ABC criticizes ‘left-leaning documentaries,’ won’t share right-leaning docudrama

Sorry to keep harping on this issue, but the more we learn about [tag]ABC[/tag]’s “[tag]The Path to 9/11[/tag],” the bigger a problem it is. For example, this morning we learned that former President [tag]Clinton[/tag]’s office requested a copy of the docudrama. ABC said no. Former Secretary of State Madeleine [tag]Albright[/tag] and former National Security Adviser Samuel [tag]Berger[/tag] also requested copies of the film. ABC turned them down, too.

In the broader context, ABC, which claims to be airing an “objective” look at the terrorist attacks, has offered advanced copies of the movie to right-wing [tag]bloggers[/tag] and Rush [tag]Limbaugh[/tag], but when top former officials, including the former [tag]president[/tag] of the United States, specifically request a copy, the network is suddenly shy. By one estimation, ABC distributed 900 copies — but it doesn’t have one for Clinton?

This isn’t Fox News; we’re talking about ABC. If there’s a reasonable explanation for the network’s decisions on this project, I can’t think of it.

On a related note, following up on an insightful comment from a thread yesterday, Lou reminded me of an ABC report on Monday about filmmaker [tag]Robert Greenwald[/tag]’s documentary, “[tag]Iraq for Sale[/tag]: The War Profiteers,” which debuts in limited release this week. ABC told viewers:

Critics of these kinds of documentaries remind viewers not to expect balance from left-leaning documentaries, such as Michael Moore’s “Fahrenheit 9/11” and former Vice President Al Gore’s global warming film, “An Inconvenient Truth.”

“Finally, the left has figured out their answer to talk radio — and it’s documentaries,” said Prof. Richard Lichter of George Mason University.

Yes, ABC wants its viewers to be careful about political movies that lack the appropriate “balance.”

The irony is rich.

It would seem that the ‘fix’ from the FCC is in and very blatant.

  • It’s time to take names. It’s time to punish “the bottom line” of all of the $#%%^&^&^## advertisers that support this propagandic crap. I urge everyone to watch the beginning and end and other junctures, and TAKE THOSE CORPORATE NAMES DOWN. It’s time for those from Corporate America who participate in supporting this slime to feel some pain.

  • ABC, in my opinion, has shown its colors over the last 3 or 4 years, and as each year goes by it moves further and further right.

    I would like to know if this is because of Republican’t supporters in the executive ranks or if this is “programming” that some execs thought might pull more (right-wing) viewers in to boost ad revenue, or some combination of the two?

  • I find it especially interesting that this “mockumentary” is based around the career of John P. O’Neill, the FBI counterterrorism expert who conveniently enough for the purposes of the producers is dead (killed in Tower 1, ironically) and hence in no position to object or correct. A film centered around, say, Richard Clarke would look, uh, somewhat different – and somewhat more accurate, since Clarke is still alive to complain.

    Attacking ABC, the fascists who run Disney (which owns ABC), and the sponsors of this piece of shit is the way to go.

  • Look, people can make as many “right-leaning” documentaries as they want. They just need to stop lying! I don’t care if the truth makes some random liberal or Democrat look bad. Just don’t lie about it or pretend there isn’t a political angle to it. Jeez.

  • Would it hurt Clinton, Albright, Berger et alii to become just a tad more outspoken than they have been? What about the DNC, the elected Democrats, some noted (and quoted) historians? Politics ain’t bean bag. Or is that mantra dead, too?

  • So where is the liberal media? CBS is running a real documentary. NBC? Probably a two hour special on Brian Williams boyhood home and how his god overcam cancer. FOX (network not NEWS) where is their counter punch? Don’t they have 101 greatest train wrecks? This is bushit!

    “Finally, the left has figured out their answer to talk radio β€” and it’s documentaries,” said Prof. Richard Lichter of George Mason University

    Hmmm…I don’t recall Michael Moore or Al Gores’ movies airing in prime time on free TV.

    God I hope this backfires on them.

  • Is the documentary going to have George W. leading the flight assault on Bagdhad like Tom Cruise in “Top Gun”? Or is he going to sit atop one of the lead tanks in the invasion of Baghdad like Michael Dukakis famously did in his photo op?

  • Keep harping, CB. The only way this kind of corporate/government propaganda is going to stop is through exposure. Since Americans can’t rely on traditional media, this is where it needs to be talked about.

    Besides, the timing is right. This show is going to appear in a couple of days and it would be great if a sizable number of people realized in advance that they’re being shown a biased, politically movitated piece on the anniversary of a national tragedy.

