An odd response to ugly racism and anti-Semitism

We’ve all seen some nasty primary fights, but I can’t think of any recent examples that got as ugly as the fight in Tennessee’s 9th congressional district. The Memphis-area district has a majority African-American population, but recently elected Rep. Steve Cohen (D), who is white and Jewish.

His opponents in the area are now distributing a shocking flier, painting Cohen as a Jesus-hater.

“Memphis Congressman Steve Cohen and the JEWS HATE Jesus,” blares the flier, which Cohen himself received in the mail — inducing gasps — last week.

Circulated by an African-American minister from Murfreesboro Tenn., which isn’t even in Cohen’s district, the literature encourages other black leaders in Memphis to “see to it that one and ONLY one black Christian faces this opponent of Christ and Christianity in the 2008 election.”

Cohen’s main opponent in the August 5 Democratic primary in his predominantly African-American district is Nikki Tinker, who is black. The Commercial Appeal wrote an editorial in Wednesday’s paper condemning Tinker for not speaking out against the anti-Semitic literature.

“What does Nikki Tinker think about anti-Semitic literature being circulated that might help her unseat 9th District Congressman Steve Cohen in the Democratic primary next August?” the editorial asked. “The question goes to the character of the woman who wants to represent the 9th District, and 9th District voters deserve an answer. But Tinker declined to return a phone call about the flier.”

When reader D.L. first alerted me to this story, my first thought was, “How disgusting.” At no point did it occur to me to think, “I wonder what Barack Obama thinks about this.”

But Instapundit’s Glenn Reynolds can be an odd duck sometimes.

His post, which accurately described the bigoted flier as “rank anti-Semitism,” added:

Well, that just makes everybody look good. Jeez. I like Steve Cohen a lot, and not just because he once gave me some absolutely amazing John Fogerty tickets (to the Mud Island show that was his first appearance after a decade of not touring). But even if I didn’t, this would be absolutely disgraceful. Perhaps Barack Obama should make a point of condemning this.

Glenn was doing just fine until that last sentence.

As far as I can tell, there’s absolutely no connection whatsoever between Obama and that crazed Murfreesboro minister distributing this ugly flier, except that they’re both black. Glenn’s argument seems to be that Obama “should make a point of condemning this” because an African-American preacher is doing something stupid.

But that’s ridiculous. As Brad at Sadly, No put it, “[W]e can all see where this game is headed, no? Every week, the Ole Perfesser will find some black guy somewhere who said something crazy and remark darkly about how ‘disturbing’ he finds it that Obama hasn’t come out and denounced him yet. As in, ‘If Obama really wanted to be a racial healer, he’d let people know that he doesn’t support sexually harassing female employees like Isiah Thomas does. Heh!'”

I can only hope the opposite is also true. Can we all agree, right now, that John McCain should be encouraged to condemn every stupid thing said by white, right-wing ministers between now and the election?

It’s not that the comments were anti-Semitic; it’s that they implied that the most important qualification for office is who’s more Christian (which automatically rules out non-Christians).

  • Reynolds comments are not ridculous C.B. Here’s the jist of it.

    Don’t focus on the crazy Preacher. Focus on Cohen. We have few progressive libs in elective office in the South. Cohen is a stellar guy.

    Barack should absolutely stop by and campaign for Cohen before the primary.

    If you know Memphis and if this preacher is trying to divide dems by religion and race, this is an easy call.

    Of course Barack does not have to respond everytime an Isaah Thomas (f)s up.

    But I think you are really missing the point here.

  • I think what Instaputz is saying is that he wants us to send him a copy of all the bad things white people say, so that he can denounce them. /snark

    More seriously, I think there’s another interesting thing about this episode:

    The editorial also noted that last summer Cohen came under attack from black ministers who challenged the congressman’s support for federal hate crimes legislation to protect gay rights. The paper wrote that the “real motive” behind the ministers’ attacks was revealed later by Rev. Robert Poindexter who, according to the Commercial Appeal, said of Cohen: “He’s not black and he can’t represent me, that’s just the bottom line.

    It’s not just antisemitism and religious bigotry going on here, there’s also anti-gay activism and out-and-out overt racism. I guess white people have always done stuff like this so he feels OK with it?

