‘Just a comma’

I’ll have the transcript up as soon as CNN posts it, but George W. Bush appeared on “Late Edition with Wolf Blitzer” this afternoon and made one of those stunning remarks that could — or rather, should — become a political problem for the White House.

Blitzer asked the president to respond to the nightmare that Iraq has become, but Bush wouldn’t hear of it. He dismissed the ongoing crisis as “just a comma.”

Update: Here’s the transcript:

BLITZER: Let’s move on and talk a little bit about Iraq. Because this is a huge, huge issue, as you know, for the American public, a lot of concern that perhaps they are on the verge of a civil war, if not already a civil war…. We see these horrible bodies showing up, tortured, mutilation. The Shia and the Sunni, the Iranians apparently having a negative role. Of course, al Qaeda in Iraq is still operating.

BUSH: Yes, you see — you see it on TV, and that’s the power of an enemy that is willing to kill innocent people. But there’s also an unbelievable will and resiliency by the Iraqi people…. Admittedly, it seems like a decade ago. I like to tell people when the final history is written on Iraq, it will look like just a comma because there is — my point is, there’s a strong will for democracy. (emphasis added)

Even by Bush’s already-low standards, it was a stunning comment. We’re talking about a war that has claimed 2,700 American lives and seriously injured 20,000 more. It’s a crisis that has, by any reasonable measure, made the threat of terrorism against Americans considerably worse. It’s a misadventure that has cost taxpayers hundreds of billions of dollars, to fight a war sold under false pretenses, and mismanaged with almost child-like incompetence.

Asked to explain himself, the president is unconcerned. Everything we’re seeing is “just a comma.” I’m sure that will bring comfort to the families of those who have sacrificed so much for Bush’s mistakes.

Now, I think I know what the president means. As he sees it, history takes a long view, so three and a half years of mistakes, violence, poor judgment, and corruption are minor details that will be easily overlooked by a long-term triumph. Or so Bush says. Of course, by this logic, everything is “just a comma.” Every life, every conflict, and every generation can be dismissed and made to appear trivial by backing up enough degrees.

It is, in other words, the ultimate cop out. Conditions in Iraq are getting worse, not better. The attacks are growing, not shrinking. The casualty rate is going up, not down. More than ever, we’re looking to the president for leadership, sound judgment, and clear answers.

Instead, we get, “just a comma.” Amazing.

Second Update: C&L has the video.

He means that all this tragedy so far will seem like just a comma after he’s through. Iran, anyone?

He’s a forward-thinking chap.

  • Think Progress has the video entire Clinton smackdown of Chris Wallace and FauxNews. Some one should edit together a comparison of how Bush handles himself when challenged with how Clinton does. It could make a powerful 537 ad.

  • BUSH: Yes, you see — you see it on TV, and that’s the power of an enemy that is willing to kill innocent people.

    IRAQI: Yes, you see — you see it on TV, and that’s the power of an enemy that is willing to kill innocent people.

  • Maybe he meant he’s been in a coma. That does make sense of many of his actions and he’s world renown for his misunderestimatednoncommunicatedlying. So I suppose its most likely that CNN just messed up the transcript.

  • Iran, anyone?

    He’s a forward-thinking chap.

    Comment by kvenlander

    Let’s us know when you’re going over. Oh wait you’re too smart and valuable to fight or get killed…send some other patriotic sucker over there.

  • Every life, every conflict, and every generation can be dismissed and made to appear trivial by backing up enough degrees.

    Good point. If we wish to view this grotesque Iraq war as a comma, George Bush and his neocons are just the tiny sliver of blank space above that comma.

    Maybe Bush is right. He might prefer to see his name written out of the history books rather than being credited with the torture, death and shame he has personally brought into the world. Here, then, is George Bush’s legacy: [ ]

  • Bush thinks God directs his actions. Therefore anything he does is divinely sanctioned. Criticism is blasphemy. Changing course amounts to lack of faith. Thus the “comma” remark. God told him to “smite Saddam”, he did so, and God will cover the consequences.