  • We have lived through many years when the right could shield themselves and the public from any viewpoints that countered their interests by merely labeling them as originating from the left or from liberals. Entrenched powers in Washington, the media and corporate globalists have utilized these labels effectively by what appears to be a unified voice at times. There seems to be a vigorous concerted effort now to flag the “lefty” bloggers and the “left” movie producers with the tag, “just like Mike” (Moore), while letting the right spread their blatant propaganda as fair, balanced and free of attached qualifiers. So, we’ll be hearing a lot of “consider the source” when the left tries to advance their message, no matter how truthful, just or urgent.

  • The Scholastic teacher materials that support school Path to 9/11 discussions are available on the web. All districts need to be questioned about their position on using this crap in the classroom. No district left behind..the Dems need to mobilize a national effort to make the point that the media is selling a Republican documerical as fact to the schools.

  • What’s going on, as Digby pointed out, is that Disney has gone to bed with the Christian Right. The fact is, the studio needs a “tent pole” series (like Star Wars was for 20th Century Fox or Star Trek for Paramount), and they have decided the Narnia series is it. The movie was produced by far right Christian Philip Anschutz and was a huge hit with the Christian Right. They want to keep them on their side, and doing this (even spending $40 million of their own money and broadcasting without commercials to make it back) is just an investment in several future $200 million domestic gross (close a billion worldwide so far for the first one) movies. As with everything Hollywood, it’s all about the joyful sound of ringing cash registers. Like Dylan said, “money doesn’t talk, it swears.”

    Lenin was right that the last two capitalists would fight each other over who would sell the rope for their hanging.

  • When it comes to right-wing moneybags, Philip Anschutz is right up there with Richard Mellon Scaife. Enough said?

  • Would it hurt Clinton, Albright, Berger et alii to become just a tad more outspoken than they have been?

    In their defense, they don’t really know what they would be outspoken about since they haven’t seen the miniseries yet. If they see it and feel that parts of it are untrue, it would then be appropriate to blanket the airwaves with denunciations.

  • When it comes to right-wing moneybags, Philip Anschutz is right up there with Richard Mellon Scaife. Enough said

    Those two are, like Paris Hilton, a primo argument for a confiscatory inheritance tax. Not necessarily job one, but right up there when we get back in power along with reinstating the Fairness Doctrine.

  • I wonder if one reason they won’t give Clinton, et al a copy of this fakeumentary is so they won’t have time to file suit and get an injunction over it’s obvious lies and falsehoods prior to it going on the air?

    Here’s hoping they’ll sue them *after* it errs. They’re depicting real people saying fake words. Isn’t that considered slander and/or libel under the law?

  • I think that Clinton, Albright and Berger are talking to their lawyers regarding libel. Is it just me?

    I sure as hell would. If the filmakers want to make a FICTIONAL 911 blaming Libs, fine with me (I’d never see it, but that’s a matter of taste.) Since they are passing this off as FACT then it’s the lawsuit time with damages in the millions especially if the FACTs the “writer” used have already been debunked in public domain.

    Such thing as libel and slander.

    Sometimes, a lawyer is a useful thing to have… WTF? Pardon me while I wash my mind out with Javex…

  • Do we know if there will be any material embarrassing to Bush, or are we just assuming?

    If they include a dramatization of Bush’s “OK, you’ve covered your ass” upon receiving the Osama PDB, wouldn’t you be cheering?

    I mean, six hours is a lot of time for nothing but Clinton-bashing.

  • My question: Where is George Stephanopoulos — chief Washington correspondent, after all — in all this?

  • CB: Sorry to keep harping on this issue

    don’t be — it most needs telling to those offline, who only get corporate media news. cause y’never know. independent thinking might just be the new black, especially now.

  • If that many copies went out, surely SOMEONE will supply Clinton et al with a copy.
    Could some of the bloggers encourage this?
    Hopefully Jon Swift got one. Or perhaps the General…
    I am sure that this will happen.

  • i wonder whether this movie rises to the level required to claim “libel” against the producers.

  • This may be too many degrees of seperation, but doesn’t Steve Jobs, CEO of Apple Computers have some serious pull with Disney? And isn’t Al Gore on Apple’s board? Apple is making Disney serious bank, so why aren’t Steve and Al angry about this?

  • All throughout this controversy many people are missing one very important point. Sure, one can muddy the water in the blame game, and maybe there was more that Clinton could have done, although God’s own party would have howled GRANDSTANDING! but thats not the point that the undeniable liberal wants to make.
    On 9-11, and for many years before that, it was standard procedure to intercept any aircraft that turns off its transponder, goes off course, or loses contact. A year or so before 9-11 (that changed everything) golfer Payne Stewart’s jet lost contact and veered off-course. Within 15 minutes, combat jets were on his planes wingtips, which is standard procedure in such a case.
    So just a few questions:
    WHERE WERE THE INTERCEPTORS ON 9-11? (they certainly had more than 15 minutes to respond)

    WHY HASN’T SOMEBODY BEEN DRAWN, QUARTERED WATERBOARDED AND SENT TO CAMP GITMO FOR THAT MASSIVE FAILURE?
    Was THAT Clinton’s fault too?

