When it’s time to gracefully exit the stage

By some measures, Andrew Young is an American hero. The former mayor of Atlanta, Young was a champion of the civil rights movement and a close ally of Martin Luther King in the 1960s, he was a popular mayor of Georgia’s biggest city, he was a successful member of Congress, and drew plaudits as Jimmy Carter’s ambassador to the United Nations.

But Young has not yet realized that his best days are behind him. Instead of gracefully exiting the public stage, Young hangs on and ends up embarrassing himself. It’s a genuine shame.

The first inkling that Young had lost his way came in 2001, when he joined with the Bush White House to tout the president’s “faith-based initiative.” Shortly thereafter, he accepted a big paycheck to become a shill for Wal-Mart. Young’s career took a turn for the worse in 2006 when he was forced to resign from Wal-Mart after telling a reporter that “Jews,” “Koreans,” and “Arabs” have been “overcharging [African-American customers], selling us stale bread and bad meat and wilted vegetables.”

Over the weekend, we learned about Young’s on-air analysis of the race for the Democratic presidential nomination. (via Too Sense)

Civil rights icon Andrew Young says Barack Obama is too “young” to ascend to the White House.

Young also quipped that Hillary Clinton has her husband behind her, and that “Bill is every bit as black as Barack,” adding, “He’s probably gone with more black women than Barack.”

Young, who supports Hillary Clinton’s campaign, went on to argue that Obama was raised in a Chinese family, and then attended “Muslim schools.” He added that Hillary, in advance of the 1992 campaign, organized a committee to “deal with…all the women” that Bill Clinton had relationships with.

Time to stop talking, Mr. Young.

First, suggesting that Obama is too young is a little silly — he’s the same age as Bill Clinton was in 1992.

Second, for Young to argue that Clinton is “as black” as Obama seems over the top. As Oliver Willis noted, “President Clinton was a great leader who acknowledged black America in a way no previous president had, but he is not black and Barack Obama is.”

Third, for someone trying to help the Clinton campaign, suggesting that the former president has “gone with” lots of black women is not exactly prudent.

And fourth, for anyone to argue publicly that Obama went to “Muslim schools,” when we know that isn’t true, is just ridiculous.

Just to clarify, Young wasn’t speaking on behalf of the Clinton campaign; he was speaking for himself, saying lots of dumb things.

There’s no shame in quietly stepping aside after you’ve passed your prime. The sooner Young realizes that, the better.

Again with the muslim slander? I don’t often feel sorry for Hillary, but this is an exception. She has to either let this maroon drag her down or take the heat for dumping him. Not gonna be pretty.

  • Young is like Coulter and O’Reilly – he craves the limelight. And, to counter his own comments, he is proof that age does not necessarily bring wisdom.

  • Yeah, it’s time for Andy Young to shut up. He may have been associated with MLK and won a well-deserved place in history for that association, but in his later years, all the praise seems to have gone to his head, creating an egotist. For God’s sake, the man supports Paul Wolfowitz, super neocon. One can only wonder if Andy Young, despite his accomplishments, really thinks about anything very much. Has anybody thought to ask him if he was “too young” to run for the US Senate at age 40? Barack is older than he was then.

    I dunno. Sounds like envy to me.

  • “Civil rights icon Andrew Young says Barack Obama is too “young” to ascend to the White House.”

    i wonder what andrew young’s response would have been if someone had told him he was too “young” to be mayor of atlanta?

  • Election season always brings out the attention hogs, doesn’t it? And what they have to say is usually worth little, other than to confirm why these people were out of the spotlight to begin with; Andy Young seems as good a case in point as any. What does he offer? Opinion based in rumors, with a hint of bigotry, a smattering of sexual innuendo, and utter nonsense; I can’t imagine the Clinton campaign welcomes any of it, and I can only imagine their frustration in having to address it.

    He does, however, fit right in with media’s game plan for covering an election, so how handy for them that Young’s willing to traffic in rumor and innuendo, and give the media the cover they need to keep talking about things that don’t matter, as opposed to real issues. As near as I can tell, there aren’t many media outlets willing to challenge the kinds of things people like Andy Young are saying, allowing much of it to stand as though it were truth.

    Yes, Andy Young needs to exercise some common sense and understand that his opinion is no more valid than yours or mine, but as long as someone is willing to give him – and so many others – a microphone, we are going to be subjected to this kind of garbage for the foreseeable future.

  • In the interest of true racial equality I declare Andrew Young a stupid prick.

    I could see how that arsehole might have thought a little race baiting to call attention to the fact Obama is half Caucasian might help HRC because a lot of people of both races still have a problem with that. But suggesting Bill Clinton has “gone with” more black women defeats the purpose.

    Go. Away.

  • Brings to mind a verse from the Bible “To everything there is a season . . .’

    It is a shame that Mr. Young doesn’t realize that his time has passed and that he must make way for the new generation.

    Brings to mind another quote, this one from a song by Bob Dylan: “. . . the times they are a-changin”

    Young should just get out of the way. He is our past, Obama is the face of our future.

  • Young saying Obama attended a Muslim school is not slanderous.

    To say it is implies negative connotations to being Muslim.
    Do we REALLY want to feed that ugly bigoted perception?

    Young is merely ill-informed. If he’s saying these things thinking it will harm Obama’s public standing, we may also properly address him as bigoted. At no point has he successfully smeared Obama except in the eyes of bigoted, ill-informed Americans. As such people typically vote Republican, this is unlikely to harm him in a Democratic primary.

  • Andy’s no longer firing on all cylinders but unfortunately still swings a lot of weight in Atlanta. His TV campaign ads for a very weak Democratic candidate for governor last year ensured the GOP landslide victory. A good friend needs to manage his public appearances.

  • Young has always been a gaffe machine. Carter made him U.N. ambassador and his mouth created one gratuitous controversy after another. The wonder is he’s still capable of getting attention these days.

  • Comments are closed.