New religious left group already under attack

That didn’t take long. The newly-formed Christian Alliance for Progress (which I mentioned the other day) held a launch event at the National Press Club yesterday. A few hours later, James Dobson’s Focus on the Family was already taking shots at the group for trying to be politically liberal and Christian.

Peter Brandt, senior director of issues response at Focus on the Family Action, said this attempt to dress the liberal agenda in the fabric of faith is a ploy that doesn’t sit well with conservatives.

“A wolf in sheep’s clothing is still a wolf,” he said. “Pushing the homosexual agenda, pushing for abortion rights — those things have nothing to do with the Gospel of Jesus Christ.”

What an odd response. Focus on the Family, an evangelical Christian ministry, has, in just the last few weeks, spoken out on estate taxes, the president’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform, Mohamed ElBaradei and the International Atomic Energy Agency, tort reform, and media coverage of the Deep Throat revelations. Maybe Focus can explain how any of these issues relate to the Gospel of Jesus Christ. Or maybe not.

Still, the fact that Dobson’s group felt the need to lash out at the Christian Alliance for Progress so quickly suggests the religious right is not altogether comfortable with the competition. If liberal Christians had an unpersuasive message, what would be the point of attacking?

For what it’s worth, it sounds like the group’s message is already off to a good start.

“The language spoken by the religious right is Christian. Our view is, this requires a Christian response,” said Patrick Mrotek, the group’s founder, at the National Press Club in Washington yesterday.

The alliance, based in Jacksonville, Fla., wants to go head-to-head with conservative Christian figures such as the Rev. Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson and James Dobson, arguing that the Gospel calls for liberal policies.

“Jesus said that your spirituality goes through the front door of your neighbor. If your neighbor doesn’t have health care and you’ve got it, you need to be working to see to it that the same advantage that has accrued to yourself also accrues to this other person,” said Rev. Timothy F. Simpson, the group’s director of religious affairs and a Presbyterian pastor. “That’s how you test your ethics, that’s how you test your spirituality.”

I have a hunch yesterday won’t be the last time Dobson & Co. lash out at these guys.

…you need to be working to see to it that the same advantage that has accrued to yourself also accrues to this other person…

They have got to put a little more punch in their message. I sentence Rev. Simpson to a weekend reading MLK’s speeches.

  • Dobson has to get a life – not everthing is about homosexuality or abortion right. I mean seariously if he doesn’t stop/slow down people might begin to wonder why he is so obssessed.

    I mean I am a more moderate Christian and heterosexual and don’t sit around thinking about how to advance the homosexuality and abortion rights all day every day. I am too busy trying to earn a paycheck.

  • I have a hard time even imagining an argument like this. Jesus got openly angry at two groups, the money-changers and the religious hypocrites (pharisees), i.e., today’s radical GOP. About taxes He said “render unto Caesar”. About gays and abortion (both of intense public concern in Hellenized Judea) he said nothing.

    He preached “love they neighbor” and “blessed are the peacemakers” and “the truth shall set you free”; He provided free food to the hungry (loaves and fishes) and clothing to the needy (offer him half your cloak); he healed the sick regardless of their ability to pay; he comforted the shunned and scorned, prostitutes and lepers; He was civil and kind toward women and children; and on and on and on.

    Can you imagine Dobson or Robertson or Falwell doing ANY of these things? or even admiring those who try to live up to Christian ideals? How in the hell do these bloated a-holes get away with calling themselves Christian? Why doesn’t someone (e.g., the press or even a single Democrat) take after them with a knotted rope and drive them from our Temple?

  • “Peter Brandt, senior director of issues response…” That’s quite a title. I wonder what the junior director of issues response does.

  • I do NOT believe that they are christians. I believe they are just a new way for republicans to get their way. These guy’s have all amassed personal fortunes imitating someone who cares.
    I’d say all they care about is their personal wealth.
    I say YEAH to the christian left for you are the TRUE christians!

  • I think it’s way past time to call these so called “christians” on what they are doing. The next time one of them says something, respond like this:

    You say that you are a Christian and yet you disobey Christ’s teachings.

    And then include which chapter and verse as appropriate (ie
    * Judge not lest ye be judged,
    * Let ye who are without sin cast the first stone,
    * Or how canst thou say to thy brother, Brother, let me cast out the mote that is in thine eye, when thou thyself beholdest not the beam that is in thine own eye? Thou hypocrite, cast out first the beam out of thine own eye, and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote that is in thy brother`s eye.
    * etc…

  • Can it be that the some of the Christian community that does not consist of frothing wingnuts and their lobotomized hordes is finally getting tired of being treated like a doormat and is at last finding the will to stand up and be heard? How delightful! More power to them.

  • Why do christians constantly try to push their silly ass religion on the rest of us?

    And I do mean SILLY read Genesis 3:1 about the “talking” snake. H-E-L-L-O… Can people really be that stupid?

    If christians, muslims, jews or whom ever want to believe in their silly false gods, prophets and fairy tales do so at one of the many thousands of churches across this once great country and stop bothering the rest of us.

  • TheAtheist: With all due respect – and I do respect your decision to be an atheist – please let’s not divide the left by calling those of us who are Christian “stupid”.

    Please note that the authors of the Bible wrote in metaphor, in poetry, history, etc. (ie the talking snake was a metaphor for human sin, greed, etc. Even Adam and Eve were metaphors, at least to some). Many people believe that the Bible must be correctly interpretted in relation to historical context as well as discerning what it means for us today (ie not for the people of its day). Above all, the words and actions of Jesus trump anything else that is written in the Bible.

    Jesus gave us two commandments: “Love God” and “Love one another as yourself”. I hope you can agree that the second is something that all of us on the left at least *try* to practice (difficult as it is at times). We agree that society is best when all of us are lifted up and taken care of – caring for our neighbors as ourselves.

    But think – if we *could* get the religious right to open their eyes to the lies and deceit of those they listen to, hey, they’d all be on *our* side! Am I dreaming? Maybe – but I think there are many who are becoming disenchanted with the hatefulness sprewed by Dobson, Perkins, etc.

    Hannah, unusually optimistic today

  • One more thing: the response by Dobson et al. is typical of the political and religious right. Anytime they are confronted with the truth, with disagreement to what they preach, they lash out, usually with their narrow talking points and with calling their opponents childish names.

    The problem for them is that the truth will always come out and the truth trumps lies and darkness. And eventually most people tire of hatefulness.

    They are bullies, and we should never stoop to their level.

  • Comments are closed.