George Allen’s Jewish ancestry — Day Three

Following up on yesterday’s item, I never would have expected the religious background of Sen. [tag]George Allen[/tag]’s (R-Va.) family to be of any interest whatsoever, but in the latest sign of a very clumsy campaign, the senator is dragging this story out a little more.

Virginia Sen. George [tag]Allen[/tag] (R) said for the first time publicly yesterday that he has Jewish ancestry, a day after responding angrily to an exchange that included questions about his mother’s racial sensitivity and whether his family has [tag]Jewish[/tag] roots. […]

In a statement released by his campaign yesterday, Allen said he was proud to have recently discovered that his grandfather, an anti-Nazi resistance fighter in North Africa, was part of a well-known Jewish family.

“I was raised as a Christian and my mother was raised as a [tag]Christian[/tag],” Allen, 54, said. “And I embrace and take great pride in every aspect of my diverse heritage, including my Lumbroso family line’s Jewish heritage, which I learned about from a recent magazine article and my mother confirmed.”

I have a hard time understanding why the Allen campaign is mishandling such a simple issue so poorly. Even the statement fudges the issue — Allen almost certainly didn’t learn about his Jewish ancestry “from a recent magazine article.” Josh Marshall noted, “[G]iven that Allen has long known that his grandfather (after whom he’s named) spent part of World War II in a Nazi concentration camp (or as Allen rather distantly phrases it, “was incarcerated by the Nazis”), it really does strain credulity to believe that the idea that he might be Jewish never crossed his mind.”

Moreover, TNR’s Ryan Lizza spoke to a veteran Virginia columnist in August who explained, “It’s funny, but the only time that George Allen ever wanted a correction from me in 27 years of covering his races was when I wrote about his mother’s Jewish family origins. He insisted, through a press secretary, that his mother was raised a Christian.” Just learned about his Jewish roots from a recent magazine article? I don’t think so.

But perhaps the strangest element of this story is how the Allen campaign is lashing out against everyone else, accusing reporters, writers, Dems, and critics of bigotry.

Yesterday, [Allen campaign manager Dick Wadhams] accused Webb’s campaign and liberal bloggers of anti-Semitism for raising the issue of the senator’s religious background.

Bloggers, some of whom are on Webb’s staff, spent yesterday writing furiously about the debate question and Allen’s answer. “What does Allen have against Jews?” one headline read on a national liberal blog.

“Introducing religion at all into the debate was inappropriate. It makes no difference what anybody’s religion is,” Wadhams said.

Wadhams also accused Webb’s campaign of mailing an anti-Semitic flier to Virginia voters during the state’s Democratic primary this year. That flier depicted Webb’s Jewish opponent, Harris Miller, with money coming out of his pockets.

“They have been continuing that anti-Semitic strategy through their paid bloggers,” Wadhams said.

First of all, the flier against Miller mocked his wealth, not his faith. Secondly, for the campaign of a confederate-flag-waving, noose-hanging, racist-befriending, macaca-smearing Republican to accuse anyone of bigotry is almost comical.

I’ve heard the buzz that Allen’s campaign manager, Dick [tag]Wadhams[/tag], is supposed to be the next Karl Rove-like genius of GOP politics. I have to say, at this point, I’m unimpressed.

I have to say, at this point, I’m unimpressed.

I don’t know . . . for a racist POS, I think this tack is somewhat brilliant. Think about it: assuming Allen sees racists as part of his base (and we have evidence of that from his photo-shoots), the only way to play the “I’m actually Jewish” card is to appeal to the other racist Southerner mantra: we’re victims. So, Allen says, “don’t pick on me” and “my grand-daddy on my mother’s side” and “I was raised Christian.”

Victim, mother’s “fault,” and born-again (in a sense). Seems to me he’s appealing to all the lower aspects of his base while simultaneously looking like the good guy from a progressive perspective.

Seems pretty clever to me. Dirty, shameful, and embarrassing, but clever.

  • The Allen campaign reaction seems to be typical Republican strategy — accuse the other side of your own failings. I have not seen the clip from the debate the other night, but reading the reporter’s question it did seem out of line. However, out of line questions are something that politicians get all the time. How they handle them often tells more about the candidate than the actual question.