    It’s time to boycott the sponsors of this movie. And it’s time to let ABC Disney that WE THE PEOPLE are tired of this propaganda Bush glorifying bullshit.
    Think progress has a helpful email tool .

    It’s about damn time that WE THE PEOPLE take back our country.

  • Answering my own question from comment #19, Editor & Publisher has this to say:

    “But what about the famous Aug. 6, 2001 PDB that warned the president about bin Laden’s determination to strike within the U.S.? We see Secretary Rice reading it in private and looking concerned, but we never see the president’s reaction.”

    The rest of the summary is here:
    http://www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003087654

    Based on that summary, it looks like Bush doesn’t get nearly as much attention as Clinton. Indeed, part 1 covers 1993 through 2000, while part 2 covers 2001.

    Oddly, the Clinton admin is criticized for balking at the (fictitious) Osama-grab because the intelligence is too sketchy; but later they are criticized for bombing the Sudanese pharmaceutical factory because of… sketchy intelligence. Which is it?

  • Undeniable Liberal: It’s time to boycott the sponsors of this movie. And it’s time to let ABC Disney that WE THE PEOPLE are tired of this propaganda Bush glorifying bullshit.
    Think progress has a helpful email tool .

    It’s about damn time that WE THE PEOPLE take back our country.

    fuckin-A, dude.

  • For the record, here was this blog’s comment on CBS spiking “The Reagans” on November 4, 2003:

    “They’ve now succeeded in trashing a program that they’ve never even seen because they suspect it might paint an unflattering picture of their deity.
    …the GOP’s conniption over the show suggests that they’ve completely lost their perspective on reality.”

    Let us now reflect on how the present situation is completely, utterly different.

  • Regarding comment #16: yes, the blog is back up, with this statement about posts:

    “Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.”

    Take a look through the comments and you’ll see the result of that policy.

  • Sullivan v. New York Times protects this piece of drivel and prevents any of the Clinton Administration from suing for libel – though this thing certainly walks and quacks like a libellous duck. For those who don’t know the case, Sullivan holds that a “public figure” cannot sue for libel, since commentary on that figure and their actions is “fair comment” under the First Amendment.

  • Tom Cleaver- I know the comments are moderated, but I’m hoping that they are still monitored and tabulated by ABC. It’s also great fun to have the chance to speak directly to the slimers oops, I mean creators of the series.

  • Hi all,
    It seems this is not just a US problem. This docudrama (Republican propaganda program) is going to be aired globally! This is how it’s being promoted in Australia:
    “The Path to 9/11 – For the first time… the story of exactly what happened…” and “… Official true story…”!!
    It will be shown on the free-to-air Channel 7 in Australia. Here is a Flash video of the promo:
    FEATURED: The Path to 9/11
    It also seems that Scholastic is behind this also. They have developed a Social Studies Teachers study guide for grades 9 to 12, that will be used in classrooms throughout the USA to help promote this Republican propaganda garbage!
    9/11 Discussion Guide for ABC Miniseries
    I have an extensive, ongoing blog about all this here (with all credits where due):
    The truth about the (rightwing orgasmic fantasy film) Path to 9/11
    So, essentially, the Republicans are trying to convince the entire World that 9/11 was all Clinton’s fault, and Bush did everything he could and is a great guy. Yeah.
    This is a Global problem now! The more that learn the truth, the better.
    Cheers. πŸ™‚

  • OK, here the names, titles and email addresses for a number of key senior Disney decision makers I found, starting at the top
    with the CEO and board of directors are at the bottom.

    Let’s make our voices heard and see if we can get these guys to pull this blatantly obvious Bush propaganda. ABC may profit from the predictable controversy but airing a film designed to obfuscate Bush’s responsibility for 9/11 will cause ABC to suffer greatly in the estimation of serious people.

    Disney and ABC should leave the RNC propaganda to Fox, it’s not ABC’s demographic.

    Robert Iger – CEO – robert.a.iger@disney.com

    Rich Ross – President of Disney Channel Worldwide – rich.ross@disney.com

    Sean Cocchia – VP/Business Development, Disney Channel Worldwide- sean.cocchia@disney.com

    Gary Marsh – Disney Channel Worldwide President of Entertainment – gary.marsh@disney.com

    Sarah Shelton – Assistant to Gary Marshsarah – shelton@disney.com

    Scott Garner – SVP/Programming, Disney Channel – scott.garner@disney.com

    Karen Myer – Assistant to Scott Garner – karen.myer@disney.com

    Meredith Metz – Senior Vice President, Creative Affairs, Walt Disney Television Animation – meredith.metz@disney.com

    Lisa Salamone – The Head of Animation Production, Disney Channel – lisa.salamone@disney.com