    BTW this is “magical thinking” not religious practice. It’s the type of attitude one finds in teenage converts, cult members, and psychiatric patients. Or at board meetings of The Washington Times.

  • Well, I think an exclamation point is too damn decent, not ‘aggressive” or “alternative” enough.

    I opt for a big, fat question mark, rounded end first, with the hook part sharpened so that when he tries to pull it out…. he might get some idea of torture is like. Just an edumakashumal experience for him, that’s all.

  • Bush puts a lot of faith in how history will treat him and his Iraq policy. He is mistaken. The criticism he gets now will be nothing compared to the criticism he will get from historians when they take a look back at the Iraq mess that he will leave his successor. He doesn’t even have real support for the Iraq policy now. He just has the cult-like support of followers who rally around him because that is what cult followers do.

  • The comma thing sounds like something Rummy would say. Bush was probably parroting something he heard in a cabinet meeting.

  • Wow. Arguably the biggest stragetic blunder in centuries — and George calls it a “comma”?

    This man is delusional.

  • Did he sound like he was going over railroad tracks when he said it? You know,

    It,will,look,just,like,a,com,ma

    Pak,is.tan,is,a,sov,er,eign,na,shee,un

    Spoken very quickly?

  • We need to also consider Iraqi civilian deaths. These are people largely like you and me – they simply want to work and raise their families. Instead they’ve been subject to…this.

    Iraq Body Count estimates 43,000 Iraqi civilian deaths. The BBC estimate is “between 10,000 and 37,000”. Let’s be (very) conservative and go with 15,000 deaths.

    The population of Iraq (which is quite obviously dwindling) is around 26 million. The population of the US is around 295 million. So…extrapolating the 15,000 deaths figure, that’s the equivalent of over 170,000 American civilian deaths.

    Now, any theories as to why we are more hated than ever in the Muslim world? Any idea why this recent intelligence study indicated that the Iraq war is fueling terrorism, rather than squelching it?

  • Somebody needs to rip Bush a new semi-colon. BTW, since this item was posted 2 more US deaths have been added to bring the total to 2,702. To see this number in the context of events, go to my U.S. Military Deaths in Bush’s Iraq Quagmire . If it weren’t labeled, I would suspect the graph described a purely mechanical process, like automobiles manufactured. Very strange how steady the pace has been.

  • “Iran, anyone?

    He’s a forward-thinking chap.

    Comment by kvenlander

    Let’s us know when you’re going over. Oh wait you’re too smart and valuable to fight or get killed…send some other patriotic sucker over there.

    Comment by AO — 9/24/2006 @ 2:14 pm ”

    Uh, kvenldander was being sarcastic, AO.

  • I think what Bush was trying to say is, “You think Iraq is a mess? That’s nothing. Wait til we do Iran.”

  • Lets see, 9/11 will not be a comma, while the Iraq occupation that has killed more Americans than 9/11 will?

  • We all aught to be thanking our lucky stars for GWB. We couldn’t have INVENTED a better example of why the conservative movement is morally bankrupt.

    For years we’ve been trying to warn the American people that this was the logical outcome if conservatives were allowed to run the country. Now we not only have our boogeyman, we have solid proof that these people are incapable of leading this country anywhere but into the toilet.

    GWB has, at the least, set the conservative movement and the Kristian Nationalists back 50 years. More likely he has destroyed them forever.

  • Put that quote alongside Comrade Stalin’s:

    “A single death is a tragedy; a million deaths is a statistic”

    So now we know what the intermediate figure amounts to.

  • I too think MonkeyBoy meant to say ‘footnote’ but because he’s a brain-dead moron, it came out as ‘comma’.

  • A classic Ozymandius moment for Bush. Pre-psychotic grandiosity grabbing hold, the sweaty center beginning to fall away, blood pounding in his ears obscuring what his own words mean. History his only finger hold. Look out below!

  • How bad will things have to be before the disaster that is our tenure in Iraq will be possible to overlook, just a comma?

