Beware of the fruit of the ‘Tree of Knowledge’

Guest Post by Morbo

Drivers on the New Jersey Turnpike are about to see something other than cement and 18-wheelers. A large billboard has been erected on the southbound lanes between the George Washington Bridge and the Lincoln Tunnel that reads, “Don’t believe in God? You are not alone.”

The billboard is the project of a group called FreeThoughtAction. I was pretty surprised when I read about this. It’s not surprising that a group would seek to erect a billboard like this — what’s surprising is that they found a company willing to rent them the space.

Books by prominent atheists like Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens have sold surprisingly well. But as I’ve mentioned in previous posts, atheism remains the last taboo, and there are some people in this country who just can’t deal with it. Billboard companies tend to shy away from anything that’s likely to get the conservative masses riled up and stick to wholesome advertising (like for cigarettes, liquor, lottery tickets and stuff).

I never ceased to be amazed at the lengths some people will go to snuff out the threatening message of non-belief. In Chester County, Pa., a woman named Margaret Downey who runs a group for non-believers sought and got permission to erect a “Tree of Knowledge” on the courthouse lawn last month.

The 22-foot evergreen tree was decorated with covers of books promoting skepticism of religion and concepts like evolution and church-state separation. It shared space with a creche sponsored by the Pennsylvania Pastors Network and a menorah erected by Chabad of Chester County.

These were not government-backed displays. They were privately funded and maintained. Everybody is playing by the same rules, everybody has access and everything’s cool, right?

Wrong.

The Tree of Knowledge was vandalized several times. As the Philadelphia Inquirer reported, Downey noted that not long after the tree was erected, “one of the spotlights was broken” and “the other five lights had been turned away from our tree to focus on the crèche.”

Two books covers were torn off the tree — Charles Darwin’s The Origin of Species and Dawkins’ The Ancestor’s Tale: A Pilgrimage to the Dawn of Evolution. A few days later, six spotlights on the tree were unplugged, and someone tampered with the cables supporting the tree. Not long after that, more lights were removed and another book cover was ripped down. On Dec. 29 or 30, Downey said, “someone had taken a knife or bolt cutters and actually severed the lighting cords to where all the lights had to be replaced.”

Last month, the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights complained about nativity scenes being vandalized. Yes, that’s bad. People who engage in such behaviors are boorish hoodlums who should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. The same goes for anyone caught vandalizing non-religious displays as well.

An open forum is exactly that — open. Everyone gets to use it. This includes messages some people may not like. These messages are erected with private funds. No one is compelled to support them. We should all have the right to speak our mind about religion or non-religion on public space without government endorsement of any message.

It’s a nice idea, but it’s not going to work until some people take an additional important step: Grow up.

Billboard companies tend to shy away from anything that’s likely to get the conservative masses riled up and stick to wholesome advertising (like for cigarettes, liquor, lottery tickets and stuff).

Unless, of course, they are in poor neighborhoods.

  • The Berkeley Free Speech Movement in the early 1960s was a fight over political activity on campus, essentially whether to allow an open forum and recruiting on campus. It had been prohibited on the UC campus, and Mario Savio and others demonstrated long and hard to overturn than ban.

    When I enrolled at San Francisco State I discovered that they had long had a Free Speech platform. Anyone who could sign up for it could use it. Every day around lunch time, sitting on the vast lawn in front of the Student Union, we enjoyed Democrats, Republican, Socialists, Wobblies, American Nazis, Sexual Freedom League people, folksingers, nudists, John Birchers … you name it.

    The contrast between that and the riotous attempt to duplicate it Berkeley was amazing to me. Incidentally, before I got kicked out of the University San Francisco (hence winding up at SF State), there was a few weeks when our (Jesuit) campus newspaper, the Foghorn, published Berkeley’s Daily Californian because that had been banned by the Regents over freedom of the press.

  • Great news! Maybe this will help to plant a seed of critical thought in the minds of the commuting masses. I’ll keep my eyes open for it as I drive home from NJ to LI. I’ll drive carefully, though.

  • What’s needed (vis a vis the Tree of Knowledge thing) is for local religious leaders to denounce the vandalism — that is, if they truly are leaders and of good moral character. ANYTHING that debases a free and open marketplace of ideas is a threat to EVERYONE’s freedom of conscience — and it might not be too long before followers of a particular brand of, say, Christianity, grow uncomfortable and dream of the freedom to be different.

    It should go without saying that this extended to leaders of the non-believer sort too.

    It’s not a religion-v-atheism thing. It’s a civil civic discourse thing.

  • Love the concept of the Tree of Knowledge:

    But it just goes to show that you have to watch out for those violent amoral Christians.

  • I think cannibalism is the last taboo. And necrophilia. Oh, and bestiality. Come to think of it, there are a lot more unpopular things than atheism. In fact, if people were given the choice between an avowed atheist and a swastika-wearing, Hitler-loving Nazi, I think most Americans would hold their nose and vote for the atheist.

  • It’d be cool if non-believers tooted their horns whenever they passed the billboard.

  • Now there’s a cool idea. “Honk if you’re an atheist.” But something like that or “Honk if you don’t believe in God” would have agnostics all indecisive. “Honk if you’re an agnostic” would leave out many of those atheists who consider themselves farther afield than agnostisicm. “Honk if you’re athiest or agnostic” might do the trick, but it’s kind of clumsy. Damn unbelievers and their nuance! I do like the idea, though. It would be really interesting to hear the results. Any ideas for a succinct and inclusive and catchy phrase that would work for everybody involved?

    For some reason this didn’t all post last time.

  • Hi everyone. I’m with FreeThoughtAction.org and we appreciate you taking notice of our billboard. And I especially want to thank Speed for saying that we’re more popular than cannibals, necrophiliacs and American Nazis. I knew we were making progress.

    BTW, since some of you brought it up, the content was not a big problem so far with most billboards we looked at. That’s partially due to the tone of our message – it’s provocative but not too agressive or negative – and partially because billboard companies are in the business of selling space not deciding whether you should drink Coke or Pepsi.

    I invite everyone who’s interested to come to http://www.freethoughtaction.org to poke around our site, sign up for email list or even donate to the cause of helping America evolve into a more rational, less religious country. Thanks!

  • #12: No, that would be too ambiguous. A “skeptic” about what? Creationists could honk at that over their views about evolution, just for one example. It really would need to be explicitly about God belief to make the meaning clear.

  • The phrase goes “love thy neighbor” not ” love thy neighber only if he believes exactly like you.”

  • Its really funny that those who preach ‘PEACE ” and not to be Judgemental,are the most destructive when it comes to free speech ?????????????
    I have been around for 57 years and never did Anything EVIL .I always gave to the abused and underpriviledged and sick .I guess that makes me EVIL .
    Well, Im not Changing and I still don`t believe in god .

  • Oh yeah .I`ve never been arrested ,I love my Family ,Friends and my pets .
    I can see where the religious think I should burn in Hell …..lol

  • Comments are closed.