Tuesday’s Mini-Report

Today’s edition of quick hits.

* Why is the GOP fighting a non-binding resolution with such intensity? Because the public relations involved with a presidential rebuke are awful.

* Speaking of which, the House will kick off its debate on a resolution against escalation next week.

* Following up on a post from the weekend, Texas Gov. Rick Perry (R) is standing firm “against a political firestorm generated by his order that sixth-grade girls be inoculated against a sexually transmitted virus linked to cervical cancer.” Perry told reporters yesterday, “Providing the HPV vaccine doesn’t promote sexual promiscuity any more than providing the Hepatitis B vaccine promotes drug use.” (Was Perry replaced with a sensible body-double?)

* If the major news networks could stop referring to Rudy Giuliani as “America’s Mayor,” I’d appreciate it.

* Chris Bowers makes the case that single-person political blogs are starting to die off as group blogs become more common and popular. I found this kind of depressing.

* The right has been worked up this week about Speaker Pelosi allegedly demanding a military aircraft to travel back and forth between DC and her home district in California. As is too often the case, the story is a crock.

* Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson invited Congress to offer an alternative to Bush’s budget, but insisted that lawmakers’ plan eliminate the deficit by 2012 and not raise taxes. (The budget process is likely to be a train wreck very soon).

* Muckraker: “What happened to billions in Iraqi funds that were overseen by the Coalition Provisional Authority? That’s not ‘important,’ according to David Oliver, the former Director of Management and Budget of the agency.”

* On a related note, the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee was all set to chat with Bush’s reconstruction coordinator in Baghdad to discuss possible waste and abuse in war funding. Then, all of a sudden, the State Department refused to let him appear.

* ABC News: “A line item buried in the president’s budget reveals the Bush administration is gearing up for emboldened legal challenges from Gitmo detainees. A brief paragraph in President Bush’s 2008 budget request shows he plans to hire nearly two dozen new Justice Department lawyers to fight suits brought by Guantanamo detainees challenging their imprisonment.”

* A new Gallup Poll finds Bush with a 32% approval rating, within one point of his all-time low. His approval rating on handling the Iraq war, at 26%, is now at its lowest point ever.

* Joe Klein seems to be having some trouble making friends in the blogosphere. In his latest spat, Klein is in a dust-up with Arianna Huffington, who clearly seems to have won the round.

* I suppose I should no longer be surprised by Joe Lieberman, but his fight yesterday with Sen. John Warner (R-Va.) over patriotism and support for the troops was breathtaking.

* Reader B.H. reminded via email that just about every Democratic presidential candidate praised Howard Dean’s 50-state strategy during their speeches at the DNC’s winter meeting. No word from James Carville on the development.

* And, finally, my very own congressman, Rep. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) became the first member of Congress to commit to reducing his office’s greenhouse gas emissions to effectively nothing. He’s “installing low-energy fluorescent bulbs, turning down the office temperature, and spending $672 of his own money to buy ‘carbon credits’ from two Vermont renewable energy projects that are part of an emerging business practice called carbon trading. In essence, the two Vermont projects will save the same amount of carbon dioxide emissions that Welch’s offices will produce, making his offices ‘carbon neutral.'” Good for him.

If none of these particular items are of interest, consider this an end-of-the-day open thread.

I’ve been heartily amused by the Joe Klein vs Arianna Huffington dust up.

Quick summary. Joe Klein is an asshole. Instead of saying, “At the time, I thought the war was right, blah blah blah. Now I’m wrong and I wish I didn’t support it…” he sez: “See I was right all along. The war sucks.”

Arianna called the turd on it after printing a few of his Kill Iraqis and Let Bush Sort’em comments. I guess he doesn’t understand that Google isn’t just a silly word anymore.

Repub Dick Armey has more of a spine than Jellyfish Joe ever will. Armey admitted he was wrong and wished he didn’t vote to authorize force.

  • Why is the GOP fighting a non-binding resolution with such intensity? Because the public relations involved with a presidential rebuke are awful.

    Well I hope the press brings that to fruition if it gets passed.

  • The right has been worked up this week about Speaker Pelosi allegedly demanding a military aircraft to travel back and forth between DC and her home district in California. As is too often the case, the story is a crock.

