Compassionate conservatism — Katrina style

Apparently, on the second anniversary of Hurricane Katrina ravaging the Gulf Coast, conservatives have decided they don’t want to talk about it anymore.

GOP presidential hopeful Rep. Tom Tancredo (Colo.) said Friday it is “time the taxpayer gravy train left the New Orleans station” and urged an end to the federal aid to the region that was devastated by Hurricane Katrina two years ago.

“The amount of money that has been wasted on these so-called ‘recovery’ efforts has been mind-boggling,” said Tancredo, who is running a long-shot presidential campaign. “Enough is enough.” […]

“At some point, state and local officials and individuals have got to step up to the plate and take some initiative,” said Tancredo. “The mentality that people can wait around indefinitely for the federal taxpayer to solve all their worldly problems has got to come to an end.”

That would be the same federal government, of course, that neglected the victims before the storm hit, as the storm hit, after the storm hit, and for the two subsequent years that followed. Indeed, for all the rhetoric we’ve heard, as of this week, “none of the 115 ‘critical priority projects’ identified by city officials” for publicly funded rebuilding efforts “has been completed.” Of the $34 billion “earmarked for long-term rebuilding,” less than half “has made its way through federal checks and balances to reach municipal projects.”

But apparently the victims and those who care about their plight are supposed to quit their bellyaching. What’s more, it’s not just Tancredo.

Over at Townhall, John Hawkins offered this jaw-dropper.

Two years after Katrina, everywhere you turn, there are people carping, whining, and kvetching. Just why hasn’t the pity party for the citizens of New Orleans run out of booze and chips yet?

It’s not as if hurricanes are a once a millennium event in the United States. In fact, residents of Florida have so many of them that they don’t even cancel a barbecue for anything under a Category 3.

Moreover, people lose their homes in this country every day of the year. If it isn’t a hurricane, it’s an earthquake. If it isn’t an earthquake, it’s a tornado. If it isn’t a tornado, it’s a fire. If it isn’t a fire, it’s a flood. Yet nobody sits and frets about John Doe, age 58, who lost his house in a flash flood two years ago or Jane Doe, age 60, who had her house blown away by a twister back in 2005.

But, we’re all supposed to eternally sit around and weep tiny little tears of sadness for the people who really took it on the chin in a hurricane because they chose to live in a city shaped like a soup bowl on the coast. Let me tell all the citizens of New Orleans something that should have been told to them 18 months ago: it’s time to stop playing the sympathy card and get over it.

Nobody is owed a living for the rest of his life because he had a bad break two years ago. Yet, we still have people affected by Katrina who have FEMA paying their rent. How sad and pathetic is it that these shiftless people are still leaching off their fellow citizens? Since when is being in the path of a hurricane supposed to give you a permanent “Get Out of Work Free” card?

If I hadn’t seen it, I wouldn’t believe it.

“The amount of money that has been wasted on these so-called ‘recovery’ efforts has been mind-boggling,” said Tancredo, who is running a long-shot presidential campaign. “Enough is enough.”

That’s laughable that he’s trying to make himself popular attacking hurricane Katrina survivors.

  • “At some point, state and local officials and individuals have got to step up to the plate and take some initiative,” said Tancredo. “The mentality that people can wait around indefinitely for the federal taxpayer to solve all their worldly problems has got to come to an end.”

    This is the Iraq recipe. Hopefully an insurgency won’t break out in the Big Easy. Tancredo is doing Big Easy Chair quarterbacking.

  • I would agree with Tom Tancredo in “a small way.” Several states–usually Southern–under-tax their citizens and businesses, while depending on federal funding and services to provide what most states do for themselves. Pennsylvania, for example, has an income tax and “a rainy day fund” (to draw on when the economy contracts and lessens revenue); Tennessee, I believe, has neither! What state you live in does matter. The less flexibility (adequate revenue and budget control) a state has, the more likely that a state is less well run. All states are not equal.

  • I’m guessing John Hawkins was never in New Orleans right after Katrina, nor has he been there any time since, hasn’t bothered to read some of the first-hand accounts of what life has been like there in the last two years, hasn’t watched any of the video reports, hasn’t done one moment of research on why it is that things are still a mess there – but, hey – what difference would it make if he had?

