Painter of schlock: Thomas Kinkade accused of fraud

Guest Post by Morbo

If you ever look at magazines like “The Ladies Home Journal,” you’ve probably had the misfortune of seeing the incredibly bad art offered therein by Thomas Kinkade.

Kinkade calls himself the “painter of light.” His scenes usually feature something like a little cottage nestled in the woods surrounded by beams of light radiating down from a somewhat cloudy sky or perhaps a lighthouse perched precariously on a rocky shore.

Kinkade also makes figurines that light up and an entire array of Christmas kitsch that really has to be seen to be believed. Don’t think Kinkade produces this stuff himself. He creates prototypes that are then mass produced by his oompah loompahs; of course it sells like hotcakes. Kinkade is an evangelical Christian, and his work is very popular in that community.

Now comes word that Kinkade may be an artist of a different type as well — a con artist. The Los Angeles Times reports that the FBI is looking into his dealings. Reported the newspaper:

The FBI is investigating allegations that self-styled “Painter of Light” Thomas Kinkade and some of his top executives fraudulently induced investors to open galleries and then ruined them financially, former dealers contacted by federal agents said…. The ex-owners allege in arbitration claims that, among other things, the artist known for his dreamily luminous landscapes and street scenes used his Christian faith to persuade them to invest in the independently owned stores, which sell only Kinkade’s work.”

Several dealers lost their shirts.

As The Times reported:

Former gallery owners said that after they had invested tens of thousands of dollars each or more, the company’s practices and policies drove them out of business. They alleged they were stuck with unsalable limited-edition prints, forced to open additional stores in saturated markets and undercut by discounters that sold identical artworks at prices they were forbidden to match.

Kinkade denies any wrong-doing. But I should point out that these allegations are not new and that they come accompanied by claims that Kinkade’s personal behavior is not always Christ like.

In March the Times reported that former gallery owners “in sworn testimony and interviews” recounted “incidents in which an allegedly drunken Kinkade heckled illusionists Siegfried & Roy in Las Vegas, cursed a former employee’s wife who came to his aid when he fell off a barstool, and palmed a startled woman’s breasts at a signing party in South Bend, Ind.”

Then there’s this disturbing story: In the late 1990s, Kinkade was staying at a Disneyland Hotel near Anaheim, Calif., when he allegedly, um, “ritually marked” a statue of Winnie the Pooh.

“‘This one’s for you, Walt,’ the artist quipped late one night as he urinated on a Winnie the Pooh figure, said Terry Sheppard, a former vice president for Kinkade’s company, in an interview.” (All I can say is, he’s lucky Tigger wasn’t there.)

I’m weary of stories like this. I’m weary of conservative Christians, who claim to be more moral than the rest of us, getting caught up in the same old scandals that plague much of the business community these days.

Consider:

* TV preacher Pat Robertson has had more shady business dealings than I can count.

* Robertson’s top lawyer, Jay Sekulow, uses a bevy of non-profit groups and sleazy fund-raising appeals to finance his high-flying lifestyle. He owns three homes and is paid so much money he is now listed as a contractor so that the figure does not have to appear on public documents.

* Jerry Falwell spent much of 2000 scaring people about the “Y2K” computer crash so they would buy his alarmist videos, books and canned goods from a company that was giving him kickbacks.

* Anti-gay minister Lou Sheldon worked to stop the spread of web-based gambling – because entrenched casino interests who feared the competition paid him to.

* Then there’s Ralph Reed.

It’s clear that the conservative Christian business community needs a little help. Perhaps they should hire a secular humanist to teach a course in business ethics.

I’m with you.

I hate his art too….

but is it against the law to be a bad artist? And is he the first charlatan to use religion to fleece foolish people?

The other claims by the ex owners might be legitimate (I don’t know, I haven’t read the claims), but if they fell for this shyster’s lines than that is their own fault.

The upside to this whole thing is that the american people were discerning enough not to buy his crappy paintings.

