Plan B, the FDA, and ‘sex-based cults’

Nearly two years ago, an [tag]FDA[/tag] advisory panel voted 23 to 4 to approve over-the-counter access to Plan B [tag]emergency contraception[/tag]. One FDA panel member called it the “safest drug that we have seen brought before us.” The scientific evidence was overwhelming and access to [tag]Plan B[/tag] would curtail abortion and unwanted pregnancies. This was a no-brainer — right up until the administration blocked the medication anyway, under pressure from its far-right base.

Ever since, the Bush gang has struggled to come up with a coherent explanation for the decision. Initially, then-Commissioner Lester Crawford cited FDA concerns about selling the drug to younger teens as a reason to keep Plan B off shelves. Then we learned Crawford was lying and the FDA had no such concerns. Some administration allies then insisted that Plan B may not be safe, but medical experts here and around the world say otherwise.

Digby noted yesterday the most outlandish explanation of all.

In the memo released by the FDA, Dr. Curtis Rosebraugh, an agency medical officer, wrote: “As an example, [Dr. Janet Woodcock, deputy operations commissioner for the FDA] stated that we could not anticipate, or prevent extreme promiscuous behaviors such as the medication taking on an ‘urban legend’ status that would lead adolescents to form [tag]sex-based cults[/tag] centered around the use of Plan B.” (emphasis added)

Rosebraugh indicated he found no reason to bar nonprescription sales of Plan B.

“This was the level of scientific discourse,” Heller said in an interview, referring to concerns attributed to Woodcock. “I find it very odd that these people who are supposed to be responsible scientists and doctors are making up wacky reasons.”

Look, peer-reviewed studies published in mainstream medical publications have repeatedly found there is no link between access to Plan B and risky sexual behavior, worse yet “sex-based cults.” How these Bush-appointed “[tag]scientists[/tag]” come up with such nonsense is a mystery.

Is it too much to ask that the administration just admit that politics is driving this process, so the Bush gang can give up on these bizarre rationalizations?

Only Republicans (or a weirdly medieval Chuch) could dream up “sex-based cults” based on the availability of a conception-preventing pill. That’s really twisted. I can’t wait for these psychos to be tossed out of our White House and back into their careers as southern backwoods snake-handlers.

  • Republicans have very active fantasy lives. It’s what they do with that (very large) part of their brains that they don’t use for rational thinking about public policy. Some of them (Newt Gingrich) get to put their fantasies into reality, but most (Jack Ryan, Bill O’Reillly) are reduced to begging and pleading with their wives and girlfriends. Maybe that’s why they hate Bill Clinton so much – sheer envy.

  • Speaking of sheer envy, would someone please send me the address of one of those sex-based cults? There don’t seem to be any in my neighborhood.

  • That’s what happens when abstinance is your only option. Everyone out there is having more fun than you are. There’s the Plan B Sex Cult. The Trojan ribbed Sex Cult. The Cool Whip Sex Cult. The Extra Virgin Olive Oil with Lemon Fresh Essence Sex Cult. The Kubota, “mow it in the morning while it’s cool”, Sex Cult. The Drop Off the Car in the Morning at the Mechanics to get the Wheel Bearings Changed Sex Cult.

    It is pervasive and it is evil and it is destroying this country. Sex is just out of control.

  • Isn’t it funny how we need to be worried about sex-based cults centered around the use of Plan B contraceptives, yet there is no concern regarding the sex-based cults centered around the use of Viagra?

  • I’m a physician. I talk to young women all day long and most of them have no idea that Plan B exists or that it’s available over the counter in California and they still engage in risky sexual behavior at a rate that amazes me.

  • Read more about sex-based cults coming to a neighborhood near you here. Just kidding. Seriously, I’m pimping my blog on the eve of my first year blogversary. I’m only about 200 hits shy of 5,000 for the first year, so in the spirit of Skippy … hit me!

  • I think the mis-use of science in the FDA (to mention just one agency with this problem) is a topic that deserves congressional hearings. If the house changes in 2006, maybe that will happen.

  • Under the category: How stupid is this?

    So, the use of Plan B would lead young people participating in “sex-based cults.”

    If I was young and I wanted to join a sex-based cult (If I could find one.), I would have to be quite stupid to have sex–without a condom–with relative strangers because of the possibility of being infected with HIV.

    Taking care to properly use a condom will result in no HIV infection–and no pregnancy. Duh!

  • I think they have to keep coming up with all these stupid excuses because if there were fewer unwanted pregnancies they think there would be fewer abortions.

    Fewer abortions means they lose one of their scare tactic issues, and if would be harder to whip the base into a frenzy…

  • Plan B is not an abortifacient. It prevents ovulation, so there’s no conception. Conflated by the ignorant with RU486, which prevents implantation of a fertilized egg.

  • Slip kid no more: of course, these freaks would turn around and say that’s why we should ban condomns. After all, isn’t HIV God’s way of punishing people for promiscuity?

    This whole Plan B thing is so infuriating. The insertion of christian fundamentalist values into the FDA is disturbing. The lengths to which they must stretch to find a concern is insane. Sex-based cults? It requires someone with a skewed view of sexuality to think of that scenario.

  • Tom said: yet there is no concern regarding the sex-based cults centered around the use of Viagra?

    That’s becase all the Viagara sex-based cults are filled with Old Rich White Guys, Republican’t get-it-ups, and Oil Executives. And they are worried about the Plan B sex cults because they would be filled with attractive adolescents thus increasing competition with their sex cult. And these guys are nothing if not Monopolistic.

  • “If I was young and I wanted to join a sex-based cult (If I could find one.), I would have to be quite stupid to have sex–without a condom–with relative strangers because of the possibility of being infected with HIV.”

    Assuming one knew about such things as condoms–got to get around the abstinence only sex education curriculum somehow.

  • Another battlefield in the Republican War on Sex. Why these people are so terrified of human intimacy is just beyond me.

  • bubba, good point about sex education. My daughters will know that sexual intercourse without a condom can lead to pregnancy, an STD, or worse. Teach your children well …

  • Sixteen replies and not a single “Woodcock” joke?

    Seriously, though, the notion that kids will go around humping like rabid bunnies simply because there are safe, viable ways to protect themselves from both STDs (condoms) and pregnancy (condoms and the Plan B pill) shows just how amazingly out of touch the far-right truly is.

    It also shows that when it comes to mind-blowingly stupid policy decisions, there really is no match for Bush.

  • Is it just me or is it to be expected that someone named “woodcock” would be obsessed with sex cults?

  • Damn, I got here too late. A Woodcock joke was the first thing on my mind when I read that article, it just screamed out for derision.

  • Comments are closed.