No, Obama is not going to force you to ‘learn to speak Spanish’

Well, we knew the right wasn’t going to be happy about this. On Monday, at an event in Georgia, a voter asked Barack Obama about a “push” for more bilingualism in the U.S. Obama criticized the “English-only” efforts and said Americans would be better off if we spoke more than one language.

After noting the importance of foreign language classes in the schools, Obama said, “We should understand that our young people, if you have a foreign language, that is a powerful tool to get a job. You are so much more employable. You can be part of international business. So we should be emphasizing foreign languages in our schools from an early age, because children will actually learn a foreign language easier when they’re 5, or 6, or 7 than when they’re 46, like me.”

Far-right blogs pounced, and other conservative media outlets soon followed. Fortunately, Obama stuck to his guns today and said he was right the first time.

“The Republicans jumped on this. I said, absolutely immigrants need to learn English, but we also need to learn foreign languages,” the likely Democratic nominee said as the 1,000-plus crowd in a school gymnasium cheered. It’s a position he long has held.
“This is an example of some of the problems we get into when somebody attacks you for saying the truth, which is: We should want our children with more knowledge. We should want our children to have more skills. There’s nothing wrong with that. That’s a good thing. I know, because I don’t speak a foreign language. It’s embarrassing,” Obama said chuckling as his audience did the same.

The Americans for Legal Immigration PAC said in a statement, “Barack Obama has stepped on a political land mine by stating Americans should be forced to learn to speak Spanish.”

That’s obviously not true.

In fact, I’m delighted to note that the AP’s Liz Sidoti added, after noting the criticism from the Americans for Legal Immigration PAC, “[T]hat’s not what Obama said.” (Look! Journalism!)

In case there’s any doubt — I assume it will soon be stated as fact on right-wing radio that Barack Obama will start fining Americans who don’t speak Spanish — here’s what Obama actually said on Monday:

There’s an old joke you’ve probably heard — what do you call someone who speaks two languages? Bilingual. What do you call someone who speaks three languages? Trilingual. And what do you call someone who speaks one language? An American.

Obama thinks we’d be better off if that joke wasn’t funny anymore. I think he’s right.

Some conservatives sure do pick strange things to get excited about.

The republican conservatives will do anything to change the subject from a failed Preidency of George Bush; the corruption endemic in the Republican party.

  • And what do you call someone who speaks one language? An American.

    And someone who speaks one languae badly? A Republican. And someone who speaks two languages badly? George Bush.

  • Well, it’s kind of a fair inference that he would support expanding foreign language training in public schools, which is more or less like forcing kids to learn a foreign language, but I don’t see why anyone would view that as something to get upset over. It’s like saying, “Oh no, Barack Obama wants to force your children to learn math!” Well, yeah. So?

  • Jesus spoke English. If English was good enough fro Jesus then it should be good enough for the rest of us.

  • Look, let them opt out. it only hurts their kids’ chances in an expanding job market.

  • As I said earlier, study after study also shows that learning another language is good for your brain. But obviously Republicans wouldn’t understand this.

    And didn’t Bush just greet the Italian PM with Spanish the other day? What a twit.

  • How could anyone think that learning more than one language is a bad thing? OH NOES, MY CULTURAL IDENTITY!!!

  • Can we stop calling modern conservatism a political philosophy and start calling it what it is? It’s a mental illness. It’s the belief that your hunches trump obvious fact and evidence. The pathetic sufferers of this mental illness have convinced themselves that truth is a lie and the most extreme spin is fact. By any rational definition of the word, they are simply delusional.

  • “Some conservatives sure do pick strange things to get excited about.”

    Jon Stewart diagnosed it. It is called Baraknophobia.

  • Thanks for this post. I was there Monday and he was spot on and the crowd of nearly 3000 agreed with him completely.

    Frankly I am beginning to wonder if things like this way are just racial attacks cloaked in non issues from luddites on the right….

  • Keep in mind, lots of studies show that when children learn a second language it improves their confidence, hireability, school performance and intelligence. And the last thing Republicans want is a more intelligent population. Why else would they spend so much time deriding the “intelligentsia” and “educated elites?”

  • Obviously, this is a political landmine in Xenamericania. Home of the bravest xenophobes you will ever meet! 1 and 11, you’re both spot on.

  • frankly this is a conclusion I came to years ago. Especially if we’re in favor of globalization. I mean come on. Don’t we have a shortage of translator in some of our intelligence capabilities, and even more so in the field with our troops. If the ‘enemy’ can’t use a language barrier against us, then how much better would that be for achieving ‘victory’.