    The stories aren’t there so they’ve got to make them up.

    I was very pleased by your response to the David Broder piece today, CB. I wish more writers had joined you in it- awesome job.

  • I found this kind of depressing.

    I found it somewhat tedious and not very compelling in its arguments. YMMV.

  • IMO the dustup between Klein and Arianna is kinda stoopid. He has overplayed his prewar “opposition” to the war, and she has underplayed it.

    He gave a few links to some noise he made about the war drumming, here’s the best one I saw (from a Jan. 27, 2003 column):

    [Bush] will have to be honest about what comes next, after the inevitable military victory: the likelihood that large numbers of American troops will have to remain in Iraq for years to come. There should be no illusions about the difficulty of Mesopotamian nation building. It has been attempted on this same ground many times before, by many other superpowers, and none — none — has ever succeeded. The last to try was England. Winston Churchill, a superhawk hero of the 20th century, ran the occupation, saw the futility of it and favored retreat. “We are paying 8 millions a year,” he wrote his Prime Minister, David Lloyd George, in 1922, “for the privilege of living on an ungrateful volcano.”

    Of course Bush was NOT honest about anything, and Klein followed that article up with some truly stupid pro-war statements (by his own admission). So it’s a mixed bag.

  • Chris Bowers makes the case that single-person political blogs are starting to die off as group blogs become more common and popular. I found this kind of depressing.

    Like Bush says, the only way you can lose is to quit. 🙂 Plus there’s always room for the “last holdout.” As single-person blogs die off you’ll just be rarer.

  • In his newsletter for the Main Street Rag, the publisher of the literary journal, M. Scott Douglass, had a provocative take on Perry and the HPV vaccine:

    “Recently, Governor Richard Perry of Texas bypassed the state legislature and issued an executive order that requires all eleven and twelve-year-old girls to receive a newly developed vaccine for cervical cancer. There are so many things wrong with this that I’m not sure where to begin, but it doesn’t surprise me that the same state that produced our current president has a governor who believes he should be the ultimate decision-maker on a matter of such personal nature.

    “If he truly believes his decision is good for his constituency, why would he bypass public and legislative debate? It has only been the past decade when drug makers have conceded that vaccines that have been used for forty to fifty years have had terminal side effects for a certain percentage of patients. How can anyone trust that a vaccine this new will not have similar side effects? What happens if twenty or thirty years from now we find that one of the side effects is infertility or birth defects—even for a small percentage of recipients? This vaccine has not been studied long enough in humans to guarantee these things won’t happen. I’m not suggesting it be taken off the market, but for the state to mandate that every eleven and twelve-year-old girl get this vaccine is a violation of civil rights.

    “That said, why would Governor Richard Perry bypass his own legislative process to force-feed this on the public? You don’t suppose it has anything to do with money, do you? The fact that Merck, the vaccine’s developer, was a contributor to the Perry’s campaign or the fact that the group lobbying to have this law passed nationwide has Merck employees sitting on its board has anything to do with this procedural side-step?

    “This is why we need lobby and contribution reform. Privacy issues aside, decisions like this one should not be made without public input nor should they be made by people who have received donations from any person, organization or business that would stand to benefit from the law. I’m in favor of a law that says lawmakers who receive contributions from those who will benefit from a particular law MUST BE excluded from voting on that law. It will never happen since that would take money out of politicians’ pockets, but it would be the right thing to do.

    “So what does this mean for the future if state and federal courts allow laws such as this to be enacted? It could mean restricted access to medications for certain demographics. It could mean the state might some day assume the responsibility for telling young women when they are permitted to procreate and how many children they are permitted to bear before the state sterilizes them. Yes, I’m employing a Republican scare tactic, but prove me wrong. If this law is allowed to stand, what’s next? Which civil rights will state and/or federal governments decide are no longer a matter of personal choice? I’m not sure folks are paying enough attention here. I’m not sure the people of Texas know what precedence has just been set; what freedoms have just been stolen from them. And the rest of us may be next.”

    You may not agree with it all, but he certainly offers a lot of context and questions.