    Is he suggesting that someday the history book will read “Though the global cataclysm that nearly destroyed our species (which we now refer to as The Dying) began with a small war of aggression, it wasn’t until that war spiralled into a broader regional conflict that things really got bad.” ?

  • ***if 100,000 dead Iraqis is a comma, what would Bush’s death be?***
    ————————————–

    When that happens, r€nato, the first round is on me. Period. No “comma,” no “semicolon,” and no “question mark.” Just plain “Period.”

    Mass quantities of exclamation marks, however, are both thoroughly permitted, and VERY highly encouraged….

  • I think he meant burp.Is it true that all interview questions have to be submitted three days ahead? And they do it? What an inspiration for fledgling democracies everywhere?

  • re #9 –
    What kind of an attitude is that – you sound so hateful! I’ll go out on a limb here and guess:.. um, neo-con?

  • “Comma, comma, Chameleon.
    I’m a man with conviction
    I’m a man who doesn’t know
    How to sell a contradiction
    You come and go
    You come and go ”

    Boy George.

    No amount of stupid could pardon this much evil.

  • And all those soldiers (and civilians) who have died? Their life stories don’t have commas now. They have a period. Over.

    This insensitive, stupid statement should be the centerpiece of a thousand campaign commercials.

  • I’m sure this is how Junior is being briefed on Iraq right now.

    No one is allowed to tell Junior he fucked up real bad, but they have to tell him something.

    So his briefings are all like, “Iraqi People Striving for Democracy (and a few people got killed) But Victory is Inevitable.”

    I’m sure he’s being told that the march of freedom is unstoppable and after things turn around and the ME becomes a liberal democracy because of his boldness and resoluteness, then history will crown him the heir of Churchill.

    He’s not making this up, it’s what he’s being told.

  • This reminds me quite a lot of Scrooge in Dickens A Christmas Carol. The part at which he praises the efficacy of famine at “reducing the surplus population” and the part at which the Ghost of Christmas Present sneers Scrooge’s words back at him when Scrooge takes mercy on Tiny Tim. Followed:

    Scrooge hung his head to hear his own words quoted by the Spirit, and was overcome with penitence and grief. ‘Man,’ said the Ghost, ‘if man you be in heart, not adamant, forbear that wicked cant until you have discovered What the surplus is, and Where it is. Will you decide what men shall live, what men shall die? It may be, that in the sight of Heaven, you are more worthless and less fit to live than millions like this poor man’s child.’

    That crack about breaking eggs to make an omelet sounds a bit different to an egg.

  • Ed in 21 and T Paine already had much the same reaction as me but I’m repeating mine anyway: whether or not the Iraq Invasion gets viewed as a comma, Bush is going down in history as the end of a colon.

    And yes, I too think he must have meant coda. Or something. Along the same theme of presidential illiteracy, I’m waiting for someone in Iraq to protest that they absolutely have no plans for “nucular” weapons.

    How do people look up to this lying incompetent jackass?

    The following is from p.256 of a great book called “Chances Are” (which is almost worth the price for the authors’ photograph alone). “In 1845, Paraguay passed into the hands of Francisco Solano Lopez. Plump, flattered to be told he resembled Bonaparte, he felt destiny strong upon him. In 1865, Lopez provoked simultaneous wars with Argentina and Brazil; Uruguay joined a Triple Alliance against him. What followed was one of the bloodiest conflicts on record. Lopez’s army was gone – killed, wounded or captured – within eighteen months. Every male Paraguayan had been conscripted: ten-year-olds ought and died beside their grandfathers. The new armies marched half-naked, their colonels barefoot. Naval infantry units attacked Brazilian ironclads armed only with machetes. As the allies advanced, Lopez’s paranoia grew: he tortured and killed most of his government, the civil service, five hundred members of the foreign diplomatic corps, and two of his own brothers. And yet Paraguayans continued to fight for him with suicidal bravery. Finally, he was cornered by Brazilian troops on the banks of the Aquidaban and was shot as he attempted to swim to freedom. Lopez’s last words were reported as: “I die for my country” – but it would be more accurate to say that his country died for him. Paraguay lost 90% of its male population: for years afterward, polygamy was tolerated. By any reasonable standard, the choice Lopez made was senseless, yet the whole nation followed him into the abyss. The power of war [I’d have said nationalism] binds individually rational judgements together in irrationality.”