  • I had the misfortune of seeing his profile on 60 Minutes. I was captivated by how a hack could turn it into a business empire.

    Not so surprisingly, the 60 Minutes profile glossed over the issues he was having.

  • Okay. Okay. But the first time you see one of those light paintings you gotta be impressed. Just the first time. 🙂

    Christian criminals and Christian gullibles. A match made in Heaven.

  • evangelical christians are the biggest suckers in the world. having given up any sense of skepticism to believe in their god and any ability to resist authority to believe in their pastors, they are just waiting to be preyed upon by hucksters and politicians.

  • As commenter #4 says, Evangelical Christians are the biggest suckers in the world.

    How else would former Rockefeller Republican Newt Gingrich have been able to change his game plan and get a career?

    What about Stalinist hack David Horowitz, nowadays seen as a “leader” of the “intellectual” right?

    In the Land of the Blind and the Illiterate, the one-eyed man and the halfassed hack really can be Kings.

    As to Kinkade, the artists to compare him with are the ones promoted by another failed-artist-turned politician, after he drove all the real artists out the country and had their work destroyed. I once saw the traveling exhibit of “Nazi Art” at the LA County Museum of Art, and it was truly astounding in its fifth-ratedness. I don;t think Kinkade even rises to that level. He gives an entirely new and original meaning to “sentimental crap.”

    What was amazing on that 60 Minutes show was the couple who have their house filled with one of everything he ever did, and thought of themselves as people who appreciated “art.” I love watching morons too stupid to know they are morons publically display their stupidity.

    And do you notice that this article on Kinkade has resulted in Google putting up an ad for “www.kinkadecorner.com” here????? Go hurry and get your toilet paper substitute!

  • I remember listening to an interview with Kinkade on NPR several years ago. He told the interviewer he was “working” while they were talking because he was so busy and committed and dedicated blah blah blah. What a maroon. Later I discovered a friend had bought one of Kinkade’s special paintings, where a flunky actually paints it and Kinkade supposedly adds the “touches of light” or whatever. Puke! (My friend sez he bought it as an investment…wonder how much he lost on that scam–I know he paid a substantial chunk for it). See, if you wait long enough, sometimes there is justice.

  • Don’t think Kinkade produces this stuff himself. He creates prototypes that are then mass produced by his oompah loompahs; of course it sells like hotcakes.

    Uhhh, not even that. His name and artwork are licensed to giftware companies, whose employees come up with these ‘kitsch’ ideas, design them and submit them to Kinkade’s licensing staff for approval. I very much doubt Thom himself (yes, he spells his name “Thom”) ever even sees the stuff. Then it is mass produced not by his oompah loompahs, but in overseas factories by Chinese workers.

    There’s no accounting for taste in America.

  • Good comment, Tom Cleaver (#5). Every Sunday when I spot the “painter of light” ad in the newspaper supplement I wish I had money to burn. If I did I’d buy all that crap I could (plus the eagles with the stars and stripes up their butts) and create a “schlock art” exhibit out in my garage for the entertainment of neighbors and friends. Religious and patriotic “art” — at least as produced for the gullible masses in this country — is the furthest thing from Art that I can imagine. An old dog turd on the sidewalk makes a better statement than “the painter of light” ever has.

  • As long as there is art, there must be bad art.

    As to people why get sucked into buying this stuff, including the gallery owners who got fleeced, it’s hard to sympathize. The reason you should buy art is because you like it, or it makes an impression on you. I tend to think art should make you a bit uncomfortable, esp. in this post-moderne era. It is supposed to make you see things in a new way. Stuff like kincade’s drek, peddles a rosy aura’d world the buyer WISHED were real but knows isn’t. It’s just participatory deception.