    Most of us have the ability to place ourselves in the shoes of those who have suffered such a devastating experience, to look around at our nice homes and neighborhoods, and try to imagine what we would do, who would help us, how we would manage, if everything we owned had been destroyed, and so had everything else in the vicinity. That’s where compassion comes from, but it is an exercise that Hawkins and Tancredo do not engage in. I’m sure they not only believe that nothing that terrible could ever happen to them, but that it only happens to those who somehow deserve it. I have to think that because this also involves, to a large extent, both poor people and black people, that Tancredo and Hawkins feel even more certain that this two-years-and-ongoing debacle is a waste of time and money.

    If ever I am tempted to wish to be someone other than who I am, I will stop and consider that I could wind up being someone like these two heartless, thoughtless and selfish people. No, thanks.

  • I would say that Mohammed has a lot to answer for. Jesus never led no cavalry charges.(He didn’t exactly charge up old Calvary hill either.)

  • Damn, I hope Tancredo keeps talking, and somehow gets that long-shot G.O.P. nomination for president. Even Dennis Kucinich would win in a landslide.

  • Fixing our country is a waste, but sending our people and our money to some other country to blow it apart and get our people killed is good.

    Just how stupid do they think America is?

  • Having been through a major flood myself, the most frustrating part was the people that promised to help and then didn’t deliver, whether friends, local businesses, government, (FEMA, SBA etc). So I can’t begin to imagine after all the promises of help from Bushco how the people of New Orleans feel now that the help they needed to restore their homes and lives hasn’t materialized. And you have a complete wanker like Tancredo gleefully rubbiing salt in the wounds! Has this man no compassion or moral compass? And he wants to lead this country, to what might I ask?

    The most rewaring part of my flood experience was receiving help and support from people that didn’t need to or hadn’t made promises except to themselves that whenever other people needed help, and they were in a position to help, they would. The old lady from Ohio who had driven hundreds of miles to help the on the Red Cross feed truck. The business man in the next village who just turned up to pump out the basement and wouldn’t accept any anything in return but our thanks. These are real Americans and I hope on day soon they will all realize that they should not have to apologize for their government. Their government will reflect who they are, a government for the people, by the people.

  • “The amount of money that has been wasted on these so-called ‘recovery’ efforts has been mind-boggling,” said Tancredo,

    Well, to a certain extent, he’s right. I read just recently — I think in NYT, though can’t find the article and the quote now — that a big chunk of the money which was supposed to have gone towards NO recovery had been used to build luxury condos near the university of Tuscaloosa, Alabama. So the term “so-called recovery” applies, just as “wasted” applies. That the people of NO didn’t see a penny of it? Who cares? They make good victims to dump your bile on. Could never have afforded those luxury condos in the first place, the shiftless so-and-sos.

  • Unfortunately Tancredo is right, but the corruption train hit the ground running when Bush took control of the so-called Katrina recovery. The immediate expulsion of Louisiana citizens followed by the mass importation of illegal labors by sleazy subcontractors was only the beginning of the “gravy train” that drained millions of dollars from federal funds and donations from Americans across the country believing that money was going to rebuild their neighborhoods. Well that money is been pocketed by best and brightest con artists on the block.

  • slip kid @3
    Like you, I’d actually agree with Tancredo a little if any of the aid he claimed went to N.O. for two years actually got there.

    Maryland has applied for drought relief. (I’m a Marylander)
    Dang, does no one prepare for inevitable setbacks?
    Are our local government’s so incompetent at planning ahead?

    Some schmucks in my own county are asking for government handouts for sewage systems since their septic systems don’t work anymore. I’d support building shacks for them with little moons carved in the door. After that, pound sand, you parasites. You want your 15 acres and fresh country air? Live the life that used to go with it.

    Don’t even get me started on “disability”.

  • I find it very interesting that these “compassionate” conservatives think that only poor and “shiftless” people were effected by Katrina. I’m white, college educated, insured, employed and I live and work in New Orleans. My life and the lives of everyone that I know have been forever altered by this storm. I don’t care if so called conservatives have any empathy for me or not. I just hope that when Colorado burns from wildfires or reels from avalanches that they don’t come crying to me for my tax dollars.

  • Pingback: da066378b873
  • Comments are closed.