    (Wikipedia at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francisco_Solano_L%C3%B3pez presents a somewhat less negative or at least more varied view of him.)

    I am fascinated and horrified by how rational societies such as 1890’s Paraguay or 1930’s Germany decide to follow an awful leader down the toilet. I still don’t really understand it, but the last six years have given us yet another example, as America, unthinkably, establishes pre-emptive invasions and torture and secret prisons and so forth as its official policy.

  • grytpype –
    i heard much the same from Sydney Blumenthal on randi rhodes…
    and he really does believe it all… i’m not sure if that makes it better…

  • Bush doesn’t read, he doesn’t know history, he doesn’t learn from history but he believes that history will be on his side?
    The war criminal should be brought to Nuremberg.

  • There may be 2,700 killed and 20,000 seriously injured, but there are only two numbers that matter to Bush. The first is zero, the number of Bush family members who are serving or will ever serve in this war. The second is unknown, but massive. That’s the amount of war profiteering taken in by the Bush family.

  • franc (#32),

    I just happen to have the brief poem Ozymandias on my website, for those who’d like to read it. It’s a perfect choice, isn’t it? Except that the Regal Moron will never do anything worthy of “Look on my works”, and he’s already a “colossal wreck” even before leaving office.

  • The bush administration down to family size:
    Wife says to me, we have enough money to pay off our entire debt and save the interest, I say,no, we will lower our income by having the bankers quit paying us, then we will borrow money to live on. I will borrow the money back from them that they get.
    Then I see my neighbor, he is BAD, he has two rocks maybe to throw at me, (I have 10000), once he threw rocks at my daddy and nearly hit him. I go in and tear his house up and throw him out, then I borrow money to fix his place back up and build him a garagel
    Then the neighbors start fighting and killing each other……….
    In a few years it will be a COMMA

  • just a comma in history, as in:

    George Bush fucked up Iraq, and then unbelievably went and invaded Iran too….

  • “I’m sure that will bring comfort to the families of those who have sacrificed so much for Bush’s mistakes.”

    YOU are the one calling it a comma, when you suggest, AGAIN AND FOREVER, that it is a “mistake” to illegally invade a disarmed country for PROFIT, power, and RACISM.

    It’s a “mistake” to do all the INCREDIBLY EVIL things he has done.

    As long as commenters like you continue to hide behind such flaccid rhetoric, you are no better than a reticent spokeman for the Silent Minority.

  • Comma???? And a period wil come… when? When there’s No Iraqi Left Behind?

    Wonder where Dante would place that worthless piece of excrement.

  • That’s why Rove invites Jeff Gannon to the White House. He gets dressed up like GI Joe and shouts commands while shoving an exclamation point up the Chimperor’s ass. It reminds the Chimperor of good times at home with Daddy.

    Somebody needs to stick an exclamation point up his colon.

    Comment by T Paine — 9/24/2006 @ 2:04 pm

  • #29 and #53

    Yep. Boy George II meant footnote.

    His is so wrong about how history is going to treat this war. Because, in the end, only his enemies know how to write.

  • As if he were describing the typical American politician, Marcus Tullius Cicero regarding the danger of internal subversion, said in a speech to the Roman Senate:

    A nation can survive its fools and even the ambitious. But it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable, for he is known and he carries his banners openly against the city. But the traitor moves among those within the gates freely, his sly whispers rustling through all alleys, heard in the very halls of government itself. For the traitor appears no traitor; he speaks in the accents familiar to his victim, and he wears their face and their garments and he appeals to the baseness that lies deep in the hearts of all men. He rots the soul of a nation; he works secretly and unknown in the night to undermine the pillars of a city; he infects the body politic so that it can no longer resist. A murderer is less to be feared. The traitor is the plague.”

