Appeals court throws out Jena Six conviction

The story of the Jena Six is one of the more painful examples of racism in recent memory.

In September 2006, a group of African American high school students in Jena, Louisiana, asked the school for permission to sit beneath a “whites only” shade tree. There was an unwritten rule that blacks couldn’t sit beneath the tree. The school said they didn’t care where students sat. The next day, students arrived at school to see three nooses (in school colors) hanging from the tree….

The boys who hung the nooses were suspended from school for a few days. The school administration chalked it up as a harmless prank, but Jena’s black population didn’t take it so lightly. Fights and unrest started breaking out at school. The District Attorney, Reed Walters, was called in to directly address black students at the school and told them all he could “end their life with a stroke of the pen.”

Black students were assaulted at white parties. A white man drew a loaded rifle on three black teens at a local convenience store. (They wrestled it from him and ran away.) Someone tried to burn down the school, and on December 4th, a fight broke out that led to six black students being charged with attempted murder. To his word, the D.A. pushed for maximum charges, which carry sentences of eighty years. Four of the six are being tried as adults (ages 17 & 18) and two are juveniles.

An all-white jury convicted one of the six. Yesterday, an appeals court threw out the conviction.

A Louisiana appeals court yesterday overturned the aggravated-battery conviction of a black high school student who was found guilty of attacking a white classmate after a racial incident that raised tensions in their small town.

The state’s 3rd Circuit Court of Appeal ruled that Mychal Bell, 17, should not have been tried as an adult by LaSalle Parish District Attorney J. Reed Walters, and that the trial judge erred in allowing Bell to be tried as an adult on charges of aggravated second-degree battery. Under Louisiana law, teenagers can be tried as adults for certain violent crimes but not battery, the court said.

The closer one looks at the controversy, the more dreadful the details appear.

The media has been slow to pick up on the seriousness of what’s transpired — and, candidly, so have bloggers like me — but it’s an outrage that deserves the intensity of the national spotlight.

The LAT ran an excellent summary today of the situation thus far.

In December, six black boys jumped a white boy at the high school here and beat him while he lay unconscious.

The victim was taken to the hospital, but he was not gravely hurt. He attended a class ring ceremony later that evening.

The black boys were charged with attempted murder, which threatened to put them in prison for most of their lives. The district attorney alleged they’d used a deadly weapon: their sneakers.

The case of the so-called Jena Six has elicited outrage around the world — not only because of the stiff charges brought against the black teenagers, but because of the stark contrast between the way black boys and white boys in the same town were treated.

The assault was the culmination of months of racial unrest in Jena (pronounced JEE-nuh), a former sawmill town of about 3,000 people in the backwoods of central Louisiana. It started at the beginning of the last school year, when a black freshman at Jena High School asked the vice principal during a school assembly whether he could sit under the “white tree,” a gnarled oak on campus where white students gathered to escape the stifling Southern heat. He was told to sit wherever he wanted.

The following day last September, three hangman’s nooses were dangling from the oak’s branches. Two months later, the school was set on fire.

The three white boys who hung the nooses were identified but not expelled or charged with a hate crime; they were suspended for three days. No one has been charged in the arson.

My friends at Too Sense have been offering thorough and excellent coverage of the controversy for months. Stay tuned.

Geeez. Too much that could have been prevented if prejudice weren’t so prevalent. Nothing a few months in juvenile hall couldn’t have cured. Also, a concentrated school effort on racism and prejudice could have been implemented. It sounds like people were just looking for excuses to blame each other. Trying as an adult…years of imprisonment…threatening black students…not tactics based on trying to end racial prejudice but rather trying to instigate it. When I was a kid in high school this is what worked. Nobody wanted to spend months in Juvenile hall where all you got to do was homework and maybe an hour or two of TV. Sounds to me like the school administration and the prosecutor teamed up to enforce some “unwritten” policy instead of working together to solve the real issues.

  • And people say that southern justice has changed. What a joke! And remember what party controls southern politics- the family value, compassionate conservative Republican Party.

    Most, if not all of the bigots that were in the Democratic party until 1968( the first election after the passing of the civil rights act) are now members of the bigoted( use Mexicans in addition to the ol’ scapegoat blacks) homophobic hate party known as the REPUG party, and for good reason.

    What I hate about this, politically, is that the tail is still waging the dog in National elections, and the composition of the tail aint pretty.

  • Plant a tree in front of your local school in honor of racial integration and equality.
    We live in an America where blacks and whites serve each other, fight for each other, give each other medical care, educate each other, drive each other to work, and save each other’s lives- Thank God for that.

  • It’s like the Germans with WWI / WWII- those crackers are just upset because they weren’t man enough to win the Civil War so they need to take their feeling so inferiority out on somebody.

  • The WWI defeat made Germans more susceptible to Hitler’s antisemitism, or that’s what some say, that is.

    The South Shall Embarrass Itself Again

  • A district attorney who makes a comment like that (“I’ll end your life with the stroke of a pen”) is unfit for public office.

    J. Reed Walters – a name to remember. May it live in infamy.

  • I’ve only learned about this incident via another article concerning Rev. Jackson and Sen. Obama, and I am APPALLED. I cannot believe that these incidents still happen in this extremity in our nation. These displays of prejudice and hate at any level disgust me and I, a journalism student, am disgusted with the media for not making the nation more aware of this incident! I agree that presidential candidates & media outlets should spend more time on this story. The citizens have a right to know.

  • You seem to imply that this “all-white jury” is complicit in these racist acts, but even the Jena 6 themselves concede that they assaulted this white kid. It sounds to me like you’re being a bit misleading with your language, trying to paint the entire town in the same light, when the actual racist acts were committed by a smaller group.

    These kids committed a crime. “Free the Jena 6” might make for a good slogan, but no matter how much racism was involved, one thing that is very clear is that these 6 hooligans deserve to spend some time behind bars.

  • Comments are closed.