Bush’s open-mike problem

[tag]George W. Bush[/tag] has had enough problems around [tag]open[/tag] [tag]microphone[/tag]s that you’d think he’d learn to be more careful. No such luck.

It wasn’t meant to be overheard. Private luncheon conversations among world leaders, picked up by a microphone, provided a rare window into both banter and substance — including President Bush cursing Hezbollah’s attacks against Israel.

[tag]Bush[/tag] expressed his frustration with the United Nations and his disgust with the militant Islamic group and its backers in Syria as he talked to British Prime Minister Tony Blair during the closing lunch at the Group of Eight summit.

“See the irony is that what they need to do is get Syria to get Hezbollah to stop doing this s— and it’s over,” Bush told Blair as he chewed on a buttered roll.

He told Blair he felt like telling U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, who visited the gathered leaders, to get on the phone with Syrian President Bashar Assad to “make something happen.”

The video — AP has the CNN clip, though I suspect there are others — is worth watching. Blair appears anxious to explain the Middle East to Bush, while the president is slouching and talking with his mouth full.

Regardless, I can’t help but notice that the president often comes across as an unsophisticated simpleton in public, with embarrassing malapropisms and difficulties in answering unscripted questions, but incidents like this one at the G8 luncheon suggest Bush is even less impressive in private.

Indeed, the transcript of the president’s open-mike remarks during a photo-op at the lunch offers a series of insightful exchanges.

* On his public remarks during the lunch: “No, just going to make it up. I’m not going to talk too long like the rest of them. Some of these guys talk too long.”

* On sticking to his schedule: “Gotta go home. Got something to do tonight. How about you? Where are you going home? This is your neighborhood, doesn’t take you long to get home. You eight hours? Me too. Russia’s a big country and you’re a big country. Takes him eight hours to fly home…. Russia’s big and so is China.”

* Upon seeing Tony Blair get out of his chair: “Yo, Blair. What are you doing? Are you leaving?”

Yo, Blair“? Seriously?

There’s a classic Saturday Night Live skit from the 1980s featuring Ronald Reagan as a slow, quiet man in public, masking an adept technocrat with a vast policy expertise and an eye for remarkable detail. The “amiable dunce” facade was just an act.

Similarly, political observers sometimes wonder if Bush is sharper and more adroit than he seems in public. The president manages expectations by appearing to be simple, the theory goes, but behind closed doors, a skillful and adept leader emerges.

Alas, Bush’s amiable-dunce act is genuine.

Alas, Bush’s amiable-dunce act is genuine.

I’m not so sure about the “amiable” part.

  • I posted this on yesteday’s discussion group, but it more properly goes here.

    Open microphones may be the closest we come to open government with the BushCo. folks and fortunately there was one at a G8 dinner. What was heard should give us no comfort about Bush’s ability to manage the latest Middle East crisis. Here is Bush on the Israeli/Hezbollah situation.

    Bush expressed his frustration with the United Nations and his disgust with the militant Islamic group and its backers in Syria as he talked to British Prime Minister Tony Blair during the closing lunch at the Group of Eight summit.

    “See the irony is that what they need to do is get Syria to get Hezbollah to stop doing this s— and it’s over,” Bush told Blair as he chewed on a buttered roll.
    He told Blair he felt like telling U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, who visited the gathered leaders, to get on the phone with Syrian President Bashar Assad to “make something happen.” He suggested Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice might visit the region soon.

    This is what Bush means when he says that he is delegator. He means he wants others to do his job.

  • I love that now Bush is relying on the UN when he’s excoriated them in the past and his supporters have been trained to consider the UN corrupt and ineffective. What happened to cowboy diplomacy? What happened to the policeman for the world?

  • I actually think that Boy George II is right about Hezbollah’s attacks being at the intigation and support of Syria. After all, they have all of southern Lebanon back, it’s Syria whose territory is still occupied. Syria wants it back, in exchange for peace. I believe the current Isreal position is they would return all but the upper shore of the Sea of Galilee to Syria (keep control of the dwindling water supply).

    But James is right, Boy George II is anything but amiable. Look how he abuses his staff.

  • Let me first comment and say that this entire fiasco embarasses me as an American.

    But, on to a serious question I have about part of the AP article.

    As he chats with Russian President Vladimir Putin, Bush expresses amazement that it will take Putin and an unidentified leader just as long to fly home to Moscow as it will take him to fly back to Washington. Putin’s reply could not be heard.