    And that Cohen guy is interesting, to say the least:

    Cohen battled racial and religious innuendo in his 2006 campaign for Congress, but not anything as blunt as the flier he received last week. After winning, he tried unsuccessfully to become the first white member of the Congressional Black Caucus

  • The asshole must have read Sadly No!’s comment because he added an update to his comment:

    UPDATE: Why should Obama weigh in? Because he promises an uplifting new kind of politics and this is an ugly old kind. Because Steve Cohen is one of Obama’s supporters, and political loyalty is supposed to run both ways — unless you’re Hillary, anyway, and Obama’s supposed to be the anti-Hillary. Because otherwise Obama’s big appeal — I’m a black candidate who’s not like Al Sharpton! — will be a fraud. And, of course, because it’s the right thing to do.

    Obama’s big appeal is that he is a black candidate who’s not like Al Sharpton?

    Reynolds is one nasty guy.

  • why is it that most religions seem to think that their religion is the only true religion, and everybody else is just a heathen? not trying to paint everybody with a broad brush here, just sayin……..that’s part of the reason why i’m an athiest.

  • It reminds me of this.

    (10-19-06) Texas GOP Accuses Democratic Opponent of Atheism: You are in a tight politically-charged race for a seat on a Texas appellate court. This race is too important to lose. The court must be packed with ideological conservatives so that progressives will not make inroads. When it is time to pull out the big guns, what do you do? If you are a Texas Republican, you accuse your Democratic opponent of the worst possible offense. Murder? Rape? Pedophilia? No, atheism. Continued here…

  • The other thing everyone seems to forget is who else is behind this. Harold Ford Jr. and the Ford machine are behind this. They are PO’ed that Cohen beat their hand picked toady last time and won’t be satisfied till they get rid of Cohen.

    Racer X:
    Cohen cares about the area he represents. Why do you think he was able to win in that district? He’s a great progressive and we need to do everything we can to help him.

  • Failure to denounce is rapidly approaching Hitler references (per Godwin’s law). Denounce Sharpton! Denounce Arafat! Denounce the White Patriot Party!

    It’s stupid, and denunciation for failure to denounce should immediately mark the denouncer in question as a stooge. Easy with Instapundit, to be sure.

  • It’s stupid, and denunciation for failure to denounce should immediately mark the denouncer in question as a stooge. Easy with Instapundit, to be sure.

    Heh. Indeed.

  • But I think you are really missing the point here.

    Really? You think Instaputz is interested in keeping a progressive Democrat in office and tamping down dirty politics inside the opposition party? Seriously?

  • I would like to apologize for Alphonse D’Amato. He should never have been allowed out of Nassau County.

  • Because he promises an uplifting new kind of politics and this is an ugly old kind.

    Apparently every time something bad happens in politics, Obama is supposed to magically make it go away.

    And they think we have ridiculous expectations of Obama.

  • The Jewish establishment (ALL the big organizations, secular & religious) bent over backwards over the past month to make it clear that anti-Obama attacks being sent via email to Jewish mailing lists did NOT in anyway represent the Jewish community.

    It wouldn’t hurt to have African American leaders do the same in this case. What do they have to lose?

  • I want to apologize for Senator James Inhofe, who is a mean-spirited moron. He’s white like me, and he’s from Oklahoma like me.

    There. Now I feel like a credit to my race.

  • Sam@#14

    Senator Obama’s speech at Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta on 1/20/08:

    “…For most of this country’s history, we in the African-American community have been at the receiving end of man’s inhumanity to man. And all of us understand intimately the insidious role that race still sometimes plays – on the job, in the schools, in our health care system, and in our criminal justice system.

    And yet, if we are honest with ourselves, we must admit that none of our hands are entirely clean. If we’re honest with ourselves, we’ll acknowledge that our own community has not always been true to King’s vision of a beloved community.

    We have scorned our gay brothers and sisters instead of embracing them. The scourge of anti-Semitism has, at times, revealed itself in our community. For too long, some of us have seen immigrants as competitors for jobs instead of companions in the fight for opportunity.

    For most of this country’s history, we in the African-American community have been at the receiving end of man’s inhumanity to man. And all of us understand intimately the insidious role that race still sometimes plays – on the job, in the schools, in our health care system, and in our criminal justice system.

    And yet, if we are honest with ourselves, we must admit that none of our hands are entirely clean. If we’re honest with ourselves, we’ll acknowledge that our own community has not always been true to King’s vision of a beloved community.