    A propos of kincade, or at least this issue reminded me. There was a terrible poet in the eighteenth cetury, named Quarrels. In order to actually SELL his work, he bought a set of beautiful engravings in Italy, and wrote verse to accompany them. People bought the book because of the engravings not the poet. Pope mentions him in the line, “And Quarells is saved by beauties, not his own….” I think that has some bearing

  • Kinkade’s “art” is typical of the legions who state that “I don’t know much about art, but I know what I like.” Representational kitsch of their liking can be found in motel rooms throughout the country. As for “business ethics,” I thought that was an oxymoron.

  • The absolute irony of this is that those individuals who scream the loudest about others not being right with their god are, in each and every instance, more a-kin to the AntiChrist that they so voraciously denounce than any of those others whom they choose to denigrate.

    The solution to the tyranny of fundamentalism is simple. Choose one member of this infamous squad. For example, let’s pick on Robertson. His first name, by the way, is Marion.

    The next time he flashes a toll-free number on his show, pick up the phone, dial the number, and tell whoever answers at the other end that “I can’t give any money to you today, because Marion is the AntiChrist. Maybe tomorrow” Don’t scream it; don’t spit it like venom; just “say it.”

    And then, hang up. He’s telling people to call him, and all you’re doing is just that—along with giving them your reason as to why they won’t be getting any of your money today. It certainly isn’t a crime; you’re not making an overt threat of physical violence. It’s not as though you were calling to “demand his assassination” or something like that.

    His only defensible countermeasure is to change his approach to the public. He would have to include a caveat along the lines of ***if you’re willing to help “ME”*** or something similar to it. If he plays the Jesus card—or the God card—or anything else other than the Pat Robertson card—call him up again.

    Don’t call him a hundred times a day; that’s harrassment. But call him once or twice a week, and remind his solicitors (the modern-day version of the money-lenders on the Temple steps) just why they cannot have your money—Marion is wrapping himself in the robes of jesus, but he’s not doing what Jesus told him to do in the Bible—therefore, Marion is the AntiChrist, and he cannot have your money.

    The Bible was intended to be a metaphorical document; a guide to living a better and simpler life. It was never intended to be used as a weapon—let alone subjected to the vitriolic weaponization that it has been subjected to by the ugliness of Theofascism. Those who apply it as a weapon, or as a tool for profit, by default have no place in a pulpit, or a broadcast booth, or a studio—or even the pages of Parade Magazine….

  • I have read that Kinkade’s “paintings” are in fact mass-produced, using a manufacturing technique that creates a texture on the canvas, making it look as if it’s been painted.

    These canvases are then sold through Kincade’s franchised “galleries.” If the sucker is willing to pay more, s/he can have one of Kincade’s travelling “assistants” put small dabs of paint, which they call “highlights,” onto the mass-produced canvas. IIRC, if they are REALLY suckers, they can pay even more for a canvas “highlighted” by the Great Man himself.

    Supposedly there is an entire housing development (in Vallejo, CA I think) which is “based on” Kincade’s sentimental pictures of thatched cottages and trellised, vine-covered gardens.

    The market is glutted, I think.

  • Re: Comment #12…Yes, the housing development is in Vallejo, Hiddenbrooke, but like everything else remotely connected to Kincade, it’s done on the cheap with next to no involvement from the “great” man. He just put his name to it.

    The developer said it would have been way, way too expensive to put up homes that looked like those in Kinkade’s pictures, so they went with teeny little remotely Kincade-esque touches (like tacky little gazebos and trellises) sprinkled among the homes, which look like those in any other nondescript housing tract. The only thing that really distinguishes the place from any other entry from the Xerox school of architecture is the stone entry gate to this place.

    More crap from this hack. I gotta think he’s got a framed picture hanging in his studio where he’s shaking hands with a certain smirking art-lover from Texas. It’s probably right next to a polite little note on White House stationary that reads like “Dear Thom, thanks again for your wonderful picture. Laura and I just love ‘Sunset over Crawford’!….”

  • He may be a hack and a crook and a hypocrite, but I can’t really fault anyone who would drunkenly heckle Siegfried and Roy.