  • There you go Ms. Cindy “Publicity Hog” Sheehan and all you other whiny mothers of dead sons. The Presnit gave you your answer!

    Your son died for a comma.

  • Dale,
    Nice tune and great for a cheap laff.

    It seems to be everytime things get really fucked up, those who fuck up proclaim history will vindicate them. It’s a pity for those of who have to suffer thru these events that history’s condemnation is a bit too late.

    I suspect that deep down in W’s heart that he knows that his name will be cursed by many throughout the world and throughout our remaining history. And I don’t think that retirement will be kind to W despite his connections and power.

  • For all those agonizing over our military losses, do you know that we lost more Americans last month in highway accidents? Why do we not cry, complain, and wail over this? Because it’s the price we pay for the convenience of the automobile. We sustain these losses without a whimper. The American casualties in the Iraq war have been amazingly low (so far). If we cannot put up with these types of casualties we may as well disband the military, forget about being a major power, and resign ourselves to becoming a large version of Belgium or France.

  • Kind of like the Vietnam Comma and the Korea Comma. I would have done much better in history class with Perfesser Bush teaching the class.

  • There’s something that comes before this phrase that disturbs me even more… “when the final history is written on Iraq”. Like when, Mr. Bush? After Armageddon?

    Here’s more of this “end times” thinking creeping into his conversation.

  • And we also loose six times the number of people killed on 9/11 EACH AND EVERY YEAR because of our health care system.

    By the time we leave Iraq, we will have spent a trillion dollars. Think of the health care that could have bought.

    And, since Iraq civilians deaths are most likely around 140,000 – that would equate to 1, 680,000 American civilian deaths since March 2003. That would be 33,600 for each and every state. You’d be sure to know at least one victim.

    And look at all the fuss about less than 3,000 people getting killled in one day!

  • The mistake is thinking that bush can or does care. He’s a sociopath or something with all the classic sociopathic traits. He doesn’t care in the least.

    Our mistake is to forget that.

    Fool me once…

  • r€nato,

    In my book, “the first round” is always served in bulk quantity. But since you insist on picking up the tab…. :

  • “Not a comma–what’s the thing that’s the same backwards and forwards?”
    “A palindrome?”
    “Yeah! That’s right!”
    “Never a palindrome–look, the reverse of ‘Iraq’ is ‘Qari’!'”
    “Oh, right.”
    “Never a palindrome….”

    (sorry…)

  • ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,+
    ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,+
    ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, … =!
    Just a few more commas. +/- who knows (lost count).
    Wake Up!

  • Asked to explain himself, the president is unconcerned. Everything we’re seeing is “just a comma.”

    Watching the video, it’s astounding how nonchalant Bush is about Iraq when he throws out the “comma” comment. It’s spoken like a person who has nothing invested in the matter, personal or otherwise, and fully expects not to be held liable for the damage done. He has nothing to lose by staying the course, so why should he care?

    Sad to say, but I think he’s right. No one will hold him accountable in any meaningful way during his lifetime, and someone else gets to deal with the mess once he’s out of office.

  • Addendum to#69, to whom it may concern in the media,

    Newsflash: ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

    Please publish this vital message from the forces of Democracy.

  • grytpype @ 39:

    So [Bush’s] briefings are all like, “Iraqi People striving for Democracy … but victory is inevitable”… [Bush is] not making this up, it’s what he’s being told.

    Yep.

    And the most damning thing about your analysis is that any President’s first operating principle has to be to establish solid communication channels for hard doses of the truth.

    Unless of course… you are a pyschopath… then you have no need for hard truths, or even half truths…

    Which is also to say:

    For the first time in our history, America has a truly mentally ill President. Worse yet: #2 in command is even more deranged. These guys are bat shit crazy with fangs…

  • MG (#59),

    You have a point about all those deaths by automobile accidents compared to U.S. Military deaths in Iraq. It certainly eclipses those numbers, just like it eclipses the number who died in the 9/11 terrorist attacks.

