Way back in January, the Washington Post ran a front-page piece documenting Barack Obama’s admitted experimentation with drugs as a teenager. The 1,300-word piece didn’t exactly break new ground, but the article concluded that Obama’s “bad choices, including drug use starting in high school and ending in college … are sure to receive new scrutiny.”
The political world responded with a collective yawn. Obama had not only acknowledged drug use three decades ago, he wrote about it extensively in an autobiography. Unanswered questions pique reporters’ interest; already-answered questions are a lot less interesting. No one on either side of the aisle found any of this compelling, and the issue has barely been a blip on the radar since.
That is, until someone in New Hampshire asked Obama about it yesterday, sparking a new round of media interest.
Barack Obama candidly discussed his youthful drinking and drug use with high school students Tuesday, prompting at least one teen to conclude that such experimentation won’t automatically ruin a young person’s future.
After delivering a policy address on education at Manchester Central High School, Obama chatted with students in a classroom, where a school staffer asked the Illinois senator to talk about his high school memories.
“I made some bad decisions that I’ve actually written about,” he said. “There were times when I, you know, got into drinking, experimented with drugs. There was a whole stretch of time where I didn’t really apply myself a lot.”
Obama explained that he “got really serious” in college, realized he wasted his time in high school, and began to get himself on track. “In fact, I was so serious that my mother told me to lighten up, because I’d become a complete grind — fortunately over time I got a little balanced,” he said.
The audience seemed to appreciate Obama’s honesty and willingness to be candid about his youthful mistakes. But Mitt Romney wasn’t impressed, calling Obama’s remarks a “huge mistake.”
“It’s just not a good idea for people running for president of the United States, who potentially could be the role model for a lot of people, to talk about their personal failings while they were kids, because it opens the doorway to other kids thinking, ‘Well I can do that too,'” Romney said.
Please. Are we really going to make this race about what candidates did as teenagers 35 years ago? What would Romney have Obama do, lie to students and school officials about things he’s already written about?
For that matter, by Romney’s logic, George W. Bush must be the worst president of all time, because no one could possibly be a worse role model — goof off through high school, goof off through college, experiment with drugs, become an alcoholic, get arrested, lie about getting arrested, fail in one venture after another, basically coast through life while relying on a famous last name through his 40s … and then seek high public office. And Romney’s worried that Obama might not be a good role model?
I’m actually at a loss to understand why the media jumped on this story at all yesterday. I suppose reporters occasionally need something new to talk about, but I kind of thought we’d moved past “youthful indiscretions.” Indeed, Obama’s admissions show a certain political maturity on the nation’s part — most Americans simply no longer care what presidential candidates did as teenagers.
The really interesting response, however, came from Rudy Giuliani, who was far more forgiving than Romney.
During a campaign stop in Chicago, Republican presidential candidate Rudy Giuliani was asked if he thought Obama’s comments to the students were appropriate. “I respect his honesty,” Giuliani said.
“One of the things that we need from our people that are running for office is not this pretense of perfection,” said Giuliani, who has faced questions about his own personal life marked by three marriages and estrangement from his two children. He said of the candidates, “we’re all human beings.”
That’s a smart line to take, given Giuliani’s personal scandals. If Obama’s personal activities as a high-school student are on the table, Giuliani might as well drop out now.
That said, isn’t it a little unfair for Giuliani to suggest his mistakes are comparable to Obama’s? After all, Obama experimented with drugs while in high school. Giuliani’s personal scandals include marching in a parade with his mistress at age 56.
Part of dismissing “youthful indiscretions” is the understanding that they happened during someone’s youth.