG. Notice the FotFers don’t say the GS has always been evil because too many of their female members were likely GS. Nope, according to FotF the GS has recently become evil and is getting worse, so better send your daughters to this group (in which they likely have some monetary interest).

  • Yet another example of how our friends to the extreme right tend to eat each other for no real reason other than to show their God is better than anyone else’s. I wouldn’t want to live next door to Dobson for he is a charlatan who doesn’t know the first thing about loving thy neighbor! -Kevo

  • Comments are closed.