    Joanna Spak – The Head of Finance, Planning, etc., Disney Channel – joanna.spak@disney.com

    Mark Kenchelian – The Head of Business and Legal Affairs, Disney Channel -mark.kenchelian@disney.com

    Jewell Engstrom – CFO and Executive VP for Disney-ABC Cable Group – jewell.engstrom@disney.com

    Olivia Stafford – Assistant to Jewell Engstrom – olivia.stafford@disney.com

    Albert Cheng – EVP/Digital Media, Disney-ABC Television Group – albert.cheng@disney.com

    Karen Hobson – Digital Media Communications Office, Disney-ABC Television Group – karen.hobson@disney.com

    George Bodenheimer – Co-Chairman Media Networks Group – george.bodenheimer@disney.com

    Nicole Nichols – Senior VP of Entertainment Communications, Disney-ABC Television Group – nicole.nichols@disney.com

    Aime Wolfe – Assistant to Nicole Nichols – aime.wolfe@disney.com

    Patti McTeague – VP of Kids Communications – patti.mcteague@disney.com

    Siobhan Kenny – Acting Head of International Communications – siobhan.kenny@disney.com

    Paul Lee – ABC Family Channel – paul.lee@disney.com

    Annie Fort – ABC Family Media Relations – annie.fort@disney.com

    Alex Wallau – President of Network Operations & Administration – alex.wallau@disney.com

    David Westin – ABC News President – david.westin@disney.com

    Mike Shaw – ABC Sales and Marketing President – mike.shaw@disney.com

    Fred Kuperberg – Disney/ABC Executive VP of Business and Legal Affairs – fred.kuperberg@disney.com

    Kara Rousseau – VP of Ad Sales Marketing for Disney/ABC Kids Networks – kara.rousseau@disney.com

    Kim Harbin – Buena Vista Media Relations – kim.harbin@disney.com

    Anne Gates – Disney Consumer Products Executive VP & CFO – anne.gates@disney.com

    James Fielding – Senior VP, Retail Sales and Marketing for DCP – james.fielding@disney.com

    Deborah Dugan – President of Disney Publishing – deborah.dugan@disney.com

    Graham Hopper – Senior VP and General Manager of Buena Vista Games – graham.hopper@disney.com

    Angela Emery – Director of Public Relations, Buena Vista Games – angela.emery@disney.com

    Chris Bess – Buena Vista Home Entertainment – chris.bess@disney.com

    Peter Murphy – Senior Adviser to Mr. Iger – peter.murphy@disney.com

    Judy Estrin – Board of Directors – jestrin@packetdesign.com

    John Bryson – Board of Directors – john.bryson@edisonintl.com

    Monica Lozano – Board of Directors – monica.lozano@laopinion.com

    John Chen – Board of Directors – john.chen@sybase.com

    Gary Wilson – Board of Directors – gary.wilson@nwa.com

    Leo Odonova – Board of Directors – leo.odonovan@mbna.com

    Thomas Staggs – CFO/Senior V.P. – tom.staggs@disney.com

    David K. Thompson – Senior Vice President – David.K.Thompson@disney.com

  • Well, things are happening fast and furious on this! πŸ˜€

    Looks like we have one victory! It appears that Scholastic has taken down the web page promoting their educational program for this Republican Propaganda production! However, it remains to be seen if they will still distribute this material or not! They haven’t made any announcement yet.

    The All Spin Zone blog is keeping an eye on this here, and were the first to break the Scholastic involvement story (as far as I am aware)! Thanks guys! πŸ˜€
    BREAKING: Did Scholastic Yank ‘Path to 9/11’ Propaganda?

    And I can’t thank Think Progress enough for all they are doing about this! Awesome work! πŸ˜€

    And also Media Matters! They have the (currently working) links to the Scholastic materials (in PDF format). I have a copy, You should all grab a copy. Just in case! πŸ˜‰
    ABC-Sponsored teaching materials falsely suggest Iraq had WMD, link War in Iraq to 9/11

    And of course, my thanks to The Carpetbagger Report! Thanks guys! πŸ˜€

    Thanks for those eMail addresses Lucid Analysis. πŸ™‚

    Cheers all! One down… πŸ˜‰

  • It is going to sting big time when this airs, no doubt about it – but the right awakens the sleeping giant that is bubba at their peril – heaven forbid this forces Pres. Clinton from to have to take a higher profile on the campaign trail the next six weeks to defend himself …..Given the Bush Admin record of failure, it’s kind of a mixed blessing to have Clinton called out like this in the middle of an election season….. Cause all that deference to the current Pres by ex-presidents starts to go out the window……ABC may not be doing the big favor for Bush that now seems so……Of course, that may be reaching for whatever shard of optimisim may be left out there……

  • Comments are closed.