    Now that we’re through playing this numbers game, let’s consider your other ideas. Disbanding the military? Perhaps not. Stop (mis)behaving like a super power? Not a bad idea.

  • Let’s us know when you’re going over. Oh wait you’re too smart and valuable to fight or get killed…send some other patriotic sucker over there.

    Comment by AO — 9/24/2006 @ 2:14 pm

    First of all, liberals and progressives are patriots, too, just not the same kind as you. We’re the type that want to actually improve the country, not just wrap ourselves in the flag and pretend like we’re doing so.
    And yes, you are a sucker. A big, fat, dumb sucker if you believe a word that comes out of W’s mouth and I pity you. Sucker.

  • I think George did “mean” comma. A comma is a pause in a narrative; an inconsequential incident. In his limited mind it made sense. Since some Iraqi people are still holding grudges from the 6th century I suspect they’ll regard this 3 to ???? years as fairly significant.

    The George Bush Rule: If you have to claim that history will vindicate you, then you are currently fucking up.

  • History’s judgement is all that he has left
    We should fight like hell for the rest of our days to fight anyone who attempts to rewrite this shamefull episode in this country’s history.

    comma huh? George’s thought process alway ends in an elipsis…

  • If W’s warmongering goes on idefinitely, as W hopes, the body count could top 1,000,000 and then the Iraq conflict will be two commas.

  • I’m still bemused about “comma”.

    Perhaps someone could ask him how much bloodier it has to get for him to call it a period.

    Or maybe someone could ask him to explain to Cindy Sheehan how he thinks her son is worth only 1/2700 th of a comma.

  • #59 You may agonize over deaths on the high way and that is fine. I however, agonize over the deaths of innocent people killed by Americans,,, Americans, Iraqi’s all inclusive. We are killing and torturing with out warrant or cause and that is the shameful historical legacy we will leave written in the history books.

  • Did anyone besides myself observe Bush’s posture at the end of the interview? It seemed to me that he didn’t have a posture that reflected confidence. In fact, it seemed entirely the opposite. It seemed like someone who is beat and defeated, or maybe feared a trial at the Hague.

  • If 2700 dead American troops, and tens of thousands of dead Iraqis are “just a comma in history”, then I suppose that the terrorist attacks on the US were nothing to be worried about at all. After all, less than 3000 people were killed. So I guess we can just forget all about it and move on, right?

  • The Bush Gang are not conservatives but Fascists.The Have not conserved one iota in 6 years,,,,,,,

  • And the Bush/Rumsfeld/Cheney planning process for the post war occupation was a very, very small comma. Too bad the US will be dragging this comma around for the next 20 years or more while Bush is rocking on the porch with Rove at Crawford and laughing about how they commandered the democrats.

  • This all makes sense… just rewind to 2003…

    Colin Powell to George Bush: “If you break it, you own it.”

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    There’s that comma. It’s the pause before he takes responsibility for his decisions. Don’t hold your breath.

  • Boy George II thinks the Iraqi Insurgency will be but a comma in History because he only reads the Cliff Notes version anyway.

    But because he is bankrupting America to pay for this war with money borrowed from the Communist Chinese, he won’t be able to read any histories anyway. They’ll all be written in Chinese characters.

  • Anyone who has ever read a history book knows that Iraq (Mesopotamia) has been at civil war for centuries. The British took 3 countries and merged them into one, stupid, stupid. Saddam, no matter how cruel and unjust, was the only guy frightening enough to break that cycle. He scared all factions into utter submission. Now that his reign of terror is over, the results are stunningly predictable. Iraq will stay chaotic for centuries to come. Any fool in Washington who took History 101 should have figured this out years ago.

  • Ends justify means all over again.

    What did Twain say again? Something like history never repeats itself, but it often rhymes?