    ‘You eight hours? Me too. Russia’s a big country and you’re a big country. Takes him eight hours to fly home. Not Coke, diet Coke. … Russia’s big and so is China. Yo Blair, what’re you doing? Are you leaving,’ Bush said.

    I immediately wondered how on Earth it would be possible for a plane ride from St. Petersburg to Moscow to take as long as a plane ride from St. Petersburg to Washington, D.C. I did a little research, and it looks like the distance from St. Petersburg to Moscow is 393 miles, while the distance from St. Petersburg to Washington, D.C. is 4,475 miles!

    So I’m wondering whether Bush got confused, the AP got the story wrong, or if Putin’s version of Air Force One is actually the Wright Brothers’ Flyer. Can anyone shed any light on this?

  • “Gotta go home. Got something to do tonight. How about you? Where are you going home? This is your neighborhood, doesn’t take you long to get home. You eight hours? Me too. Russia’s a big country and you’re a big country. Takes him eight hours to fly home…. Russia’s big and so is China.”

    His grasp of the planet is indeed impressive. I’m surprised he didn’t follow up with:

    “Yo, Blair. Your country is puny.”

  • This story could be the most significant “scoop” of the Bush presidency. His poll numbers are very low, as Nixon’s were as the Watergate story ground on. But the even Nixon’s staunchest defenders left him when the tapes revealed that he used foul language. I’m curious how the religious right responds. Of course, the fact that he has no idea what he’s doing won’t won’t disturb anyone.

  • So I’m wondering whether Bush got confused, the AP got the story wrong, or if Putin’s version of Air Force One is actually the Wright Brothers’ Flyer. Can anyone shed any light on this?

    Yeah, that bothered me too, TL. The problem is the AP assumes Bush was talking to Putin, though there are some reports suggesting that he was speaking to Chinese President Hu. That would make more sense.

  • I heard our potty mouth president utter the word on CNN — so I think we should all contact the FCC to complain. They won’t fine Dubya, but they might fine CNN and then perhaps CNN will think twice before airing Dubya live for fear of what he might say. Turnabout is fair play.

  • Our president is a simple, stupid, ill-mannered child, and that harsh fact was brought sharply into focus for leaders of the G8. Watch Angela Merkel’s embarrassed reaction to Bush’s comments about the roast pig during their joint press conference. Or Putin’s response to Bush criticism of the state of Russian democracy. Or Blair’s exasperated stance as he explains the Middle East to Bush, while Bush blows out out bread crumbs all over his tie and blurt out how Hezbollah needs to cut the “shit.” Or the fact that Blair and Kofi Annan met behind closed doors to discuss the Middle East, but Bush either wasn’t invited or couldn’t bother to attend.

    What a pathetic, weak little man. It’s going to take decades to repair the damage he’s done, if it can be repaired at all.

  • I hate him more than anyone has ever hated anyone in the whole history of the world. I think I said that already.

  • Yeah, that bothered me too, TL. The problem is the AP assumes Bush was talking to Putin, though there are some reports suggesting that he was speaking to Chinese President Hu. That would make more sense.” – Carpetbagger

    That would make more sense, as it certainly seems redundant to tell Putin that “Russia’s a big country and you’re a big country.” However, I looked up the distance from St. Petersburg to Beijing, which is listed as 3,769 miles. That’s still 706 miles shorter than the distance to Washington, D.C., or roughly the distance from New York City to Atlanta.

    Perhaps the most likely candidate is the Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi. After all, the distance from St. Petersburg to Tokyo is 4,728 miles, which is only 250 miles more than the distance to Washington, D.C. Of course, if that is true, then the “you’re a big country” comment wouldn’t really make sense. Hopefully the AP clears things up later.

  • An amiable dunce in public. A snappish, brusque, ill-tempered dunce in private, according to some accounts.

  • Merkel’s embarassed countenance is pretty similar to the expression on the face of the lady in the classic Vonage advert as she realizes her husband is robo-dancing in the background.

  • That would make more sense, as it certainly seems redundant to tell Putin that “Russia’s a big country and you’re a big country.” However, I looked up the distance from St. Petersburg to Beijing, which is listed as 3,769 miles. That’s still 706 miles shorter than the distance to Washington, D.C., or roughly the distance from New York City to Atlanta.
    I don’t think 706 miles is a big difference when you factor in possible flight paths and rounding to an even hour. I’d say he was talking to Hu.

  • “Yo, Blair”, that is too precious.

