Friedman, Broder help shift the conventional wisdom

In the world of professional punditry, heavy-hitters like [tag]David Broder[/tag] and [tag]Thomas Friedman[/tag] not only help reflect the [tag]conventional wisdom[/tag], they help shape it. The mainstream political world considers their opinions as the most serious and credible perspectives in the country, and in turn, their points of view become synonymous with sensibility.

And right now, both want out of [tag]Iraq[/tag].

Yesterday, Broder, the “dean” of DC’s political reporters, strongly suggested the need to withdraw U.S. troops from Iraq, arguing that the “logic of prolonging the agony” can no longer withstand scrutiny.

Today, [tag]Friedman[/tag], whose name has become synonymous with an overly-patient approach to the war, is finally fed up as well.

It is now obvious that we are not midwifing democracy in Iraq. We are baby-sitting a civil war.

When our top commander in Iraq, Gen. John Abizaid, tells a Senate Committee, as he did yesterday, that “the sectarian violence is probably as bad as I’ve seen it,” it means that three years of efforts to democratize Iraq are not working. That means “staying the course” is pointless, and it’s time to start thinking about Plan B — how we might disengage with the least damage possible.

It seemed to me over the last three years that, even with all the Bush team’s missteps, we had to give our Iraqi partners a chance to produce a transitional government, then write a constitution, then hold an election and then, finally, put together their first elected cabinet. But now they have done all of that — and the situation has only worsened.

Friedman concludes, “The longer we maintain a unilateral failing strategy in Iraq, the harder it will be to build such a coalition, and the stronger the enemies of freedom will become.”

Welcome to the new sensible, centrist position on Iraq. The political mainstream has finally caught up with the Democratic mainstream. It’s about time.

Plan B – Abort the mission. It’ll probably have as much trouble getting by the Republicans as the pill by the same name has.

It’s amazing how many lives can be lost while people finally come around to the centrist position.

  • Oh come ON, Tom, maybe in as little as six months they will see us as liberators, and embrace the flat-earth mythology you have spewed for so long.

    /sNARk

    I would sentence Tom Friedman to reading his earlier “cheerleader” columns to a room full of Iraq war veterans with loaded weapons.

    If he could survive that, I would welcome him to the “angry left”.

  • The wheels of the universe grind slowly, but grind they do. For Friedman, anyway, it looks like the six months is finally up.

  • That smug prick Tom Friedman can blow it out his ass. I’ve seen him too many times on TDS and other TV news programs spouting the same optimistic bullshit with that all knowing smug attitude of his to say join the club. I’d rather kick that smug attitude out of the pompous blowhard instead.

    He’s like the lobster in the pot and only realizes something’s wrong when his shell turns a bright red. A lot of unwise unsmug naysayers said this was going to be a big shit sandwich (many from day one) and he still didn’t believe.

    I agree with racerx on his punishment. I doubt it will happen, but it’s a “nice” thought.

  • Friedman:

    “…and the stronger the enemies of freedom will become.”

    That phrase shows that Tommy is still drinking the koolaid.
    Albeit… at half rations…

  • I read in the paper this morning that the Regal Moron has spent 381 days on vacation at the Crawford “ranch” (which has no cattle). Of course, all he does when he is “at work” is ride bicycles and fall out couches while watching TeeVee.

    I’m amazed it’s taken anyone — least of all these two fuzz-brains — five years to cast a reasonable judgement on the Bush Crime Family and its operations.

  • Broder and Friedman are now merely making attempts to save what’s left of their sorry reputations–revisionists just like the war criminals they have propped up for the past three years. I call “bullshite” on them.

  • Friedman is a more serious version of Peggy Noonan. David Broder talks to himself. Where have these two been while the Republicans have turned America into an Orwellian mindfuck?

    Republicans and their Hannity/Limbaugh mouthpieces have almost come to the point of trashing cookbooks as leftist media because they contain phrases like “apply liberally.” And not a peep from the “watchdogs” of the press. Any pundit not screaming “impeachment!” hasn’t been paying attention.

    A day late and $300 billion short.

  • Professional pundits like Friedman and Broder will beside themselves when “Jumping Joe” Lieberman loses.

    Can we all then go to Vegas and bet against anything they say?

  • Friedman is merely co-opting what we’ve known to be the truth for quite some time. All he needed was for Daddy Abizaid to give him permission to say so.

    Broder is a supercilious old fart with ego problems.

    Who really pays any attention to them?

  • Iraq is a catastrophic foreign policy debacle. It has alienated us from our allies and generated hatred among Muslims across the world. It has weakened our military, forcing our troops into an extended occupation in the midst of a growing civil war for which they have neither appetite nor training. It is a recruiting boon for al-Qaida. It has sorely weakened our foreign policy influence, as demonstrated graphically in the current conflict in Lebanon. It has cost nearly 2,700 American lives, over 20,000 Americans wounded — and an estimated 50,000 Iraqi deaths. It has compromised our budget priorities, spending about $300 billion already — with the estimated cost likely to exceed $1 trillion. The budget is a statement of our moral choices — and this is a deeply immoral choice. Hey Tom, can we cut and run from this mess.

  • I don’t know how anyone alive during Vietnam couldn’t have known the disaster Iraq was from DAY ONE. Sadly, all these “pundits” are complicit in the crime and anything they say now is too little, too late. The only thing the Friedmann column was good for is a script for the Bush Sadministration when they bow out. Rationalization as to how this wasn’t really, maybe someday, a complete, foreseeable catastrophe.

  • As the purveyor and creator of conventional wisdom, David Broder (and most of the msm) has consistently said that the Democrats are weak on defense. The opposite is true. The Republicans have decimated the Army along with it’s image world wide all the while running up a huge defense bill with their corporate welfare program. The National Guard is in shambles. Bill Clinton managed to prosecute a war in Kosovo with one US causalty. Broder et.al. don’t understand national defense, which btw includes a strong balance of trade and economy, and have continued parroting the “conventional wisdom” that Republicans are strong and Democrats weak on defense.

  • They once were lost but now are found, and blind but now they see. I’m with frak; anyone alive during Vietnam should have seen this one comming from miles away, and both these “wise men” were very much alive. Who cares what those morons think? It was guys like that who enabled Bush & Co. to do their damage. If tht is what passes for wisdom in the MSM, lord help us all.

  • Plan B – Abort the mission. It’ll probably have as much trouble getting by the Republicans as the pill by the same name has.
    Comment by Dale

    Unfortunately, (the other) “plan B” has to be applied within 72 hours of possible conception to be effective, so Friedman is a tiny tad too late. Like, maybe, 3 yrs+. If one were to continue the parallel, the little monster has had plenty of time to gestate and is now walking, talking, and throwing tantrums like any other “terrible two”.

  • Comments are closed.