    Nope, even though the conservatives recognize that language is a living history of every culture, and to protect our american culture, everyone else should learn english(who cares about other cultures’ heritage anyway? hippie liberal douchebags thats who)

  • 4.On July 11th, 2008 at 4:10 pm, Texas Republican Sate Legislator said:
    Jesus spoke English. If English was good enough fro Jesus then it should be good enough for the rest of us.

    🙂 Jesus is just all white with me.

    JO said: Jon Stewart diagnosed it. It is called Baraknophobia.

    🙂 Sort of like Agoreaphobia?

    JoeW said:Can we stop calling modern conservatism a political philosophy and start calling it what it is? It’s a mental illness.

    Good point. And it’s a national malaise.

    chrenson said: And the last thing Republicans want is a more intelligent population.

    True. They want to keep them barefoot and ignorant or billionaires.

    They say you learn a second language with a different part of your brain and here have been cases where the normal speech section of a brain was damaged and the person could only speak their second language. And since so many Republicans seem to be brain-damaged, you’d think they would support it.

  • Two languages? Maybe three if you count speaking out of both sides of his mouth.

  • I was appalled at O-Drama’s remarks. Are we sure he is running for the President of the United States and not the President of Mexico??? His love of everything Mexican, especially the illegals, flies in the face of America and the serious problems we face. Now granted, learning another language is not a bad thing, but I think that him saying we should learn Spanish was a stupid move. Worry about American and its legal citizens first before worrying about if we will be able to communicate with the millions of illegals he wants to grant amnesty to. Everytime something stupid comes out of his mouth, it reinforces why I will never vote for him. I am scared to see what America will look like after his “change”

  • Why hasn’t anyone pointed out that it is a requirement in most American public and private high schools that a student take two years of a foreign language? Ostensibly, though not practically, the purpose of this instruction is to make students at least conversational in another language. My research tells me such instruction has been going on for years, and that most students opt to study Spanish.

    So: Why is foreign language instruction suddenly “controversial” when Barack Obama talks about it?

    Don’t answer.

  • Well, as an American who is bilingual, I definitely resent the “learn spanish” comment. Yes, I’ll make every effort to make sure my kinds are bi-lingual but they won’t be speaking French, German or Spanish, they’ll be speaking my African language.

    Show me a German, French or Spanish person who speaks Swahli and I’ll appreciate their talent but the fact that they speak a language of Commerce? I am not impressed. If the language of Commerce were German or French I am sure many more Americans would be bi-lingual, but since it is English and their native language is English they are not forced to learn a second language. That to me is not something to be “embarassed” or ashamed of.

  • Fist Jabbing Terrorist:

    Conservatives basically took the word “embarrassed” and extrapolated to Obama is anti American, embarrassed to be American, etc etc. Plus some read it as him saying all American kids need to learn Spanish.

    And American kids are taught in schools often, but it’s nothing like the language schooling and development they get in Europe.

    Btw, nice name haha.

  • This topic always amazes me. Instead of wanting our future to be well versed in another language, the conservatives pounce. Take a hard look at China … when kids are old enough to sit up, they are in front of a computer and learning english. If you think we won’t be at a considerable disadvantage in a generation (ignoring the fact they already own us…real estate, debt, etc.) you are sincerely fooling yourselves.

  • Perhaps Obama was using Spanish as an example of a language that would be helpful to learn. Colleges require a language for graduation. This is a no brainer. I thought the cold war mentality was in the past. I wish I knew another language and I know of many people, republicans too, who are trying to learn a second language. I have friends from other countries and feel silly that I’m not at least bilingal.

  • Haven’t you ever been in a restaurant or on the subway and heard people yucking it up in some foreign language? Why do you think they do that? Talk like that in public?

    It’s so they can talk trash about me and you and America. They don’t have the guts to do it in English. They think they’re better than us. You don’t need to learn another language to know that.

    My uncle was in Europe during WWII. You know what Hitler did? He made all the road signs in German so our GIs would get lost. Did the same thing in France and Italy, too. That’s why we had to bomb em. No road signs up in the air.

  • NOOOOOO!!!! We only speak english here– in fact we should rename the language we speak, english, to what it should be rightfull called— it should be called “American.”

    We must leave our children behind the rest of the world. Bilingualism (and multilingualism) is for America haters.

  • Good job being as disingenuous as BHO, but he said:

    “you need to make sure your child can speak Spanish”

    We’re only a pander away from BHO trying to make that an actual requirement.

    Instead of being as misleading as BHO and hoping this blows over, let me suggest looking at the polling data related to languages. Maybe Hillary or Gore would be better choices.