    Does he call Dick and Rove up and do the “Whazzup” routine?

  • uncouth brutish Neanderthal boor

    I feel sorry for the beast, he’s so off kilter.

  • Why should Bush need to engage in diplomacy and negotiations when he he is a mystic? After all, he can look into men’s souls, as he told us about his first meeting with Putin — or “Vladimir,” as he diplomatically called another head of state. (Mercifully, he didn’t call him “the Put-man.”) In Putin’s case, Bush’s soul-gawking may have been affected by blurred vision. Anyhow, we don’t need any other branches of government with a decider/seer as president.

    (Ooops! Did I say “mystic?” I meant “mistake.”)

  • Hey, DeepDarkDiamond (in other words, a piece of coal), if you want to see “crude language,” try Little Green Footballs and Free Republic. You’ll fit right in with the other bipeds lacking frontal lobes and opposable thumbs.

  • Tom Cleaver – slow on the satire uptake and quick as usual with the personal attacks…

  • Like we say in the sticks, it will take 5 generations to breed GW out of his line of descendants. But America and the world may not have that chance after GW is done restoring dignity to the Oval Office.

  • while the president is slouching and talking with his mouth full.

    In addition to the profanity, this is the part that will be shocking to his supporters if they see the video. Good table manners matter in most conservative households, and Bush’s manners are atrocious. My parents would have never taken me out to eat with them again if I had behaved like that in a restaurant when I was growing up,

  • Even worse than Bush’s use of the sh** word was his rush to leave the G-8 conference: “Gotta go home. Got something to do tonight.” (Transcript) The U.S. is in the middle of a foreign policy crisis (Iraq, Iran, Israel, Lebanon, Syria, Afghanistan, N. Korea, …) and could desperately use help from our Allies. Yet Bush is itching to leave a meeting of the world’s leaders to jump into his 747 and go home. What could he possibly have to do that could be any more important than meeting with the leaders of the G-8, watch American Idol? What a moron.

  • “Yo, Blair”? ??????

    “Russia’s big and so is China. ” What is going on in this man’s mind? A screen-saver of bouncing puppies? Images of fleecy white clouds sailing across a blue sky? God help us, this wasn’t supposed to impress world leaders with his mastery of geopolitical details, was it?

    I’ve come to the conclusion that the reason that Bush so often sounds like he’s explaining stuff to a four year old is that he’s explaining his own reasoning. As soon as Bush is out of office and the people who dealt with him (in Washington and overseas) start retiring, there’s going to be an unprecedented flood of fascinating memoirs, but until then, how can his supporters look themselves in the mirror? .

  • ‘Yo, Blair’

    …and other comments, sound just like the frat boys I knew. Calling someone by their last name is something I left behind in college.

  • With material like this coming out of Dubya’s mouth every other day, Jon Stewart doesn’t need writers for The Daily Show — he just needs to turn on the VCR every morning. Thursday was the pig roast, today the lunch in Russia. And when Bush is busy, there are other morons waiting to fill for him in such as Sen. Ted Stevens and the tubes on his internets.

    Seriously, this whole sorry administration would be a lot more amusing if they weren’t so bloody scary.

  • Dear Deep Dark Diamond: I thought you were kidding and I hope you are. After all, the filthy language we are discussing was generated by our president. Every time there is a live mike we hear some crude remark. He is only surpassed by his own choice for VP who tells a US Senator to go f—k himself on the Senate floor.

  • Dear Deep Dark Diamond: I thought you were kidding and I hope you are. That’s the point – it’s supposedly ok to criticize liberal blogs for language (of all things) – but coarse language on the right is accepted – big double standard. One would assume that both liberal and conservative blogs will be reporting this, as well as the MSM, – so will everybody come under attack for their language then? Or will it be because Bush said it’s OK?

    Now Tom Cleaver made two nasty offensive ethnic slurs against Lieberman and Shumer in the comments in this blog last week – and got quite nasty (as well as refusing to accept responsibility for his actions) when called on it. It’s kind of funny to see him as the self-appointed arbiter of the comments section.

  • The transcript I read — huffingtonpost — started with “yo blair.” The other quotes you have weren’t in it. Based on that transcript, at least, he sounded more intelligent to me than he normally does with his prepared speeches in public. At least he sounded engaged and with some grasp of the situation, which is actually more than I expect of him.

  • I’ve found that the deliberately ignorant people who worship this idiot tend to be really offended by coarse language. But trumped-up wars which cause the deaths of hundreds of thousands of innocent people… not so much.