  • Joe Klein seems to be saying that since his prewar statements were inconsistent (though mostly prowar), we should give him credit for the ones that look good now and ignore the ones that don’t.

  • Re House resolution against escalation, the article states:

    “If you’re not for victory in Iraq, you’re for failure,” Boehner said. “The consequences of failure are immense. I think it destabilizes the entire Middle East, encourages Iran and on top of that it’s pretty clear that the terrorists will just follow us home.”

    The bottom line with Iraq is that it has had its successes and its failures. Successes include making the final determination that no WMD existed, removing Hussein and his sons, and providing Iraqis with a small shot at setting up their own government. These are areas where our troops could make a difference and successfully made a difference. However, the failures far outweigh the successes on any and every scale imaginable–a failed state, a “state” in chaos, a breeding gorund for terrorists and other undesirable activities, the continued loss of life, the destruction of the US’s reputation in the world, the loss of our position in the world as the human rights leader, destabilization of the regionand on and on. These failures were predicted many times before we went to war with Iraq, and these failures in these areas were the likely outcome regardless of the success of the military side of this. This is even more true considering the incompetents who brought us this war. And now the bottom line is that our military does not have any real or substantive goal or endeavor for which it can be deemed successful or to which it can apply its services to improve the current situation. They are now merely targets. Our successes are complete. Our failures are complete and can only be magnified from this point on. I guess my point is that comments like Boner’s are just simply wrong.

  • Thanks angry young man #7. I had some of those same objections to this. When you look a Republican gift horse in the mouth you often find it’s a Trojan horse. If politicians want to make medical decisions, let them start with universal health care.

  • This terrorists-as-lost-puppies nonsense is just an offshoot of the ridiculous (and immoral, if it worked) “flypaper” strategy. Who are all these terrorists that are attacking us in Iraq now but will “follow us home”, getting on a plane and coming to the United States, if we leave? Exactly what sort of people are we talking about?

  • Gov. Perry sez: Pay no attention to that Merck rep. behind the curtain!

    Were I cynical type I would wonder if Fuckus on the Fambly types are paid shills. They make a fuss which allows Perry to paint this as a progressive v. social conservative issue. The girls get their shots, Texas pays the bill, FotF gets a nice fat share of the proceeds. The girls can drop dead for all anyone cares.

    “Merck faces 9,200 lawsuits from plaintiffs who blame Vioxx, the $2.5 billion arthritis painkiller Merck pulled off the market in 2004, for heart attacks, many of them fatal. So far, Merck lost the first state case but won the second. The third case, in federal district court, was declared a mistrial. Merck has lost about a third of its stock value since the withdrawal.”

    But they’re not desperate to make up for that lost cash or anything.

  • Just like a main stream Repub or Beltway pundit, Klein wants to recieve better treatment for himself and his past than he is willing to give others. He makes a living trashing politicians, especially Dems.
    Where is his record of sticking up for the under dog?
    Where is his record of pushing back against Swift boaters and rumour mongers and gossip artists and mud throwers who have so poisoned the political arena?
    Where is his record of investigative reporting or even fact checking the Bush/Cheney/Rumsfeld assertions of the last six years?
    There may be a little but most of his work is just warmed leftovers, discussing issues only long after any controversy is dead and buried.
    What were his predictions of the 2006 election 6 weeks out and then 4 weeks out and then 2 weeks out? He was certainly on many panels and round tables in the preceeding weeks. I seem to recall a lot of hedging and a general down playing of any significant Dem success.
    Yet he is infatuated with his own ability to find minor flaws in others.

  • Wait a minute angry young man #7….To get ones child into school today they have to have a shot record…They must be vaccinated for various things…including tetnuas( I can’t spell…will try to find my dictionary) which isn’t catching like say Whooping cough. This is done in the interest of public health….so what is the problem with girls receiving a vaccine that will prevent ailments that will in most cases effect only the girl but could be caught by others interacting with her? What is the problem? In the case of the dpt vaccines that all children need plus polio there are ways to opt out…if the parent has a religious problem with the child having the vaccine, they can arrange that their child not get it. So why shouldn’t he make this vaccine mandatory? Why wait for a legislature to debate endlessly about health meansures that they know nothing about?
    This was a good move on his part…maybe his wife made him do it.