  • RE:
    July 11, 2008
    No, Obama is not going to force you to ‘learn to speak Spanish’
    Posted July 11th, 2008 at 3:55 pm
    ————————————————–
    Thank you for wecloming me
    And allow me to congratulate you for your previous article
    ————————————————————————————
    LETTRE AU SÉNATEUR BARACK OBAMA

    Montréal, le 20 février 2008

    Sénateur Obama,

    Le monde entier a les yeux fixés sur vous, sur les États-Unis d’Amérique et sur son peuple.

    Tous et chacun s’attendent à ce que vous soyez démocratiquement élu et que quelque chose
    se passe en Amérique

    Un des porte-paroles les plus célèbres de l’humanité,
    Jean-Paul II, est jadis venu chez nous, en
    « Haîti », en mars1983,
    proclamer tout haut ce que tous et chacun murmuraient tout bas :

    « Ill faut que quelque chose change ici ».

    Aujourd’hui plus que jamais le peuple américain, debout, aspire à quelque chose
    et fait vraiment que quelque chose se passe.

    Et l’Histoire, qui désormais repose entre tes mains chère Haïti, te dis :
    « C’est à ton tour de te laisser parler d’amour ».
    Dis le donc aussi à ton tour aujourd’hui: Vas, Amérique, vas ! Montre-nous ton vrai visage, positivement !

    À chacun alors de jouer son rôle pour donner à ce pays son cachet d’excellence !

    À ce prix, volontiers, je m’adresse aujourd’hui à Vous et au peuple des États-Unis d’Amérique, qui offrez
    à ce pays une manière d’être quelque chose. Oui, comme qui dirait :
    « Quelque chose comme un grand peuple ».

    « Vas-y, Amérique, vas ! … sur les pas de l’un de tes fils en passe de devenir l’un de tes Hommes d’État ».

    Dans cette optique, Monsieur le Sénateur, à qui d’autre qu’à Vous je pourrais confier ce document adressé jadis sous forme de lettre à Sa Sainteté le Pape Jean-Paul II à l’occasion de sa première visite en Haïti, ainsi que l’accusé de réception émané du Vatican ?

    Cette « Lettre au Pape Jean-Paul II » vise à attirer l’attention sur le problème du racisme anti-noir et ses répercussions négatives au niveau même de l’avancement du progrès scientifique en Occident et plus précisément dans le domaine de l’Optique.

    Dans le Monde occidental, en effet, selon la théorie admise depuis Newton, on considère que le blanc est la synthèse des couleurs ; en réalité c’est le contraire : le blanc constitue l’analyse ou le décodage « visible » de la lumière ou des couleurs, alors que le noir en est la synthèse ou la composition « invisible ».

    Autrement dit, l’obscurité ou la noirceur et par extension le « Trou noir » (terme utilisé à tort dans le Monde scientifique pour désigner la réalité des astres invisibles ou Soleils noirs) sont source d’énergie et de lumière.

    Cette matière première de l’énergie lumineuse culmine, à son degré extrême de rayonnement, par neutralisation de toutes les couleurs du spectre, sous la forme de « lumière blanche » selon l’expression consacrée.

    Par conséquent, le « noir absolu » – absorption de toutes les couleurs – est une composition “divisible” de la lumière. La théorie de Newton, sans contredit, donne une interprétation partielle à la notion de lumière en excluant le noir. Notre apport tend à démontrer que le noir est non seulement partie intégrante du processus de la lumière mais en est la synthèse véritable. Le concept de lumière s’affirme donc comme étant un tout « divisible » comprenant une gamme d’intensités (ou de couleurs) où le noir est la forme « invisible » (ou absorbée) de l’énergie ainsi considérée.

    Qu’il me soit ici permis, Monsieur le Sénateur, pour étayer ces propos concernant les Trous noirs et le rayonnement, de poser avec Hubert Reeves, docteur en astrophysique nucléaire et conseiller scientifique de la NASA, la question suivante :

    « Que deviendrait le Soleil si on le plongeait dans un rayonnement de haute température comme celui qui existait au début de l’univers ? »

    «Au lieu d’émettre de la lumière, il en absorberait et finirait par se résorber entièrement dans le fluide cosmique”.

    Le fluide cosmique, voilà ce que par « erreur d’Optique » on appelle
    « l’obscurité » ou « les ténèbres de l’espace ». C’est ce flux électromagnétique, océan incommensurable où baignent les planètes et les étoiles, comme la mer qui relie les continents les uns aux autres. L’obscurité est donc « la Mer de l’Espace ».

