Clinton is not hearing ‘voices from beyond’

I get alerts from ABC News via email, and one hit my inbox this afternoon with this subject line: “Clinton Hears Voices from Beyond: ‘Keep Going’.”

Naturally, given that ABC News’ headline suggested that a leading presidential candidate was hearing voices in her head, I was curious what on Earth the report (which had the same headline as my email subject line) actually said. Wouldn’t you know it, Hillary Clinton is not delusional.

ABC News’ Eloise Harper and Kate Snow Report: In McAllen, Texas this morning Senator Hillary Clinton, D-N.Y., said she wasn’t giving up on her race for the White House.

Speaking about her work in South Texas as an organizer for George McGovern’s 1972 presidential campaign, Clinton said two strong Texas women inspired her — Congresswoman Barbara Jordan and Texas Governor Ann Richards.

Clinton said they taught her about courage and determination. Then she suggested that she is hearing from them even as her campaign struggles to compete after a string of losses.

“I can hear their voices saying, ‘You keep going! You give the people a real choice about the future!'” she said at a campaign event.

Note to ABC: Clinton did not mean she can literally hear the voices of dead people. She is not schizophrenic. “Clinton Hears Voices from Beyond” is not a particularly helpful headline.

Or, as Kevin put it, “Look. I know that campaign coverage can get mighty dull and the search for something resembling actual news can get pretty desperate. But seriously, folks, this is what we professional writers call a ‘figure of speech.’ Hillary is not suggesting that she hears ‘voices from beyond.’ OK?”

If I had to guess, I’d say it’s at least possible that ABC News is trying to piggyback on this two-day story from 12 years ago.

The woman described by Bob Woodward as a spiritual adviser to first lady Hillary Rodham Clinton disputed several of Woodward’s published assertions Sunday night .

Jean Houston, interviewed at the Newark Airport by CNN, said that Mrs. Clinton did indeed have imaginary conversations with Eleanor Roosevelt at Houston’s suggestion.

“(But) that was maybe four minutes out of hours and hours of conversation,” she said.

In his new book “The Choice,” Woodward wrote that Houston, co-director of the Foundation of Mind Research, urged Mrs. Clinton to write “It Takes a Village,” and assisted extensively in rewrites. Houston said that she did help edit the book, but that Mrs. Clinton “wrote that book entirely.”

Houston said she made the suggestion to hold the imaginary conversations with Mrs. Roosevelt and others “to focus her busy mind on issues that surrounded the book.”

“That was it,” Houston said. “No spooks. No seances. Nothing. She’s the least psychic person I’ve known, and I’m a close second. … I don’t have a psychic bone in my body.”

Mrs. Clinton wrote about her imaginary conversations with Eleanor Roosevelt in her June 10 syndicated column. She said she talked to Roosevelt about the role of a first lady. “She usually responds by telling me to buck up, or at least to grow skin as thick as a rhinoceros,” Mrs. Clinton wrote.

Reporters grew to realize this was a silly little flap 12 years ago, but if there’s one thing we’ve learned, especially when it comes to the Clintons, the media has a way of coming up with new little flaps all the time.

I wonder if her sessions with the spiritual adviser cost more than John Edwards’ haircuts.

  • She is not schizophrenic.

    Kudos on the correct usages of this disorder, Steve. As someone who has a degree in psychology, it maddens me to no end when movies and television mis-identify dissociative identity disorder (aka DID or multiple personalities) as schizophrenia.

    Gold star.

    Back to the topic, sigh. Did Jake Tapper write regurgitate the article?

  • Having imaginary conversations with people who aren’t there isn’t unusual. I regularly lob curses at Benjamin Franklin as stress relief.

  • Hence my aversion to believe anything the MSM has to say about HRC.

    Our 4th estate is dead and buried. And we are so much poorer for it.

    Fuck corporate media.o

  • In this election, it’s sometimes difficult to distinguish among the media’s manufactured flaps and Clinton’s manufactured flaps. Thanks to CB for setting the record straight on this one.

  • I once bet a friend I could start an Internet smear on Drudge, and I sent this quote from Edwards that was out of contest under the title, “Edwards crosses over”. It was from his closing argument in the case with the girl who got her intestines sucked out, where he said something along the lines of hearing the girl talking to him, what she would say. I sent it to all the usual suspects, but no one seemed to fall for it. Though later, Coulter kept referencing this weird spirit channelling thing of Edwards, referring to that quote, so, who knows?

    This seems like a similar smear. I’d like to take credit for it, even though I lost the bet.

  • What kind of media scrutiny does Huck get when he asks himself, “What would Jesus do?”

    There is nothing wrong with communing with the souls of great women. It’s kind of like praying. It’s only a problem when the great women (or God) start talking back.

  • Even die-hard Obama fans have to admit Hillary suffers a lot of abuse and liberties taken at her expense by the press. She gets no free passes.

    Echoing Okie, nor does the press questions Bush’s assertions of divine guidance as a pathology, or at the very least, a cop-out.

  • ABC News — Tapper, the movies aimed at fundies (Narnia), the rewriting of history in their 9/11 drama, directed by a guy who graduated from one of these think tank things meant to produce Christian directors to undermine the homosexual agenda of Hollywood from the inside, now this.

    Is there any question who they’re sucking up to?

  • I am channeling Barbara Jordan as I type and what I am hearing is “Go with the black guy. It’s time!”

  • OMG! I’m hearing from someone who sounds exactly like MLK. He seems to be saying he has a dream. Something about a black man being elected president forty years after his death. In the background, I can hear music. You probably won’t believe this but it sounds like Oprah singing “I Second That Emotion.”

  • This is pretty strange. Now LBJ is insisting I tell Hillary that he put his legacy on the line for the Civil Rights Bill, not the ERA.

  • I hear the ghost of Walter Cronkite…

    He’s cussing his ass off at the “media” we have now. Oh wait… now he’s throwing up.

  • There’s a reason our Founding Fathers didn’t want to legalize corporations.

    A fact that the Republican’ts don’t often note. But then the Republicans (their more sensible predicessors) fought a war over the stupidity that the Founding Fathers did put in the constitution. So maybe there are reasons they only quote the FF’s occasionally.

    No Corporate ownership of any media!

  • At least all you folks get to hear cool people. Warren G. Harding won’t leave me alone…he complains a lot about about the “hooting of suffering civilization”, and i try to tell him that it doesn’t count if his speech writer made up the phrase. He’s not a very good listener. Every time i try to talk about MY problems, he just professes his innocence about Teapot Dome or goes on some rambling, esoteric lecture about Free Masonry.

    I wish that Eleanor would visit my head, just once, and kick his ass. He knew he wasn’t fit for the office of President, i don’t know what makes him think that he’s fit for taking up office in my head. On the other hand, he’s pretty cuddly once you get to know him.

  • HRC is no Richards or Jordan, imho. On the other hand, this is NOT what I would call playing the gender card. They were both very admirable liberals. I almost puked when I heard W beat Richards, just about, if not, the most popular TX governor ever.

  • Racer X: That isn’t Walter Cronkite’s ghost that you hear. Walter is still with us.

    It’s probably Edward R. Murrow.

  • Were these the same voices that were whispering to Multiple Choice Mitt in the Republican debate?

    If so, that could explain his varying positions — it all depends on who’s talking to him that day.

  • Comments are closed.