‘Sicko’ strikes a chord

Cory Doctorow featured this interesting, first-hand account of a guy who saw “Sicko” in a suburban mall in Dallas. I can’t vouch for its authenticity, but if it’s true, it’s the kind of story that will cause some heartburn for insurance company executives.

When the credits rolled the audience filed out and into the bathrooms. At the urinals, my redneck friend couldn’t stop talking about the film, and I kept listening. He struck up a conversation with a random black man in his 40s standing next to him, and soon everyone was peeing and talking about just how fu**ed everything is.

I kept my distance, as we all finished and exited at the same time. Outside the restroom doors… the theater was in chaos. The entire Sicko audience had somehow formed an impromptu town hall meeting in front of the ladies room. I’ve never seen anything like it. This is Texas goddammit, not France or some liberal college campus. But here these people were, complete strangers from every walk of life talking excitedly about the movie. It was as if they simply couldn’t go home without doing something drastic about what they’d just seen. My redneck compadre and his new friend found their wives at the center of the group, while I lingered in the background waiting for my spouse to emerge.

The talk gradually centered around a core of 10 or 12 strangers in a cluster while the rest of us stood around them listening intently to this thing that seemed to be happening out of nowhere. The black gentleman engaged by my redneck in the restroom shouted for everyone’s attention. The conversation stopped instantly as all eyes in this group of 30 or 40 people were now on him. “If we just see this and do nothing about it,” he said, “then what’s the point? Something has to change.” There was silence, then the redneck’s wife started calling for email addresses. Suddenly everyone was scribbling down everyone else’s email, promising to get together and do something … though no one seemed to know quite what.

The account seems to have originated with Josh Tyler, who manages a movie-related site called Cinema Blend. He does not appear to be particularly political.

Again, while I have no idea about the narrative’s veracity, it sounds entirely plausible. As for those who are outraged by the film’s message, but are unclear about what to do next, MoveOn.org is hoping to fill the gap.

This is, without a doubt, the last thing the insurance companies want to hear.

Without a doubt, the first thing that I want to hear is that the insurance companies have been removed from the process.

Health insurance, like hurricane insurance, is not there to make you whole should you be afflicted. It’s there to make you feel good right up to the time that you need it.

  • Dennis -SGMM writes:
    “the first thing that I want to hear is that the insurance companies have been removed from the process.”

    True, but not so if Hils wins. She who has taken a large amount from the Health Insurance “industry” (Quotes because I believe industry produces something useful from time to time unlike the insurance “industry”.) Then it will be more of the same ole same ole. See her vote on bankruptcy “reform.”

    BTW, I read on huffington.post that Harvey Weinstein begged Moore not to display Hils name on the list of top benefactors from the Healthcare Industry. Not sure if this is true, but it would not surprise me if it was.

  • The ins. industry guys will find something else to do- they’ll be fine. I’m sure if they’ve got any smarts, they’ve saved up a lot in stocks and bonds and CDs.

  • Don’t worry, “health care” executives, if all it took was overwhelming popular support to change something, then we wouldn’t have the media deregulation we have. Remember the polling when Michael Powell gave us all the big middle finger?

    Congress will remember who can cut their throats, and they will pass a BS “compromise” package that does nothing but shift the dollars around and let the “health care” industry keep screwing the American people.

    What we need is to make the Congress live the way we do. Force them to find their own insurance as if they were self employed, and give them an “insurability” rating no higher than the average American’s. If their family has someone with “uninsurable” issues, too bad.

    If that happened, we would see some changes. But that’s about as likely as Tony snow busting out and saying “I can’t take it anymore! I lie for a living, and I work for a bunch of criminals! There, I said it, now God, please cure me of my cancer!!!”

  • If this is the Sicko effect, here’s my suggestion CB…

    Make sure every post of yours mentions the fact Fred Thompson’s kneejerk response was to attack Moore. With this article, which totally missed the point of the visit to Cuba by the 9/11 rescuers.

    http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=OWNhNzA2YmY3NTNjZjZhNjE1NmZjMDFkOTdjN2Q4ZmE=

    And then a stupid video which showed up Thompson as an out-of-touch elitist.

    http://www.breitbart.tv/?p=611

    Hoist Thompson by his own petard. He wanted to make light of healthcare, have him explain why.