    If I thought there was a God, I’d ask him to save us from this idiot.

  • Funny how the Decider isn’t up to making any decisions nor is interested in taking a leadership role. This transcript should remove any last vestiges of dignity that U.S. foreign policy had left. A lot of the world now believes that the U.S. is the most dangerous nation on the planet — we’re a loose cannon rolling on the deck of a rudderless ship with an idiot for a captain. Thanks W, we all now realize you spent all that money flying Airforce 1 to the G8 summit just to eat a few free meals. Now that’s leadership!

  • Fred Kaplan has a good analysis of Bush’s handling of the Israeli-Hezbollah conflict based in part on the Bush-Blair exchange.

    Unless he wants to heighten the chances of a war that engulfs the entire Middle East, Bush needs to do what most presidents in far less dire circumstances would already have done: drop the moral posturing; resume diplomatic relations (not the same thing as friendship) with all parties; “get on the phone with Assad” himself (don’t leave it to Annan, whose leverage is limited); and get Condi on that plane, not “pretty soon,” but now.

    .

  • What a bunch of morons you blogers are! Bush is a great leader that will get the credit down the line for what Liberals will never give him now! Think of having Prez (I got “wounded” 3 times by spinters!) Kerry or Prez (I invented the internet and the world is about to end from global warming) ALGORE. We would still be running from the terroists! Liberals are wimps and Terroists LOVE wimps. Just look at Bin Ladin’s writings about when President (SHE’s UNDER THE DESK!) Clinton was in office. He talked about how we didnt have the stomach for losing troops when we pulled out in Bosnia.
    We are lucky to have Bush as President!

  • It’s amazing to me the standards people are holding this president to.Unlike the one we had before just him, you know the the one who had an affair with his teenage inturn, then lied on T.V. about it. The one accused of attemped rape and sexual assualt. The one who gave the Chinese and the North Koreans assistance with nuclear weapons and long range missle technology. Married to that lawyer who had all those questionable land and stock dealings. I could go on but I have a life and this is the first and only time I am going to read this b.s. you people are writing. Hey if you don’t have the guts to leave your real name here what does that say about you! Lee Lawrence Richmond, Virginia

  • #38

    Mr. Lawrence, I hope you are not reading this. It would mean that you were wrong about this being the last time you’d read this bs. We bid you hurry in your exit, and hope you are as good as your word.

    It’s hard to believe that anyone could still believe the stuff you spout.

  • Dubya did all but put his boot on the table. I wonder if it ever shall be possible for his supporters to shake off their blind partisanship long enough to admit that this fellow is a poor quality, second (fifth?) rate manniquin? He is propped up by connections and people who are too proud to admit the screamingly obvious, that he is a huge mistake. The damage he has wrought upon the nation will injure Republicans and Democrats for a long time to come. Our soldiers are stretched to the breaking point fighting a war in the wrong country. Our disaster management needs disaster management. We have an attorney general who doesn’t believe in the writ of habeus corpus, and if he could UNsign the Geneva Conventions, he would. This is the mark of an uncivilized country. When our soldiers fight abroad, they will suffer for it.
    For those who invoke Clinton’s misbehavior whenever Bush’s manifold shortcomings are brought up, it’s irrelevant. Monica’s misadventures with Big Bill had no effect upon foreign policy, and have nearly passed the statute of limitations. It is this president’s utter incompetence, here and now, that will harm us all, on the left and right, while partisans bicker.

  • The tragedy of George Bush is not that he’s an imbecile, but that he has failed to realize his potential. If he was more curious about what is going on in the world, and if he studied harder, he could have been a moron.

  • The tragedy of George Bush is not that he’s an imbecile, but that he has failed to realize his potential. If he was more curious about what is going on in the world, and if he studied harder, he could have been a moron.

    Comment by Joe Wallace — 7/19/2006 @ 7:16 pm

    I totally agree with a lot of you about the short-commings and let-downs over time by Bush.

    What really bothers me is when is all this going to make the public reflect on the reality of the situation and when is it going to have some consequences for the people in office causing all this mayhem. Is the post for presidency for sale for the highest bidder or the biggest fool..?

    That is almost the case for most of the leaders all over the whole world. The question is when is the public going to learn..??

  • anyone know what he’s “gotta go home” for?

    According to the White House, he had nothing on his schedule. He is just a moron.

  • Comments are closed.