  • when i was a boy my very italian and very catholic grandmother told me how her family had to flee spain after a relative got his head cut off and hung from a bridge. (this was in the, oh, sixteenth century?) i had to grow up and learn some world history before putting two and two together.

    allen runs history through his ego. he is a rank fool.

  • I think Webb is going to walk away with this one.

    Allen is not Bush and the reporters are going to dig, he just has way too much baggage. At every turn he has really screwed up, from the “I just made it up” to the “I read it in a magazine” non-sense.

    Looks like Wadhams is using Rove’s old play book. Those plays worked in the 90’s, but I just don’t see it working in Virginia in 2006. Just like I don’t see the swift boating business being as effective as it was in 2004. Once the play has been run, the opposition is ready for it and makes their plans accordingly. Rove’s genius has always been catching the other guy way off guard.

  • Consider the following:

    Once, there was a California sheep. This particular California sheep has grown up with the constant frustration that his California friends kept winding up on the dinner table of the Virginia wolves, who lived on the other side of the land, and he longed to be a Virginia wolf—thus placing him at the top end of the food chain.

    So, the California sheep got himself a Virginia wolf-suit, and moved to the other side of the hill.

    Everything went perfectly for this California sheep; every last one of the Virginia wolves believed him to be a prince among wolfdom—and they made the California sheep their leader, because wolves are notoriously dense, although some wolves can be much denser denser than others—South Carolina Fundamentalist wolves are renowned for being denser than concrete.

    But I digress, and thus return to the story.

    One day, a bird flew over the Virginia wolves, and saw a bit of wool sticking out from under the California sheep’s Virginia wolf suit. The bird asked with complete honesty: “When did you stop being a California sheep?” A few of the Virginia wolves heard this, and the camouflaged California sheep went to great lengths to deny the issue.

    The Virginia wolves passed the ramblings of the bird off as being just “the ramblings of a bird….”

    The next day, another bird flew over, saw a bit of wool sticking out, and asked the same question. This time, a couple of the Virgina wolves saw the wool as well, so the camouflaged California sheep angrily replied: “So what? I was raised a Virginia wolf—and anyway, this whole thing is the bird’s fault!”

    The Virginia wolves began growling quietly amongst themselves about “the California sheep who had supposedly been raised a Virgina wolf….

    Gradually, the day on which the Virginia wolves elect a new leader grew near. Wolves tend to do this every six years or so, while their domesticated counterparts such as poodles and chihuahuas—who were very finicky and always on edge—had evolved into thinking biannually. As the great day approached, instances of birds, squirrels, rabbits, and turtles asking this same question began to wear on the camouflaged California sheep, until one day, he stood up, took off his Virginia wolf suit, and declared before the world that he was proud to be a California sheep—and anyone who thought otherwise was a bigot.

    This did not play well with the “real” Virginia wolves—who were proud to be bigots—and they promptly fell on the California sheep, devoured him in a highly colorful bloodbath, and subsequently elected a groundhog as their new leader. This was based on the realization by the Virginia wolves that the groundhog, although not a Virginia wolf, was at least honest about who he was—and also a real Virginian….

  • as usual, the media conveniently leaves out allen’s mother’s french-tunisian heritage (hence, familiarity with “macaca”) virginia will accept a little jewish blood, as long as it’s been disowned, but the fluent french that allen speaks? never.

  • If I lived in Virginia, I’d already have decided to vote against this clown, and the “Jewish?” thing would just make me shake my head a little faster. On the other hand, if I were still on the fence or (God help me) already firmly in the Allen camp, it would be too complicated to figure out why anyone was excited about this latest dust up. I predict a net effect of zilch.

    BTW, after seeing their joint appearance on TV over the weekend, I can’t say I’d be in a frenzy to elect Webb, either. A “D” is a “D” but that D struck me as coming with an “ick” suffix.

  • I’m not an Allen fan, but I’m going to believe him on the finding out through a magazine one.

    What you may not understand is just how much some post-World War II Jewish refugees turned their backs on and denied their Jewish heritage. My grandfather did, and even with _knowing_ the stories, the fleeing from Germany, the cousins who migrated to Israel or Brazil, my mother and aunt still grew up totally and completely unaware. I guessed, but they only found out when the family was contacted for an article about wealthy Jewish families who fled Germany right before the outbreak of World War II. Even faced with the evidence, the family atmosphere of denial was so strong that they could not even conceive of being Jewish until shown documents. And then they had to try to figure out why their father had lied so hard to them.