  • …debate endlessly about health measures….
    still can’t find the right spelling for blood poisoning.

  • * Chris Bowers makes the case that single-person political blogs are starting to die off as group blogs become more common and popular. I found this kind of depressing.

    CB, FWIW, I think quality will always prevail. Some blogs that I used to read regularly get only occassional visits from me now because the quality of the writing seems watered down. I worry that high-quality, single-blogger sites will fade away because I believe it has to be incredibly hard work to sustain a site with interesting posts day after day after day. But, I’m not interested in “drinking from the fire hydrant” that is some of the group sites. If you can maintain the pace and partner with quality writers when you need a vacation or have to be away, you will continue to be at the top of my blog list.

  • CB – On Chris Bower’s post at MyDD, I think Chris overlooked a number of things. Because the most viewed blogs are turning into multi-author or community blogs isn’t a bad thing. The workload has to become enormous to sustain a loyal readership and spreading the work around seems to be an evolutionary step for a nascent medium. Bowers was also looking at the big, national blogs and didn’t scratch the surface of the growth of local or regional bloggers. Just look at the impact of My Left Nutmeg on what was going on in CT. Then you get an inevitable shakedown after any boom where the best bloggers survive and others start doing something else.

    Bowers points to another ray of hope – the growth of reader participation in the comments section. Where did all the other bloggers and wannabe bloggers go? Just look at all the other bloggers posting in your comments section

  • “The right has been worked up this week about Speaker Pelosi allegedly demanding a military aircraft to travel back and forth between DC and her home district in California. As is too often the case, the story is a crock.”

    On AOL News, the headline is “Pelosi Demands Trump-like Travel” – the right has made this another “factual piece of news” with the MSM.

  • In a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention testimony before Congress in 2004, CDC Director Julia Gerberding cited statistics that estimated 50 percent of sexually active men and women will acquire a genital HPV infection at some point in their lives.

    The CDC’s website states 80 percent of women will acquire HPV by age 50, according to a 2000 study published in the Journal of Epidemiology.

    HPV

    HPV (human papillomavirus) is a virus that is common in the United States and around the world and can cause cancer and genital warts. HPV is spread through sexual contact. There are about 100 types of HPV. HPV is the major cause cervical cancer in women and is also associated with several other types of cancer in both men and women.

    HPV is the most common sexually transmitted infection in the United States. At least 50 percent of sexually active people will get HPV at some time in their lives. Every year in the U.S., about 6.2 million people get HPV. HPV is most common in young women and men who are in their late teens and early 20s.

    HPV

    I’m in agreement with Joan, above.

  • Why is the GOP fighting a non-binding resolution with such intensity?
    Right after the Nov elections, the repubs seemed gleeful that they could now blame (or at least share the blame with) the Dems for their Iraq quagmire.. Now it looks like they still want to horde the entire debacle to themselves. Let them. They’ve put themselves in a box, which they’ve painted into a corner. Their last line of defense seems to be that the evil Dems saw what they were doing was stupid and would do nothing to stop them, so it’s all the fault of the Dems.

    I realize the repubs have no good options, but this tactic seems to be the one that will hurt them the longest. The war continues to lose support. Prolonging it and their near exclusive association with it strikes me a slow motion suicide.
    Only a couple years ago, the repubs rarely missed in their political calculations. Now they can’t even walk and chew gum. I guess the lesson here is that when a political movement turns into a cult of leader worship, the movement and the cult come to resemble their leader. Either that, or whatever is wrong with Bush is contagious.

  • Joan @14,

    thanks for taking the time to point out that vaccinations are a different animal when it comes to public health and the political process. I doubt that angry young man or Dale will bother to respond, but I appreciate your adding a valuable perspective.

  • “Why is the GOP fighting a non-binding resolution with such intensity? Because the public relations involved with a presidential rebuke are awful.”

    You think the PR of a rebuke would be bad, wait until you have to defend your vote for the surge in 2008.

  • Tom – that’s old data. The cases against Merck have gone decently well for Merck (they are taking every one to verdict and no class action certifications). Merck’s stock has nearly doubled in the past 18 months.

    I’m sure it will go up more if Perry has his way….