    We have scorned our gay brothers and sisters instead of embracing them. The scourge of anti-Semitism has, at times, revealed itself in our community. For too long, some of us have seen immigrants as competitors for jobs instead of companions in the fight for opportunity…”

  • Sam, Obama is a national candidate. So the smear on him was a national issue. Most black leaders will not have heard of Steve Cohen. Or any of this.

  • […] the literature encourages other black leaders in Memphis to “see to it that one and ONLY one black Christian faces this opponent of Christ […]

    Funny… I had always thought — apparently in error — that Jesus himself was a white guy and a Jew to boot.

    The relationship between blacks and Jews had always been somewhat strained (read James Baldwin and Richard Wright), with both sides contributing. Which is why I was so impressed with Obama’s courage and integrity for tackling the problem head on *and* in a place where the reception of his sentiments was not likely to be favourable. (see the quotes provided by The New New Deal, @18). But why do it twice, TNND?)

  • TR

    Reynolds is a Looooser. But, I don’t know what his motivations are and neither do you.

    Dems are not suposed to be divided on race and religion. That’s for the other team.

    And it a perfect opportunity for O to back Cohen. O’s been campaigning on themes that transcend race. Why not stick up for a Lib in need and put your $ where you mouth is.

    So the thing is: I think you are really missing the point here.

  • SB, thanks for bringing this up. I told you it was one of the most vile things I had ever seen in a campaign. Cohen is one of the best progressive freshmen congressmen in the nation. I hate that the DLC and Ford family backed machine are trying so desperately to get rid of his needed voice and his needed progressive vote. Nikki Tinker was hand picked by Ford, Jr to run after she lost the primary to Cohen 2 years ago and another Ford was carpettbagged in to run as an independant. He won 60% of the vote on his merits as a state senator and on his campaigning. And he did ask to become a member of the Black Congressional Causus, since 60% of his district is AA.

    So, anyone who desires better Democrats, not just the more please send a few bucks through ACT Blue to Congressman Cohen’s re-election campaign.

    That Sadly, No thread last night was brilliant. And so along the same lines, as a white woman from TN, I want to abjectly apologize for the most odious Marsha Blackburn, who is my congressperson, and for Bob Corker and Lamar Alexander. Oh, and for most of the crap that comes out of Nashvegas that they call country music.

  • Speaking from Memphis, blatant racism in local politics is nothing new. While I’m not sure I agree that Sen. Obama needs to get involved, I don’t know how often I’ve heard outraged cries for this politician or that politician to denounce something a racist nutjob said or did on their behalf only to be greeted to crickets when the tide of bigottry flows the other direction.

    As for the “not Sharpton” comment, I think you are deluding yourself if you don’t see that part of Sen. Obama’s success as a national candidate is that he is not blatantly partisan to the point of excluding non-blacks. As I have said before, many will vote for a candidate who is black that would not vote for a Black candidate. It has nothing to do with a candidate’s race, but more with the perception that his/her decissions would be unduly informed by the race of the affected constituents.

  • libra@#20

    My mistake. I didn’t notice the double post until it was too late. I’d be happy if Steve fixed it.

    Meanwhile, I got to thinking. Isn’t Bill Clinton the first black president? Shouldn’t Bill and Hillary be rushing to Cohen’s defense?

  • Dems are not suposed to be divided on race and religion. That’s for the other team.” – brian

    Do you really believe this? No, that’s a feature of the human condition, one that is regretable and one that is nobly opposed by many from all political stripes. I find your simplistic bigottry and “yea our side” cheerleading disgusting, though unfortunately all too predictable.

  • Maybe I’m getting off topic here slightly, but it doesn’t seem to be bothering anyone here that candidates are being targeted specifically because they’re not Christians. This goes for the Cohen example set forth in this repugnant story, but also for the gutter-trash falsehoods spread about Obama’s religious background. Not to mention the fear and revilement in which atheism is held in this country. It seems to a large segment that if you’re not down with the cross, you can’t be a legitimate American. How shameful.

  • What Obama and Hillary need is a “Denounced” list on their websites.

    Like Colbert’s “On Notice” list.

    It’d be easy to bookmark, and maybe Instaputz would go back to drawing pictures of George W. Bush kissing him in his Trapper Keeper.