    «Mais que se passerait-il si on injectait dans ce rayonnement primordial non pas une étoile ordinaire comme le Soleil blanc mais un « Trou noir » ou « Soleil noir » ?

    Selon la physique d’Einstein, un Trou noir est un lieu où la gravité est si formidablement intense que rien ne peut s’en échapper, pas même la lumière « visible ». Un tel objet devrait aspirer et absorber le rayonnement et augmenter progressivement sa propre masse (E=MC2 toujours…).

    «Mais après Einstein, il y a eu Bohr, Heinsenberg et la physique quantique ; et rien ne sera plus jamais pareil».

    La version einsteinienne du Trou noir est équivalente à l’affirmation que la matière située à l’intérieur du Trou noir est définitivement « assignée à résidence » dans ce volume d’espace. Selon le mot de Hubert Reeves,
    « Un énoncé aussi absolu est donc contraire à l’esprit quantique d’après lequel : rien n’est jamais définitivement localisé quelque part. Il y a toujours probabilité d’en sortir. Si le mur d’enceinte est trop haut, on creusera un tunnel ; si les prisonniers sont patients, ils s’évaderont. Il suffit d’attendre ».

    «En vertu de ce principe, les Trous noirs «s’évaporent ». Constamment, de la matière s’échappe sous forme de rayonnement ; les Trous noirs « brillent » ! Leur surface se comporte comme celle de n’importe quel corps porté à une certaine température et ce
    « rayonnement » alimentera sans fin le merveilleux « fluide cosmique » que l’on s’obstine, comme des aveugles, à appeler
    « l’obscurité ».

    Nigra sum « sed » formosa. Oui ! mais de préférence ne faudrait-il pas dire : je suis noire « et » belle ? Car l’obscurité, à la fois source et véhicule de la lumière, n’a pas à se défendre d’être la belle et infiniment discrète
    matière première
    del’univers. «L’obscurité est la mère de l’univers».

    Discrète et belle es-tu, toi aussi, Haïti. Discrète, oui; mais effacée, jamais ! À l’image de la « Vierge Noire »
    qui t’inspire et qui t’aime. Du sommet et par delà l’espace de ta
    « Cité Soleil ».

    C’est pour proposer une approche plus constructive qui amène des correctifs aux données traditionnelles abusives dites encore scientifiques de l’Optique que nous nous sommes adressé, Sénateur Obama, à ce témoin authentique du signe des temps – Sa Sainteté le Pape Jean-Paul II — prophète de l’ère nouvelle.

    Soyez félicité, Monsieur le Sénateur, et que soit à jamais félicité le peuple des États-Unis d’Amérique pour avoir rendu possible, aujourd’hui, que sonne l’heure d’ une
    « Ère nouvelle d’Espoir ».

    Lucien Bonnet

    S.V.P., Voir Lettre au Pape Jean-Paul II
    Dans : «Bill a ri et voici la Lumière !».
    http://www.contact-canadahaiti.ca

    LIENS
    – – – – – – –
    Le Cosmos, un grand trou noir?
    Selon le physicien Jae-Weon Lee

    Image de milliers de galaxies formant le cosmos captée par le télescope
    spatial Hubble et transmise par l’Agence spatiale européenne.
    Photo AFP

    Agence Science-Presse

    La solution à l’énergie sombre, cette mystérieuse énergie qui imprégnerait
    l’ensemble du cosmos, réside peut-être dans le fait que notre cosmos est en
    fait… un trou noir.

    Le physicien Jae-Weon Lee, de l’Institut d’études avancées de Corée du Sud,
    compare «l’événement-horizon», cette limite encerclant le trou noir, à
    l’intérieur de laquelle rien ne peut s’échapper, pas même la lumière, aux
    limites observables de notre Univers: tout ce qui se trouve au-delà de cet
    horizon nous est à jamais caché.

    Avec son équipe, il a calculé l’énergie qui serait générée lorsque deux
    particules «corrélées» (c’est-à-dire immuablement liées l’une à l’autre, en
    vertu d’une théorie propre à la physique quantique qu’il serait trop long
    d’expliquer ici), lorsque ces deux particules donc, sont séparées par
    l’événement-horizon: le résultat de ce calcul, affirment ces chercheurs,
    correspond à la quantité d’énergie nécessaire pour expliquer que l’expansion
    du cosmos soit en train d’accélérer plutôt que de ralentir -un phénomène
    encore inexpliqué, mais que les cosmologistes attribuent à cette mystérieuse
    énergie sombre.

  • Those claiming that Obama will force children to learn Spanish apparently themselves never actually learned to speak English.

    Know-Nothing scumbags.

