Just when you thought it was safe to forget about the Schiavo story…

I honestly thought it was over. Even Jeb Bush had resigned himself to the fact that he could no longer exploit the Terri Schiavo matter. But, alas, the Senate’s nuttiest member, Sen. Tom Coburn (R-Okla.) is still pursuing the case.

U.S. Sen. Tom Coburn challenged the accuracy of Terri Schiavo’s autopsy Thursday, saying he has a copy of the Florida woman’s medical file.

Coburn’s comments came during the taping of a television show for the Oklahoma Educational Television Authority in Oklahoma City. He was responding to questions from a panel of journalists, including a Tulsa World reporter and Terri Watkins, a reporter from KOCO-TV in Oklahoma City.

“I have on my desk a complete medical file of Terri Schiavo, and I would challenge the accuracy of many of the statements by people involved in that case in terms of her medical condition, and I would also challenge some of the autopsy findings based on what I have on my desk in Washington,” Coburn said.

You’ve got to be kidding me. The Florida pathologist who performed the autopsy, wrote that “no amount of treatment or rehabilitation would have reversed the massive loss of neurons.” He, not Coburn, studied Schiavo’s remains, reviewed court, medical and other records, and interviewed her family members, doctors and others in making his determination.

But Coburn, who weighed in on the case because he “look[ed] at her on TV,” is challenging the autopsy report. It’s just sad.

On a related note, am I the only one to notice the similarity between “I have on my desk…” and “I have in my hand…“?

How many medical privacy laws were broken to get Terri Schiavo’s “complete” medical records onto Senator Coburn’s desk?

  • I caught that “I have in my hand…” thing, too.

    I think it’s neat that he can read a file on his desk (shouldn’t it have been at least put in a file cabinet?) in Washington while he’s talking in Tulsa. Sorta like Frist being able to provide us with a diagnosis via viedotape. These guys are amazing.

  • HIPAA regulations regarding medical record confidentiality are very strict, and no doubt Mr. Coburn should be investigated on that count. However, I wouldn’t put it past Terri’s family to have provided the file to any lawmaker who expressed interest.

    Despite the fact that the case was taken over by religious and political extremists leeches, I think Terri’s family had best intensions at heart. Not that I think they were correct, but if they believed Terri could be cured and brought back to them, I think fighting was the right thing for her family to do.

    The bigger issue is that this idiot is running around making baseless claims in an effort to spin a total disaster into a left-wing conspiracy. Is this guy a doctor? I’d like to see someone ask him what, exactly, makes him think that. I’m sure he couldn’t get specific.

  • Hey Eadie,

    I’m pretty sure that Cobourn is a Dr., specifically a OBY/GYN. Isn’t that a scary thought?

    More on topic, doesn’t this help the Dems generally speaking? I thought the polls showed a national pretty well united and unhappy with how the GOP handled the Schiavo affair. If that’s true, then OK ought to be able to field a candidate that can take down Cobourn. Its his first term, right?

  • My comment on an earlier post on this subject:

    Can someone tell me just how he plans on challenging these (autopsy) results? Is there some legal case to make or is it pistols at dawn?

    Thanks for clearing that up for me. It’s pistols at dawn then.

  • Short of a scandal involving sex, children, and photographs, Coburn will be a Senator from God-fearing Oklahoma as long as he wants to. Sens. Inhofe and Coburn are like bookends; Oklahoma has the distinction of having–not one–but two right-wing nutjobs for U.S. Senators. LOL

  • Edo,

    Coburn’s kind of a weird duck in several ways. He originally graduated Oklahoma State 1970 in accounting. From 1970-78 he was a manufacturing manager at the Ophthalmic Division of Coburn Optical Industries in Colonial Heights, Virginia. After the family business was sold he went to Oklahoma Medical School (grad 1983). Interned in general surgery at Saint Anthony’s Hospital in Oklahoma City and family practice residency at the University of Arkansas, Fort Smith. Then he returned to his birthplace, Muskogee, where he specialized in family medicine, obstetrics and allergy. Prior to the Senate, he represented Oklahoma’s 2nd Congressional District in the U.S. House of Representatives from 1995-2001.

  • Someone say’s short of scandal involving sex,children and pictures this guy will be a senator for life. How do these nut/cases get elected? Are the majority of people in these southern states crazy? The bible belt? Does this mean that you can be as deranged as possible but your still ok as long as you carry a bible?
    Scrushy got off because of his bible……….CRAZY

  • Then he returned to his birthplace, Muskogee, where he specialized in family medicine, obstetrics and allergy.

    Thanks Ed for the clarification. I know I’m allergic to his brand of wing-nuttery. Is there anything I can take for it, or would he just tell me to read the Old Testament?

  • Edo and Ed,

    Thanks for the clarification. I’d still like to get him to specifically outline his reasoning and analysis, though. His claims were pretty strong.

  • I used to think it was a problem that so many lawmakers were lawyers. So now we have Doctors Frist and Coburn, not to mention exterminators, high school teachers, and oilmen.

    Could we have the lawyers back, please?

  • How do these nut/cases get elected? Are the majority of people in these southern states crazy? The bible belt? Does this mean that you can be as deranged as possible but your still ok as long as you carry a bible?

    Yes.

    Oklahoma has one moderately sane person that I know of, Bartcop (Okay, probably Mrs. Bartcop too). But Coburn was an obvious nutjob before he got elected, which any rational person would have recognized. Apparently, though, the vote was close, so an argument could be made that only about half the people in Oklahoma are nuts.

  • But this whole issue for the right wing crazies is
    a whopping loser.

    If only it weren’t for the family and friends, I’d
    be saying “Bring ’em on,” because they would
    simply bury themselves in the muck and mire. This
    is a whopping loser for the right wingers.

    I also agree with Eadie, that the family really
    meant well. This whole issue is so tragic. It’s
    going on all over America. A tug of war between
    those who want death with dignity, and those who
    seem to want to hang no matter what the consequences, no matter how much suffering is
    involved.

    I wrote an op-ed piece for our leading newspaper
    in Idaho on the right to die a couple of years ago. I took the position that it is every citizen’s
    unconditional right to decide when he or she wants
    to let go, after some obvious steps are taken to
    make sure the wish is truly valid. I made no
    exceptions – if you’ve had enough, you should be
    able to get out of this life with dignity.

    I expected a storm of hate mail, phone calls,
    and letters to the editor calling for my head.

    But there wasn’t one single response. Funny.

  • Comments are closed.