Murtha’s plan is catching on

When Rep. John Murtha (D-Pa.) unveiled his redeployment plan for Iraq, Dems were quick to offer him support in the face of far-right condemnations, but were less enthusiastic about his plan. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, in particular, told reporters, “Mr. Murtha speaks for himself.”

That was two weeks ago. Murtha’s plan apparently improves with age.

Reversing course, House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi on Wednesday endorsed a call by a prominent member of her rank-and-file to begin withdrawing U.S. troops from Iraq.

“We should follow the lead of Congressman John Murtha, who has put forth a plan to make American safer, to make our military stronger and to make Iraq more stable,” Pelosi said. “That is what the American people and our troops deserve.”

Pelosi, D-Calif., said she wouldn’t be calling for a party caucus position on the plan by the Pennsylvania Democrat because “a vote on the war is an individual vote.”

Nevertheless, she said: “I believe that a majority of our caucus clearly supports Mr. Murtha.”

Good. Not only am I glad because I think Murtha’s right, but also because this juxtaposes nicely with the president’s speech today — Bush thinks the war is progressing nicely and that his plan for Iraq is on track, while Murtha and the Dems think the opposite. It makes the substantive debate clear for the nation.

“It makes the substantive debate clear for the nation.”

Along with the General’s smackdown of Rumsfeld today.

  • That’s promising, but it’s not as encouraging as it sounds. Without the Democratic Caucus backing Murtha’s plan or any troop withdrawal plan, this just sound like Pelosi was taken to task by her California constituents for not taking a principled stand the first time around.

    Without the backing of the rest of the party, Ms. Pelosi and Mr. Murtha speak for themselves.

  • It’s so nice to have a ‘uh huh’ to toss back when a Rethug says the Democrats don’t have a plan. That talkin’ point won’t work anymore.

  • True, its good that Pelosi and other dems are starting to come around. The plan seems to be a rational one despite it being described as a plan calling for “immediate withdrawal” by the right. There is one problem: the most prevalent criticism of the left is that our leaders are wishy-washy…that they lack conviction on serious issues. While that is clearly bullshit…Pelosi distanced herself from Murtha and has now embraced him which only strengthens their argument. I just wish she would have kept her mouth shut, read the plan, then commented.

    JFran

  • Comments are closed.