TPM posted a clip on Friday of Rudy Giuliani screaming “bullsh*t” at a police union rally in 1992. Surprisingly, several leading conservative blogs complained bitterly, questioning the significance of the video.
At first blush, the clip appears to reinforce concerns about Giuliani’s temperament, but even more important was the context in which the comments were made. As Greg Sargent explained, a lengthy piece in the New York Times today helps clarify exactly why Giuliani’s outburst matters.
…Mr. Giuliani took a fateful step that would for years prompt questions about his racial sensitivities. In September 1992, he spoke to a rally of police officers protesting Mr. Dinkins’s proposal for a civilian board to review police misconduct.
It was a rowdy, often threatening, crowd. Hundreds of white off-duty officers drank heavily, and a few waved signs like “Dump the Washroom Attendant,” a reference to Mr. Dinkins. A block away from City Hall, Mr. Giuliani gave a fiery address, twice calling Mr. Dinkins’s proposal “bullshit.” The crowd cheered. Mr. Giuliani was jubilant.
“If you’re acculturated to like cops, you don’t necessarily see 10,000 white guys who don’t vote in the city, don’t write political checks and love you for the wrong reason,” an aide said. He spoke on condition of anonymity because he is working with the Giuliani presidential campaign.
Mr. Dinkins has not forgotten that sea of angry cops. “Rudy was out there inciting white cops to riot,” Mr. Dinkins said in a recent interview.
A year later, Giuliani asked aides to identify potential pitfalls for his mayoral campaign. The “vulnerability study” cited Giuliani’s “shrieking performance,” and noted that he had inexplicably failed to denounce those who levied racist attacks on Dinkins.
That’s why the video clip is important, not because of a candidate’s profanity, which is hardly a disqualifier in a presidential race, but because Giuliani’s speech appears to have been an attempt to stoke racist animus against an African-American mayor.
For that matter, it speaks to something of a pattern: Rudy Giuliani has a difficult past when it comes to race relations.
In the years to come, Mr. Giuliani would rebuff not just the histrionic Mr. Sharpton but nearly every high-ranking black official in the city, even those of moderate politics: congressmen, a state comptroller, influential ministers.
But grabbing hold of the race dial proved easier than turning it to his will.
“I never thought Rudy Giuliani was a racist,” said Fran Reiter, one of Mr. Giuliani’s deputy mayors. “But he was obsessed with the notion there were certain groups he couldn’t win over. And he wasn’t even going to try.”
Black leaders, Mr. Giuliani said in 1994, had to “learn how to discipline themselves in the way in which they speak” if they expected to chat with him. The city’s welfare-state philosophy, he said later, was racist and “enslaved” black New Yorkers.
Michael Meyers, president of the New York Civil Rights Coalition, who once advised Giuliani, acknowledged that the former mayor “could play on the edge of old racial antipathies.”
As the campaign progresses, expect this to become more and more important.