  • Look at GHR’s most recent buffoonery:

    “ANOTHER UPDATE: Okay, the “fraud” bit was a bit strong. But it is the right thing to do, and it’s the kind of thing that a guy promising a new uplifting kind of politics ought to do. Trust me, if the racial angle were pointing the other way, this would be getting a lot of attention, especially if it could be tied to a Republican. And I say this, remember, as a guy who went after Trent Lott for a lot less.”

    So what Trent “we wouldn’t have all these problems” Lott said is “a lot less” than Obama’s non-comment on a situation that has nothing to do with him? Reynolds really is delusional.

  • To submandave

    “Dems are not suposed to be divided on race and religion. That’s for the other team.”

    Ya man I believe it. That’s what Barack tells me anyway about the first sentence and Ken Mehlman tells me about the second sentence.

    Here is a primer for you:

    Liberal position is not discriminate for or against any particular faith….neither for or against any particular faith but rather to remain neutral. And the other team, not so much. Check out the case of one Willard “Mitt” Romney. Also, check in on the Harriet Myers debaucle.

    And Dems have come a long way on race. Other team, not so much so in recent history. Check out the case of one Kenneth Mehlman. Ken, GOP Chariman, speaking before the NAACP in 2005 said:

    Last November, Mr. Bush won 11 percent of the black vote. Since then, the Republican Party has been making an effort to woo black voters to what Mr. Mehlman reminded his audience was once widely hailed as “the party of Lincoln.” But whether those efforts will pay off remain to be seen.

    In his remarks, Mr. Mehlman noted that about 90 percent of blacks vote for Democrats in most national elections. And he said Republicans themselves were partly to blame.

    “Some Republicans gave up on winning the African-American vote, looking the other way or trying to benefit politically from racial polarization,” Mr. Mehlman told his audience. “I am here today as the Republican chairman to tell you we were wrong.”

    Now I am not saying that are Dems always perfect in all parts of the Country. That ain’t possible. But you see, you got an overall record to compare. Mehlman is honest enough to admit it. Others are not (and do you know who I am talking about).

    As far as charges of bigotry goes …….. pretty easy type that phrase. Backing up the claim is another story.

    For example one could type out some pixels to say that anyone (say a conservative) who is against the gays having the same civil rights as everyone else is sad, pathetic, disgusting, though unfortunately all too predictable from the likes of a “yea our side” cheerleader. It is Easy to Type, Man.

  • Brian, don’t you remember when he failed to renounce Harry Belafonte for Tim Russert? I guess Barack just doesn’t understand that he’s running for the office of black America’s national garbage collector.

  • sniflheim – Dood you a Insta-Troll?

    Harry B is like 80 years old. You got something better than O’s decsion not to smack down a geriatric.

    Hell, O does not even smack down wingnuts. And Man they just ask for it. Case in point See Sniflheim, above. For O it is Unity and All, brother.

    But O is a better man than me. You see, I enjoy a wingnut beatdown now and again even though I don’t go looking for them.

    O got a different approach. Again, he a better man than me.

  • brian said: Reynolds comments are not ridculous C.B. Here’s the jist of it.

    Don’t focus on the crazy Preacher. Focus on Cohen. We have few progressive libs in elective office in the South. Cohen is a stellar guy.
    Barack should absolutely stop by and campaign for Cohen before the primary.
    If you know Memphis and if this preacher is trying to divide dems by religion and race, this is an easy call.
    Of course Barack does not have to respond everytime an Isaah Thomas (f)s up.

    What? I mean what? Barack should campaign for Cohen? Fine. What about Hilary Clinton? or John McCain? or maybe even George Bush?

    What is George Bush fine with this preacher making anti-semitic comments? What about Huckabee? Since Huck and this guy are both ministers, doesn’t that provide an even closer linkage to the ridiculous newletter? The point that Reynolds is making is that Barack Obama needs to condemn the preacher because they are both black. No link otherwise. Why does he only focus on Obama? How come no one else in the Democratic or Republican parties need to condemn the newsletter?

    Reynolds is simply trying to inject race into an issue that has nothing to do with race.

  • jmill

    Unless you are best buds with Reynolds (and I don’t think you are) you can’t tell me that you got Insta-loooosers pulse down. You’re not swappin spit in the showers with this guy are you? Probably not so – You don’t what the dude’s intention was.

    O’s is running a different campaign. This is a good opportunity to reach out and help a progressive in need.

    Who said @#$% about issuing condemnations. Not me – that was you. Speech police like Insta-looooser may like condemnations, but not me.

  • Comments are closed.