CPB investigation shows Tomlinson broke the law

Ken Tomlinson’s partisan, ideological, and generally ridiculous work as chairman of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting helped lead to his recent resignation from the CPB. But what we didn’t know before now is just how much Tomlinson violated the law.

The former chairman of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting broke federal law and repeatedly violated the organization’s rules and code of ethics in his efforts to promote conservatives in the system, an endeavor that included consultation with White House officials, according to the findings of an internal investigation made public Tuesday.

The 67-page report — the culmination of a six-month investigation by Kenneth A. Konz, the corporation’s inspector general — portrays former Chairman Kenneth Y. Tomlinson as a rogue appointee who often exceeded his authority in his determination to address what he viewed as a liberal tilt in public broadcasting.

Among Tomlinson’s transgressions, the former CPB chairman coordinated some employment decisions with White House officials, including Karl Rove, as part of a drive to hire a former Republican Party co-chairwoman. (Tomlinson had previously told reporters he had had “absolutely no contact from anyone at the White House.”) The scheming, Konz said, appears to have run afoul of the Federal Broadcasting Act, which prohibits the use of “political tests” in employment.

For that matter, the law prohibits the CPB chairman from interfering with public broadcast programming, but that didn’t stop Tomlinson from promoting the development of “The Journal Editorial Report,” featuring right-wing commentary from the editorial board of the Wall Street Journal. In fact, Tomlinson had no qualms about pushing PBS to broadcast the program while advising Paul Gigot about the program’s format.

The LA Times even noted that Tomlinson was “so zealous in what he termed his pursuit of political balance that he instructed corporation staff to threaten to withhold federal funds from PBS to achieve it,” despite the fact that he didn’t actually have that power.

What bears repeating now, however, is that Tomlinson continues to have a key administration role.

With all the attention given to Tomlinson’s humiliating, amateurish hackery at the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, it’s easy to forget that Karl Rove also made Tomlinson the head of the Broadcasting Board of Governors, an independent government commission that oversees the Voice of America (VOA), Radio Free Europe/Radio Free Liberty, and Radio Sawa and its sister TV network, Alhurra — making him a key person in America’s international diplomacy.

As Franklin Foer explained in a very good TNR piece in August, Tomlinson has run the BBG just as he ran the CPB, “purging the bureaucracy of political enemies, zealously rooting out perceived ‘liberal bias,’ and generally politicizing institutions that have resisted ideological intrusions for decades.”

And as of earlier this month, as if Tomlinson hadn’t done enough, it got worse.

Kenneth Y. Tomlinson, the head of the federal agency that oversees most government broadcasts to foreign countries, including the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe, is the subject of an inquiry into accusations of misuse of federal money and the use of phantom or unqualified employees, officials involved in that examination said on Friday.

How long will the White House stand by this clown? Are his ties with Rove that significant?

It seems to work two ways. Either the Republicans actually do the wrongdoing they have accused Democrats of. Or they accuse Democrats of doing what the Republicans are actually wrongdoing.

The wingnuts’ belief system has a lot of holes in it. Assholes.

  • Assholes. Agreed. But think of all of the material for campaign advertisements for the next two election cycles. A simple one will be to just show “mug shot” type pictures of each one of these scumbags with a brief recitation of their position in the GOP/government and their crime, and to just roll this down the screen, and then ask the pubic why they would ever vote republican, or something short and snappy.

    Also, OT, here is aletter to the editor of the NY Times I wrote yesterday morning right after I read its editorial on bush’s revisionism. Thought I would share it here as the NY Times will likely not print it:

    To the Editor:

    The NY Times is to be commended on its straight forward analysis of the Bush Administration’s efforts to deceive the public once again regarding Iraq. As Mr. Bush has stated: “Fool me once, shame on–shame on you. Fool me–you can’t get fooled again.” We can only hope all Americans are not fooled again by these shameless hucksters. But the NY Times editorial staff must also be chastised for its own attempts to “rewrite history,” or to at least bury it, regarding the Times’ contribution to the original deception. Its writers, particularly Judith Miller regarding WMD, and William Safire regarding the Prague meeting, were at the center of the storm in pushing the administration’s absurdities. A full accounting by the NY Times has not yet occurred either. Maybe the Times can set an example for this truth-averse administration.

    Respectfully,

  • I think it is worth recalling what the CPB had to say at the time about the Tomilison resignation.

    In announcing Tomlinson’s departure yesterday, the CPB added a curious addendum: “The board does not believe that Mr. Tomlinson acted maliciously or with any intent to harm CPB or public broadcasting, and the board recognizes that Mr. Tomlinson strongly disputes the findings in the soon-to-be-released Inspector General’s report. The board expresses its disappointment in the performance of former key staff whose responsibility it was to advise the board and its members.”

    To understand why the board would take this position, consider the following.

    Despite his departure, the CPB remains firmly controlled by conservatives. Tomlinson’s successor as chairman, Cheryl F. Halpern, is a longtime contributor to Republicans, including President Bush and Sen. Trent Lott (Miss.). Its vice chairman, Gay Hart Gaines, another Republican contributor, was a founder and former chairman of GOPAC, a powerful GOP fundraising group

    The board wants to save Tomilinson’s ass. CBP isn’t out of

  • I still want to know about that mysterious ‘consultant’ that Tomlinson hired whose only known address was a Hallmark card store. No one has ever been able to find him that I know of and I, for one, would very much like to know exactly who he is. His data was probably fabricated to begin with, and if the man himself was a phantom created by Tomlinson or others then it just gets worse.

    Anybody get any info on him? A photo, live interview, anything?

  • If you mean the guy who monitored “Now” his name is Fred Mann. Here’s an NYT article about him. From the article:

    Until last year, Mr. Mann worked at the National Journalism Center, which for the last few years has been run by the Young America’s Foundation. The foundation describes itself on its Web site as “the principal outreach organization of the conservative movement” and as being committed to the ideas of “individual freedom, a strong national defense, free enterprise and traditional values.”

  • Thanks, Link, that was really helpful. I still wish somebody would get Mr. Mann into a hearing room on the record, but tht will probably never happen. Such a pity.

  • Comments are closed.