  • hey, edo, can’t a brother get some love?

    personally, i agree with joan: i think kids should get the vaccination for the same reason kids get measles shots (and used to get small pox shots): because they might give it to someone else, forget that they might get it. and if kids don’t want to get it for “religious” reasons, they can have their classes at home.

    the two points that douglass makes that strike me most are:

    1. should a government official, beholden more to a pharma donor than his constituency, be able to force everyone in a political district to use that donor’s product at the public’s expense? what if he made them use an inferior product or less reliable vaccination for cost-based reasons?

    2. what happens when an official uses the same methods as the texas governor to proscribe girls from coming to school while on the pill because that offends his christianist backers? they already drug test in some schools. you can get suspended now for having an aspirin. birth control is a drug. how’s it any different?

  • Did you hear the sanctimonious line of shit that Mitch McConnell tried to slip by us? “We welcome debate…” Then why did he vote against it?

    Speaking of right wingers, if you hate the Scientologists as much as I do, then you’re going to love this post about one of the most extraordinary examples of reverse religious persecution that you’ll ever read anywhere.

    Imagine being forced to go on the run for 7 years because you made a pun about Scientologists?

  • Steve…. you do an amazing job here (mostly) by yourself, day-in and day-out, always interesting and relevant. CB is a keeper, wherever it is now or wherever it may be tomorrow.

    And let’s not forget that Steve is also the editor of Salon’s The Blog Report (Time to update the link to reflect the blog’s new name.)

    (You live in Vermont??? Why was under the impression that you lived in suburban D.C.?)

  • ….so what is the problem with girls receiving a vaccine that will prevent ailments that will in most cases effect only the girl but could be caught by others interacting with her?

    Data: There isn’t enough of it re the effect of this drug on anyone, much less adolescents and pre-ads.

    History: Tells us that given the choice between making a fast buck and doing thorough research (especially where women are concerned) pharm companies go with the fast buck.

    And that isn’t even getting into the whole who’s in bed with whom and the current legal troubles of the company that benefits in this particular instance. Oh yes. Condoms can help reduce the risk of HPV but you don’t see Perry handing those out to kids.

    Perhaps I’m scaremongering but this thing involves too many creatures I have reason to distrust: Large corporations, ReThuglicans and polititians from Texas. The horror. The horror!

  • “…America’s Mayor…”

    The “America’s Mayor” crown is as much of an artificial, PR construct as McCain’s “maverick.” And while MediaMatters is on the right track, even they don’t go back far or deep enough.

    Voters need to hear from real New Yorkers about what kind of mayor Giuliani was before “America” even knew his name.

    If a few voters in Florida had known what a lot of Texans knew about GWB, he would have been the one sent home in 2000. I know some Texans did try, but I don’t recall them ever gaining much traction.

  • Hey, what about Waxman asking Bremmer about the missing money? You gotta love headlines with the phrase “Giant Pallets of Cash”.

    99 pallets of cash on the plane
    99 pallets of cash.
    Take one down, pass it around,
    98 pallets of cash on the plane!

  • To get a handle on how much the Iraq war has cost this nation, in monetary terms, here’s a snippet from Henry Waxman’s hearings on Iraq war fraud and waste: “Waxman also questioned the wisdom of sending billions in cash to Baghdad – 363 tons of bills, sent in enormous pallets via military planes and passed out from the back of pickup trucks.”

    If you want to see how much this war has lightened our collective wallets, try 363 tons of Benjamins shipped over to Baghdad. That over 100 tons more than the Statue of Liberty weighs. F-ing disaster. And Repubs don’t seem the slightest bit concerned.

  • If Bowers is right, and I don’t know that he is, I am less likely to participate. Too much chaos.

  • Chris Bowers makes the case that single-person political blogs are starting to die off as group blogs become more common and popular. I found this kind of depressing.

    The problem is that a single person often can’t keep up with politics and news. Blogs require so much updating that unless you do if full time or have help, it’s impossible to compete.

    As peterado @ #17 points out, that could lead to increased comments all over the blogosphere. Not a bad thing.

    It’s also why I’ll let mine expire soon. But that’s okay.

  • Comments are closed.