  • Just another Crazy Uncle? It has been widly reported that Michelle Obama practically grew up in Jesse Jacksons house,and is best friends with one of Jesse Jacksons daughters! Jesse Jr is one of Obamas campaign directors, and one of Jesse Jackson kids is one of Barack Obamas daughters god parents.Do not be so Niave people,This is the Politics of Chicago and the Politice of Obama!We are all aware that the Obama Campaign uses the race card anytime it is convenient for the Obama Campaign, as it usually always benefit’s none other then the Obama campaign.This is just another example of another long time Obama cohort { Reverend Wright, Father Pfleger, and now Jesse Jackson } making racial statements to deflect attention away from a very problematic time in the Obama campaign. By Jesse Jackson taking this hit in the media,he is getting all the media’s attention off of all the talk of Obama breaking his major campaign promises, in particular The FISA Bill, which Obama had promised his supporters that he would against and decided to vote for the FISA BILL.Yes he has broken another major campaign promise, and has had a very tough week or two, as he has been taking a lot of heat from the media, and even his own supporters. To “deflect” the attention away from Obamas political inexperience, and his FISA Vote yesterday, It is just a little to convenient for The Obama Campaign, headed by Jesse Jackson JR. by the way, that comments made by Jesse Jackson Sr. made Sunday suddenly broke yesterday.Just after Obamas key vote supporting President Bush’s FISA Bill that had been threatening to break even Obamas staunchest of supporters. As of yesterday Obama was being criticized daily by media outlets and supporters alike, about the many flip flops made by the Candidate of Hope and Change, and now even Jesse Jr. came to Obamas defense “Ripping” Jesse Sr’s words, thus successfully deflecting the media attention away from Obamas Hard move to the right! Well played Camp Obama. Now all the pundit’s are talking about is Jesse Jackson not Barack Obama.This is not the Politics of Change, nor is it mere Politics as usual, This is the Politics of Obama. If anyone would like to see how deeply Jesse Jackson is planted in the Obama campaign, go to C-Span and watch the JUNE 29 TH Rainbow Coalition tapes, where you can watch Jesse Jackson and other African American leaders planning the first 30 day’s of The Obama presidency.To bad that it has not been reported how Jesse Jackson Jr. has been treating any elected delegates that did not support Obama thru out this election season.
    puma/nobama

  • Oh, how I wish I had paid more attention to French… As things are, however, my response to #28 has to be limited to the only French word I ever learnt: merde.

  • Lou Dobbs had his shorts in a knot over this issue tonight. What is it with Repubs and education? Did they write the song a few decades ago, “We Don’t Need No Education.”?

  • This is good fun:

    SRES 236 IS

    105th CONGRESS

    2d Session

    S. RES. 236

    To express the sense of the Senate regarding English plus other languages.

    IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
    May 22, 1998

    Mr. DOMENICI (for himself, Mr. MCCAIN, Mr. HATCH, Mr. DEWINE, Mr. Chafee, Mr. LUGAR, Mr. HAGEL, Mr. GRASSLEY, Mr. ABRAHAM, and Mrs. HUTCHISON) submitted the following resolution; which was referred to the Committee on Labor and Human Resources

    Resolved, That the United States Government should pursue policies that–

    (1) support and encourage Americans to master the English language plus other languages of the world;

    (4) recognize that a skilled labor force is crucial to United States competitiveness in a global economy, and the ability to speak 1 or more languages in addition to English is a significant skill;

    (5) recognize that knowledge of Spanish, in particular, is vital for building future cultural and economic bridges to Latin America;

    (6) support literacy programs, including programs designed to teach English, as well as those dedicated to helping Americans learn and maintain other languages in addition to English; and

    (7) develop our Nation’s linguistic resources by encouraging citizens of the United States to learn and maintain Spanish, French, German, Japanese, Chinese, Italian, Korean, Vietnamese, Farsi, African languages, sign language, and the many other languages of the world, in addition to English.

    END

  • Talk English, guess Obama went to far, they better start debating before he keeps thinking of ways to win, the debating is the best part, shows how stupid he is, i kind of think his hot air is running out, the DEAN team better get the kid ready for DEBATES, this is what we are waiting for, NO picking OBAMA first to answer a question, we don’t have HILLARY to give the kool-aid kid the answers.. now if i was the DEM. party, i would think hard, just many you srewed up, back to the votes, (this is why i think we should all speak spanish…amm…ammmmi…need to get the spanish people, wouldn’t it…ammm..ammhelp me if we make them happy with spanish??) come on folks, immmm Obama, i got to get the spanish votes..HILLARY..come up here…help me man..talk to them…..

  • Comments are closed.