  • Can you imagine the conversations in the office of special plans or even in the bush family home between father and sons and the degree of meglo-manic extended futuring hypothesis of the New World Order attitude of this family who have done most their dirty double dealing in the darkness of the extrapolated skull and bones alumni turned free enterprising intelligence field or beholden and friendly with the same people we now surrender our transfixed daily lives to in not only totally saturation news in addition to every spare cent and national resource while they are never required to touch the ground in this country on any issue or need or program this country’s citizens attempt to work toward solution. This president fella is quite brain damaged and people should realize it fully for what it is. His competence is not almost child-like. It is thoroughly and clearly retarded.

  • Following a country down the toilet. This war nympho leading us down the toilet with our two partys staying the course. A dictatorship by coup will take over Bagdad that holds the US in freindship. So the US and its new partner in war can pursue another debacle with a pun intended. ( I ran ) , Isreal can start it and unlike Lebanon, we will not remain silently manipulative behind the scenes. Total caos divide and conquer. How dose it go. We have seen the enemy and it is us. These next elections have got to work. Impeachment or silenceing these two will not happen unless NOV brings a big change. They are passing laws to make themself even further from any ability to hold them accountable.

  • Can someone please explain to me once and for all why this man isn’t shitting in a corner of a rubber room somewhere in Houston instead of squatting in the fucking White House?

    US deaths are just “numbers” and Iraqi bloodshed is just a comma.

  • JP,
    ..because of all the dingbat neocon chickenhawks living in bumfuck who mindlessly take orders from devious machevellian corporate empire builders – who all vote or control the machines.

  • Isn’t he like a totally god loving person and he thought we should be better christians etc? so people dying is just a comma? ooooo, I think I know where Mr. Bush is going for his afterlife. Some place burning HOT! And where he’ll finally get to hang out with Bin Laden since he’s not going to catch him for us in this life time.

  • As a Navy Veteran who volunteered and served overseas, who has looked actual terrorists in the eye, (and volunteered yet again for hazardous duty in the Gulf to combat terrorists afterward), this (to put as mildly as I can) flippantly insensitive remark glares blindingly as such that could only be uttered from one who has no true experience of, (nor respect for) those who actually have served in the past, present, or future of our great nation.

    Plainly, the man is insane in the membrane.

    By the Square,

    Neil W. Ahrens

  • Bitching about Bush doesn’t put Democrats in office. We can wipe the slate clean by voting the Democratic ticket all the way.
    The Bushists need to go!

  • This entire war was fought for Haliburton, Exxon, and daddy George 1st and his rich oil friends. Poor kids from small town America die over in Iraq, while rich people get richer by the hour and their kids go to Harvard and Yale. How many more Countries are the Republicians going to invade? How many have we invaded now? The Industrial Military Complex must be mighty happy.

  • Do you think he meant “just a comet” — you know, like the one that killed off the dinosaurs?

    He can’t pronounce “nuclear” correctly either, you know.

  • “comma”?

    didn’t our miscommunicator in chief mean “footnote”? (@53)

    No, it’s a dog whistle to the evangelical base, based on the saying “Never place a period where God has placed a comma.” Elsewhere in the interview he refers to “wonder-working power,” which is a phrase from a well-known hymn.

    He has, or his speechwriters have, to do this because, with the congressional session ending soon, they don’t have an anti-gay-marriage bill or an anti-abortion bill with which to flog their base to the polls.

  • A comma? Hmmm. Well, I guess that answers Cindy Sheehan’s question.

    So, are we to call the mothers of all the dead soldiers Gold Comma Moms?

  • 40 years of dictatorship were better for the people in Iraq, then 40 days of Bush ! We have destroyed this country for no reason! Resign now Bush!

  • How can Bush refer to only “a comma” when Rumsfeld makes the following statement?

    “Speaking during a brief ceremony at the Ministry of Defense, Rumsfeld said Albanians “will look back on it five, 10, 15, 20 years from now and see the contribution you have made, and the contribution your country has made, and take great pride in what you’ve done.”

