This exodus isn’t going anywhere

We joke about the “Taliban wing” of the Republican Party, but the truth is there are very few Americans, even within the right wing, who literally want to replace our liberal democracy with a Biblically-based Christian theocracy. They do, however, exist — and they have a plan.

At a time when evangelicals are exerting influence on the national political stage — having helped secure President Bush’s reelection — Christian Exodus believes that people of faith have failed to assert their moral agenda: Abortion is legal. School prayer is banned. There are limits on public displays of the Ten Commandments. Gays and lesbians can marry in Massachusetts.

Christian Exodus activists plan to take control of sheriff’s offices, city councils and school boards. Eventually, they say, they will control South Carolina. They will pass godly legislation, defying Supreme Court rulings on the separation of church and state.

“We’re going to force a constitutional crisis,” said Cory Burnell, 29, an investment advisor who founded the group in November 2003.

“If necessary,” he said, “we will secede from the union.”

Now, I realize it may be tempting to tell these folks not to let the door hit them on the arse on the way out of the country, but there’s more to it than that. We’re talking about a group of people who want to turn South Carolina into a mini-Afghanistan.

Still, even if we put aside legal and practical concerns, I can’t help but wonder if these guys are all talk.

Every so often, some fringe group will announce a sweeping initiative whereby like-minded people will migrate to one location and launch a hostile takeover. It’s easier said than done.

A couple of years ago, it was hard-line libertarians who said they’d move to New Hampshire and set up a small-government utopia. The goal was to have 20,000 committed to relocating by 2006. How many have pledged to do so? About 6,600. How many have actually moved so far? About 100. The political establishment of the Granite State is not exactly feeling the effects.

Christian Exodus is poised to follow a similar path. A whopping total of five families have moved to South Carolina as part of this mass migration of fundamentalist theocrats. Burnell, the founder of the movement who’s talking about secession, still lives in Valley Springs, Calif. Hardly a good sign.

It’s not that I question their ability to force a constitutional crisis. If some communities in South Carolina decided stop following American law and start following a narrow interpretation of the Bible, they’d either have to secede or federal marshals would invariably have to go and tell these folks to knock it off.

But I’m pretty confident that they just won’t have the numbers.

Does anybody wonder what the South Carolina Jewish community is going to say?

  • Not only are these folks “all talk” — this whole idea is nothing but an incestuous masturbation fantasy for them. Hey– whatever turns you on, right?

  • If we dare them to leave, do you think that might help encourage them to get out of the country?

  • In many ways it’s best for the “worst” to happen. If Roe is overturned, conservatives cannot imagine the backlash. If a secession movement begins in certain states, the same is true….unless it ascends to majority level in those states, which is doubtful.

    I suspect that a worst case scenario for the U.S. is a transformation into a looser federation later on this century. I would welcome the donor states (blue) no longer supporting the recipient states (red) to the current degree.

    So please do force that constitutional crisis. Maybe we’ll get a truly proportional U.S. Senate.

  • I wasn’t going to blog today, but seeing this story changed my mind, CB.

    Check out their Website: http://www.christianexodus.org

    Also, check out their leader’s blog: http://www.christianexodus.org/blog/coryburnell.htm

    Apparently they think even the Christian Coalition isn’t conservative enough.

    And even though they haven’t said which upstate counties they want to take over, it’s obvious that one of them is Spartanburg County.

    But here’s the scary part–they could actually succeed in getting their lunacy pushed on county councils, if nowhere else. Upstate South Carolina is DEEEEEEEEEEP red–their leader wasn’t kidding when he said this region would vote for a corpse if it had an R next to it. I should know–this area is about an hour and a half from me. Both Jim DeMint and Lindsey Graham are from this area.

    As someone who lives near this area, I think they’ll succeed in making some noise at the county level, but they’ll be nipped in the bud before they get much further.

  • This is interesting stuff. Does anyone know why these exodus-people think that their experiment will turn out better than, say, that of the Puritans, Mormons, and hundreds of other US utopian communities that imploded or withered away?

  • I live in Greenville SC, one of their targets. This exodus group is planning a big conference here in October. Recently our local paper gave some coverage to this movement. The overwhelming response in the form of letters to the editor and “word on the street” from this conservative community, was “we may or may not have some similar values, but we don’t take strangers coming in and mucking around lightly.” I’m more concerned about our home grown dominionists Bob Jones University and the League of the South than the Christian Exodus. The local coverage here said only one family had moved here so far. Greenville is a beautiful and booming place, lots more “normal” people are moving here than fanatics.

  • Here in Whatcom County WA we’ve had at least three major efforts by nut groups to secede and form their own county. I can’t remember the third, but all the area northwest of Bellingham (eek! a university town) was to become Pioneer County, and all the area east of Bellingham (eek! a liberal city) wanted to become Independent County.

    These movements were coordinated by a PAC called the Keystone Forum, which was heavily laced with members of the Whatcom Chamber of Commerce and Industry. Many of them were members of the Whatcom Republican Party who had lost power as a result of a 1992 faction fight with Christian Right activists over the abortion issue in the previous year.

    In elections November 1993 the Keystone Forum got its slate of candidates elected to the Bellingham City Council and the Whatcom County Council. The one exception, Bellingham at-large, lost to the incumbent by a very narrow margin. Their success was due, largely, to the disorganization of the County Democratic Party, disorganization which was to begin to show nationwide in the 1994 elections.

    Just as it looked as though the nutcases might win the day, the WA Attorney General’s office issued its opinion that these new counties, if they could be formed, would have to pay their own way. They could not expect the City of Bellingham to fund the rural bumpkins as they have always done under the single-county arrangement.

    The independence movement collapsed over night and has never again been heard from.

  • Oh man, that’s rich. The libertarians couldn’t put their all-important money where their mouths are and move to NH.

  • If memory serves, they announced this over two years ago and so far they only have 1 family to show for it? That’s an awesome expression of how influential and supported their fundy movement is– it’s a joke.

    On the other hand, SC has enough of its own homegrown fundies to worry about.

  • If they we’re to suceed-and that’s a big if-while Bush was still in office, imagine the bind it would put him in. Does he act according to the law and upset his American Taliban base? Or, does he do nothing and upset rational Americans? It’s a choice he isn’t likely to face, but imagining him squirming over it sure is fun.

  • And even though they haven’t said which upstate counties they want to take over, it’s obvious that one of them is Spartanburg County.

    Do you think their first order of business would be to change the name of their county when they discover that Spartan culture encouraged gay relationships between older and younger men? They’d probably burn everything that had the word Spartan on it.

    What a pack of fools.

  • Gosh, wasn’t it South Carolina that fired the first shot of the Civil War? Wasn’t that whole thing about their right to secede from the Union? That piece of business didn’t end very well for them, did it?

    Of course, this time around I’d be inclined to let them leave, and save us all the bother.

  • Comments are closed.