  • Anyone else remember the “Harry and Louise” ads that the healthcare industry produced in response to the Clinton health plan back in 1993? Anyone recall that Time, CBS News, CNN, the Wall Street Journaland the Christian Science Monitor ran stories questioning whether there really was a health-care crisis? Do we actually think that it would be any different now?

    The candidate who proposes a national single payer plan that cuts out the insurance companies will disappear faster than Jimmy Hoffa. All seventeen candidates and the MSM probably do know what’s best for American health care but, they have theirs already and they definitely know who butters their bread.

  • Health Insurance Execs: “Quick! Someone kidnap a blonde woman!”

    All along, the health insurance game (like any other scam) has been a matter of how long the con artist can get away with it before the crowds start heating up tar and tearing open pillows. Is this the beginning of the end of the con? I don’t know.

    Anderson Cooper did a “Fact Check” of the movie and found some incorrect information. I’m sure the PR critters for the various HICs are practicing their damage control speeches. The problem is that people can be so irrational when their lives are at stake.

  • Let’s see…Michael Moore…ah, here it is. According to the office GOP Playbook: The Neoconicon it says to shoot the messenger.

  • It would be wonderful if this sort of thing happens frequently. However, we need to be aware that there might be a self-selected bias among those who attend Michael Moore’s movies. Many people in red states and conservatives in general are not likely to attend Moore’s movies because of their perception of who he is (leftist wacko). Even if the did, they would be disinclined to believe his presentaion of the facts. So, the people who attended that movie in Dallas (if the story is true) would be those who either had issues with health insurance in the own lives or were more liberaly inclined to begin with.

  • P.S. That being said, regardles of their politics, it’s remarkable if they did indeed rally outside the theater after the film was over. Let’s hope similar things happen elsewhere.

  • If each of us doesn’t have our own story of getting completely screwed by our healthcare system, we know firsthand accounts of someone close to us who had a horrific circumstance with healthcare. There is no other problem in this nation that intimately touches such a nerve across all lines. When Hary and Louise were around, insurance rates were lower and more of our employers were covering healthcare to a greater extent. Not so any more. The vast majority of America would be insulted by those ads now. This is a new day and I challenge anyone to find even a couple of people they know who aren’t mad as hell about healthcare.

  • I saw the movie this weekend and thought, no matter whether you agree with Michael Moore, you have to admire that he takes these huge cultural problems, and invests huge amounts of his own energy to blast out the message that what too many of us accept as an unchangeable reality doesn’t have to be that way.

    At the very least, I left with the impression that a) the health care/insurance system is even more FUBAR than I realilzed, and b) I need to do a little additional research on the effectiveness of single-payer systems. It would seem that almost anything would be better than the system we’ve got.

    I left the theater kind of depressed. I’m glad that there are apparently people moved from apathy to action.

  • “Socialized medicine.” That’s the term the country can’t get past. People don’t know what the hell it means, but they know it’s terrible. So terrible that they’d rather do without any health care at all than be condemned to “socialized medicine.” Just look at the facts: All the people in Canada, Britain, and France have been dead for years.

  • “All the people in Canada, Britain, and France have been dead for years.”

    I guess I’m posting this from the grave… Ha

  • If the phrase “socialized medicine” gives people the creaps, the curent counterpoint is “elitist medicine.” Our system rewards those who can afford to pay cash or their medical services over those with insurance. If you don’t believe me, negotiate with your doctor or hospital when it comes time to pay for services and ask them what they will charge you if you will pay cash on the barrelhead for your services instead of them having to process your claim through an insurance company. The results will startle you.

    Our system “works” if you have the cash to pay for everything up front. Not so much if you don’t.

    Another facet that can cure a lot of ills is to have Congress cease drug companies trying to market prescription drugs directly to the uneducated consumer. Let the physician make the decision and not the patient telling them what they have been led to believe by seeeing commercials. Stop the demand for expensive drugs at the source and healthcare should get cheaper within days.

  • “All the people in Canada, Britain, and France have been dead for years.”

    I guess I’m posting this from the grave… Ha — Former Dan. @16

    No, no. Just from your place in the queue to get an appointment to see a doctor…

  • Comments are closed.