  • You crying anti-christian bigots can wallow in your own hateful tears. Look down on people for their taste in art or their belief in Jesus if it makes you feel better about your own empty lives.

  • I purchased a print (Thomas Kinkade Concoring the Storm) # 567 of 570 prints . I recieved my print framed with a crease in it. I complained and demanded a replacement, they refused at first ,saying all prints were all sold and as garanteed there were only 570 prints. After a few months of complaining they sent me a new print. This print was the exact same print as I had before exept it was#1172 of 2850. I was garranteed that my print would hold its value and increase over time becuase there were only 570 prints and there would be no more. I currently have both prints, is this enough to prove fraud?

  • Kinkade is no artistic genius but he knows how to market his stuff. I wouldn’t put it past him to cut his ear off and then mass produce 1000 rubber ears, selling them to unsuspecting suckers as the real deal.

  • And to think that I have always wanted one of his prints. I love the tranquil feel of them, but I am coming to read, he has a major dark side.

    Peeing on Pooh, how sad. I may still like his work, but will have the vision of him peeing on all those colorful bushes in the paintings…

    I guess I will be rethinking my fandom.

  • Thomas Kinkade has sold more canvases than any other painter in history More than Picasso, Rembrandt, Gaughin, Monet, Manet, Renoir and Van Gogh combined. He is to Art when Henry Ford was to automobiles. He is the most collected living artist in the U.S. and worldwide (60 minutes CBS).

    One in Every 30 Americans own a Thomas Kinkade image whether in stationary, greetings cards, jig saw puzzles, afgans, night lights, Lazy Boy chairs, clocks, watches, train sets, lighthouses, plates, or high end canvsses which is what I sell.
    Thomas Kinkade paintings radiate light and by using lighting with a dimmer switch you can literally change the painting from dawn to mid-day sun to sunset, which Thom attributes to soft edges, a warm palette and an overall sense of light.

    When any of the cirtics can command $5 million dollars on the sale of an original, then your would be a “peer” and critical comments could be taken more seriously.

  • Thomas Kinkade has sold more canvases than any other painter in history More than Picasso, Rembrandt, Gaughin, Monet, Manet, Renoir and Van Gogh combined. He is to Art when Henry Ford was to automobiles. He is the most collected living artist in the U.S. and worldwide (60 minutes CBS).

    One in Every 30 Americans own a Thomas Kinkade image whether in stationary, greetings cards, jig saw puzzles, afgans, night lights, Lazy Boy chairs, clocks, watches, train sets, lighthouses, plates, or high end canvsses which is what I sell.
    Thomas Kinkade paintings radiate light and by using lighting with a dimmer switch you can literally change the painting from dawn to mid-day sun to sunset, which Thom attributes to soft edges, a warm palette and an overall sense of light.

    I would like to show off this site to you. Inside I will unravel the many hidden treasures and their symbolism, found throughout every Kinkade painting.
    Please do not miss what so few collectors will ever know about “The Kinkade Secret”.

    Best wishes,
    http://www.squidoo.com/thomas-kinkade/

  • I find myself saying about Kinkade’s work that he makes Beautiful Paintings, but Terrible Art. I think that’s an important distinction to make.

  • Well, you may just be right about T Kinkade but you have the wrong idea about Christians. We Christians get tired of the conservative Christians and their hypocritical stance. Historically religions of all types have been used to bilk little old ladies out of the few nickels they possess. It is against scripture, as is tithing. It is against scripture to judge. Don’t be pissed at all Christians just because some are using it for illgotten gain. Jesus was here, and you know what?, he got just as pissed off at hypocritical self proclaimed Christians as you do. If you truly look at his words, you may find that you would have liked this guy. What you atheists need to do that must have proof, is do your homework. Start with the Shroud of Turin. I mean read every book on it and see if you end up with at least a raised eyebrow.

    Peace

  • Comments are closed.