A study in contrasts

Over the last two weeks, Bill Clinton and George W. Bush made separate trips to Vietnam. Let’s take a moment to compare and contrast, shall we?

Clinton was in Hanoi today, where he was swarmed by throngs of admirers seeking autographs, handshakes and photographs.

Clinton, in town to sign an agreement between his foundation and the Vietnamese to get more AIDS drugs to children, left the Hilton Hotel in the center of Hanoi, crossed an intersection buzzing with motorbikes, and strolled toward Hoan Kiem Lake, the spiritual heart of the city. […]

“I love you!” a young man shouted, reaching over the crowd for a handshake.

“There are no words to describe how happy I am,” squealed 17-year-old Nguyen Thu Hang, jumping up and down and clutching Clinton’s freshly signed autograph. “I’m going to frame this and hang it on my bedroom wall!”

Followed by Secret Service agents and Vietnamese police, Clinton stopped along a half-mile route to chat with his Vietnamese admirers before making his way to an art gallery in Hanoi’s Old Quarter and then to the tomb of Ho Chi Minh, who led Vietnam’s communist revolution.

After he and Health Minister Tran Thi Trung Chien signed the pediatric AIDS agreement, Clinton took part in a discussion about AIDS with several university students and a young woman living with HIV.

And then, there’s Bush, who was in Vietnam for four days during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit.

From the report out of Hanoi two weeks ago:

President Bush likes speed golf and speed tourism – this is the man who did the treasures of Red Square in less than 20 minutes – but here in the lake-studded capital of a nation desperately eager to connect with America, he set a record.

On Saturday, Mr. Bush emerged from his hotel for only one nonofficial event…. Mr. Bush’s national security adviser, Stephen J. Hadley, conceded that the president had not come into direct contact with ordinary Vietnamese, but said that they connected anyway.

“If you’d been part of the president’s motorcade as we’ve shuttled back and forth,” he said, reporters would have seen that “the president has been doing a lot of waving and getting a lot of waving and smiles.”

It’s probably safe to assume Bush won’t return to Vietnam in six years, swarmed by well wishes and screaming fans, on his way to cultural landmarks and chats with local people.

For all the concerns that Americans are no longer liked around the world, I sometimes think our stature will improve around, say, January 2009.

So Clinton stayed at the Hanoi Hilton ??

In all seriousness, Bush is so hated, his security risk has to be so high that even if he wanted to, he couldn’t realistically walk through the streets in New Orleans or Miami, much less a third world country never mind I keep forgetting that those place are third world countries.

But he is a man of the people, a fella I could have a drink with, or so they tell me.

  • Actually it might be wise not to let he world know the real George Bush. From what I’ve heard he’s personally kind of an asshole.

    George to Vietnamese, “How’s your dead kids?”

  • For some sad reason, I actually laughed out loud at “…the president had not come into direct contact with ordinary Vietnamese…”

    Direct contact?! *shudders* Of course not!

  • “Americans are no longer liked around the world”

    When I was in Italy last year I saw no evidence of anti-Americanism of any kind; in fact, the university students there (Padua) were very kind to us. I did see lots of “Fuck Bush” graffiti, much more than I’ve seen in this country unfortunately.

  • It’s both funny and painful. Bill Clinton can go anywhere in the world, walk the streets, and be mobbed by half a million people who only want to shake his hand or say hello. George W. Bush can’t “mingle” anywhere, even if he were to want to.

  • I sometimes think our stature will improve around, say, January 2009.

    I imagine it already did last month and will do so again November 2008.

  • Part of the contrast is that Boy George II would not want to get out and walk with people.

    As ScottW points out, the guy the Republican’ts claimed we’d like to have a beer with. Hell, I wouldn’t want to be in the same building with him.

  • I sometimes think our stature will improve around, say, January 2009.

    I imagine it already did last month — Allen K., @9

    Indeed it has. I correspod with quite a few people in Europe (not just my birth country of Poland) and I was swamped with congratulatory e-mails.

    I agree with Ed Stephan (@4) there’s no dislike of us, as *people*, at least not in Europe. But there’s a dislike of us as a *country*. And, even without active dislike, it can get pretty stale pretty quickly to have to keep answering questions like “how on earth did you manage to elect such a moron?”

  • Ed Stephan and Libra are both right. November 8, I got e-mail from all over the planet from people who know my politics (and are my friends because of them), saying “congratulations!”

    Americans aren’t disliked around the world. It’s America that’s hated around the world. With good reason.

  • Comments are closed.