    So I believe him on this one, which doesn’t mean that he isn’t running a very bad campaign.

  • “I have a hard time understanding why the Allen campaign is mishandling such a simple issue so poorly.” – CB

    Actually I think the Allen campaign is mishandling this issue pretty well, really. 😉

  • “However, out of line questions are something that politicians get all the time. How they handle them often tells more about the candidate than the actual question.” by MW.

    So, you can’t conceal yourself all the time. George might need time to do “soul-searching” first, not the Senator job.

  • Oh, I get it. It doesn’t matter that Allen didn’t bring up the Jewish ancestry issue. Somehow, even though Webb fingerprints are all over this, Allen is not only tarred as a liar but he’s also guilty of manipulating the issue for his political gain.

    And Webb gets off scot-free? Get real, gang. The reporter asked the Jewish ancestry question as a follow up to speculations by Webb’s paid bloggers as to where Allen could have come up with the term macacca.

    This is nothing but a predictably ugly extension of the macacca mob attack perpetrated on Allen by born-fighting-dirty Webb, the stalker that Webb appointed to harass him, the Washington Compost and all their MSM colluders, all of whom would offer up their first born for the hope of a Webb victory. Their motivation is that Allen orchestrated the successful dethroning of Lord Daschle by the upstart Thune.

    My wife and I live in Virginia, we voted for Allen at every opportunity, we contributed to his current campaign and we hope to do so again – even more so after all this hooey balooey about macacca and Jewish ancestry.

  • Keywords: When, Why and Identity.

    The reporter, or whoever she was, asked Allen “at what point” he disconnected from his true heritage. That was the bottom line of her question. Unfortunately, everybody has been focusing on the other words in her clumsy phrasing.

    Remember, Allen, in high school, flew a Confederate flag and has since donned cowboy garb. The reporter (like many people) wanted to know about his reasons for the disconnect.

    Unfortunately, Allen has never answered it. The point has been lost in the hoopla over his mom, grandpa and concentration camps. He is not required to answer it, of course, but the evasiveness does not make for an honest image.

  • I know little about Webb other than that he went to Vietnam, and that his son is in uniform, and that he is ten to one behind Allen in funds. I only know what I read about Allen, and he chose not to go to Vietnam; is just not too bright; wears cowboy boots when there are no cowboys in VA; and is a posture politician. Between Macaca and his clumsy dishonesty about his typically American mix of backgrounds, its clear that he is just another bufoon.

    Should he represent the Commonwealth of Virginia in the US Senate? He has, without distinction, and now its time for someone else.

    He’s had his chance. He is not a future-minded person, so he ought to walk away from his poorly considered ambitions of greatness in American civic life.

    Try football coaching at a local high school, George.

  • Nothing wrong with having Jewish ancetory.

    The problem is in the minds of those who having chosen
    to hide their Jewish ancestory.

    Most Jews are Democrats there are several Jewish senators.
    So one has to wonder who is really playing the anti-semitic card
    and why.

    I see it as a desparate attempt to salvage Allen’s campaign,
    after his macacca remarks and questionnable past.

  • Bottom line, it’s all about Macaca and whether or not Allen knew it was a racial slur when he hurled it at the young man. And it’s not at all a stretch to conclude that this North African slur was heard around the Allen household by young Georgie growing up.

    Bottom line, Allen intentionally called the young man the equivalent of America’s N-word – straight up, to his face, on camera, to the delight of his audience.

    If this is the kind of trash that Virginia wants representing them, then he’s the kind of trash Virginians deserve.

  • The problem is that he is on the senate floor, voting on issues beyond the borders of the Commonwealth. His low grade performance as an American adult should limit him as a dispatcher for a garbage hauling business (or some similar position for which clock watching and radio messsaging is the skill set, I assume), but he’s in our nation’s capitol, and that is a national issue.

  • George Allen needs some serious therapy to deal with his racism, confederate flag obsessions, violent infliction on his family with multiple beatings, domestic violence against women, his latent hatred for Jews, his latent hatred of himself (his Jewishness), having a hangman lynching noose in his law office used to kill blacks in this country, his abject lies to the press and the world, his cowardliness in the face of being stood up to, and his general dumb self.

    What a loser this guy is. He should not even be allowed to get coffee for American leaders, let alone be elected one.

  • Comments are closed.