  • a million comma comments will not rectify the problem which has been made perfectly clear to anyone with a brain in their head; as opposed to your president’s rectum between the ears.

    SOLUTIONS people are the only thing worth discussion.

    Taking back your senate and white house by any force necessary is the only way to redeem America’s vision which you have allowed this murdering imbecile to destroy. Your congress is about to pass a law making his crimes unpunishable. Will you allow that to happen?

  • Al qaeda has stated for the record that it intends to transform Iraq into:

    “a base for exporting terrorism and revolution”

    … if it can drive out U.S. forces.

    Iraqi civilians are being murdered by the radical islamists, not the U.S.

  • Evidence available demonstrates that GWB is a liar. My opinion after having considered all the truths revealed about this man is that he loves to kill people. He is definitely a thief. I suppose all who know this and yet support this person are accessories. This man has destroyed the USA.

  • To use White House spokeswoman Dana Perino’s own words: it is “a reasonable extrapolation” of the president’s position that what might eventually be 5000 or more American lives (considering his recent admission that this could go on for years to come) are worthy of nothing but a “comma” in history. After all, none of these thousands will be the sons or daughters of the President, Republicans in Congress, or executives of Halliburton.

  • “The Comma Quote” an obscene indifference to human suffering

    …I like to tell people when the final history is written on Iraq, it
    (being all the people tortured, mutilated, and killed[1]) will look
    like just a comma …
    –George W. Bush

    ^1-Innuendo:
    in text, an explanation or interpretation, of words and statements, usually placed in parentheses after the referenced item.

    Notes
    ———————————————————–
    1) It is possible that he may have been trying to say Coda not Comma
    Irregardless of whether or not he meant to say coda, asterisk
    or footnote; the gist of the statement is still the same.

    2) Attempt to recontextualize “The Comma Quote”
    Remarks by the President September 28, 2006
    Whitehouse news releases

    We’re going to help the Iraqi people. Remember, 12 million
    of them voted in elections last December. That probably
    seems like a decade ago to you, but when the history is
    finally written, it will be just a comma. Twelve million people
    stood up in the face of assassins and car bombers and said,
    we want to be free.

    3) Attempt to subvert criticism of the 20SEPT06 quote
    by referencing the 28SEPT06 recontextualized quote
    Press Briefing by Tony Snow
    October 5, 2006
    Whitehouse news release

    As for the comma. This has been brewed around; Peter had a word or two to say about it today. The comma refers to the period of time between last year’s election and today. We’re talking about—well, the President is making the point is, when you look at a history book, a 10-month period is a comma. Now, some people have tried to say, how dare the President refer to this as a comma; he’s being glib about the deaths of Americans. That’s outrageous, and the people who say that know it. What they’re trying to is, willingly or not, wrench a statement out of context and try to use that as an opportunity to accuse a President who is deeply aware of the human cost of war of being calloused about those costs. It’s just not true

    Subvert:
    to turn it from the truth; to corrupt; to confound.

    4) Attempted whisper campaign to Meme Hack The Comma Quote

    Sources on the internet claim esoteric knowledge of the true
    meaning of the The Comma Quote as follows;

    The Speaker states, in reference to the The Comma Quote;

    He likely meant to finish it off by suggesting that, looking
    back, the Iraq war will be viewed as “just a comma,
    not a period.”
    Not surprisingly, this is rooted in current Christian teaching,
    often in reference to the death of Jesus, or more generally
    as “Don’t put a period where God puts a comma.”

    The Speaker then makes the following interpretation;

    This is Dog-whistle politics, which means one thing to
    the general population but which has a more specific
    meaning for a targeted subgroup of the audience.
    This is the same communication technique he used
    previously for the “Dred Scott” coded messages he
    sent.

  • The whole country of Iraq is still less violent than the cities of Washington, D.C., Detroit, Baltimore, Atlanta, and St. Louis.

    What does that say about our system of government… it should be abandon, right?

  • Comments are closed.