‘So bad that it makes you wonder if democracy is a failed experiment’

Matt Taibbi’s cover-story in Rolling Stone on the Republican Congress is even better than I thought it’d be.

These past six years were more than just the most shameful, corrupt and incompetent period in the history of the American legislative branch. These were the years when the U.S. parliament became a historical punch line, a political obscenity on par with the court of Nero or Caligula — a stable of thieves and perverts who committed crimes rolling out of bed in the morning and did their very best to turn the mighty American empire into a debt-laden, despotic backwater, a Burkina Faso with cable.

Taibbi then spends a few thousand words proving it. He even conveniently breaks up the argument into five parts — Step one: Rule by cabal; Step two: Work as little as possible — and screw up what little you do; Step three: Let the president do whatever he wants; Step four: Spend, spend, spend; Step five: Line your own pockets.

“The 109th Congress is so bad that it makes you wonder if democracy is a failed experiment,” says Jonathan Turley, a noted constitutional scholar and the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington Law School. “I think that if the Framers went to Capitol Hill today, it would shake their confidence in the system they created. Congress has become an exercise of raw power with no principles — and in that environment corruption has flourished. The Republicans in Congress decided from the outset that their future would be inextricably tied to George Bush and his policies. It has become this sad session of members sitting down and drinking Kool-Aid delivered by Karl Rove. Congress became a mere extension of the White House.”

There are a slew of great anecdotes in here, but like Pandagon, I thought this one summed up quite a bit about how the GOP-led Congress operates:

One of the most depressing examples of one-party rule is the Patriot Act. The measure was originally crafted in classic bipartisan fashion in the Judiciary Committee, where it passed by a vote of thirty-six to zero, with famed liberals like Barney Frank and Jerrold Nadler saying aye. But when the bill was sent to the Rules Committee, the Republicans simply chucked the approved bill and replaced it with a new, far more repressive version, apparently written at the direction of then-Attorney General John Ashcroft.

“They just rewrote the whole bill,” says Rep. James McGovern, a minority member of the Rules Committee. “All that committee work was just for show.”

Of course it was. That’s how this gang operates.

Just to add to the fun, Taibbi also ranked “The 10 Worst Congressmen,” though he stuck only to the House:

1. Dennis Hastert (R-Ill.)

2. James Sensenbrenner jr. (R-Wis.)

3. Don Young (R-Alaska)

4. William Jefferson (D-La.)

5. Jerry Lewis (R-Calif.)

6. Tom Tancredo (R-Colo.)

7. Dick Pombo (R-Calif.)

8. Curt Weldon (R-Pa.)

9. Hal Rogers (R-Ken.)

10. Marilyn Musgrave (R-Colo.)

It’s hard to argue with this, though Reps. Steve King (R-Iowa) and Patrick McHenry (R-N.C.) certainly belong on the list somewhere, at least as dishonorable mentions.

Did he miss any of your personal favorites?

Katherine Harris of Florida.

  • Well, Republican’tism is a failed experiment. I wouldn’t say democracy has failed just because we can’t get it right in this country.

    I suppose Jo Ann (Christmas Tree Protector) Davis (R-VA 1st) probably doesn’t deserve to be in the list, despite the fact she shared two committee assignments with Rany (Duke) Cunningham and should have been aware of his corruption.

  • How is this good political writing?

    The GOP’s “take that, bitch” approach to governing has been taken to the greatest heights by the House Judiciary Committee. The committee is chaired by the legendary Republican monster James Sensenbrenner Jr., an ever-sweating, fat-fingered beast who wields his gavel in a way that makes you think he might have used one before in some other arena, perhaps to beat prostitutes to death.

  • Sessions is a backbencher and not prominent like those other guys. But if you made a list of “Top 10 Dumbest Members of Congress,” Sessions would probably be on it. Guy always seems like he’s just had a lobotomy.

    King and McHenry didn’t make it, but it’s not for lack of trying. King is a complete looneybird with a raving mouth and McHenry is a College Republican thug wandering the halls of Congress. Witness his pathetic attempts to try and turn the Foley matter against Democrats.

  • ‘So bad that it makes you wonder if democracy is a failed experiment’

    These ten are good examples of when parents should have “snuffed their own seed”.

  • Democracy isn’t a failed experiment, or any experiment it’s just a form of government.

    To rephrase what Turley said into what he means:
    America’s experiment with Democracy is a failure…

    Let’s not write off Democracy just yet; let’s just try to be more like Canada.

  • I don’t think it fair to say Democracy is a failed experiment, it just proves humans haven’t evolved to the point where they can truly appreciate it. I do think it fair to say that the US as we know it will go the way of every other great empire and the crap that has gone on for the past six years has done to accelerate that process.

    Who would I add to the list? Someone already got my first pick: Crayzee Mascara Laydee (K. Harris).

  • Wow, just finished reading the whole article. While none of it was new, when you put it together in one package, it really brings home the sheer volume of sleeze and corruption. The irony is that even if the Dem’s win back both houses, it will take years, if not decades to clean up this mess. I truly feel sorry for the Democratic caucass, they really have their work cut out for them.

  • The irony is that even if the Dem’s win back both houses, it will take years, if not decades to clean up this mess. I truly feel sorry for the Democratic caucass, they really have their work cut out for them.

    Comment by Liam J

    That’s a really good point. And I think if the Dems do win, it will be sort of ‘uh oh moms’ home’. There will again be adult supervision. There’s some danger of Dems trying to fix everything at once and imposing discipline that will alienate a citizenry that has been used to sacrificing nothing at all.

  • Bob Ney.

    John Boehner.

    Jean Schmidt.

    Katharine Harris.

    And that whining imbecile Curt Weldon.

    Goodness, trying to keep it to 10 in this day and age is like trying to decide which is worse, death by drowning or being eaten by wolves.

    -GFO

  • I don’t know that democracy has failed, but recent developments certainly have solidified my belief that the Revolution was a horrible mistake.

  • Democracy isn’t a failed experiment.

    One party rule is a failed experiment.

    Ignoring checks and balance is a failed experiment.

    the “Imperial Executive” with a boy king at the helm is a failed experiment.

    Putting loyalty to the Bush family over loyalty to America is a failed experiment.

    Manipulating and exploiting tragedy and fear for your agenda is a failed experiment.

    But if We The People decide to keep Washington the same on November 7th, then it may very well become a failed experiment.

  • Taibbi sounds like he’s been an active reader of the Carpetbagger Report.

    What dark humor to be able to joke that a contest was held for the ten worst Congressmen and twenty Republicans showed up.

  • #5 How is this good political writing?

    Um … it’s Rolling Stone not The National Review, dude. One of the first rules of good writing: Write to your audience. For all the aging baby boomers and hipster wannabe frat boys that read that rag, I think Taibbi nails it. It’s certainly vivd.

    Besides, after everything I’ve read about James Sensenbrenner, that’s a fair assessment.

  • ***a stable of thieves and perverts who committed crimes rolling out of bed in the morning***

    In other words, a Tammany Hall at the Federal level.

    Oh…and I would like to nominate the entire GOP caucus from Ohio….

  • Marilyn Musgrave only made #10. She is my congresswoman and I can attest that she is much worse than that.

    I’m heading out tomorrow morning to spread the good news about her opponent, Angie Paccione.

    Go Angie!

  • “Besides, after everything I’ve read about James Sensenbrenner, that’s a fair assessment.”

    Wow. Clever. How is this crap any different from all the bullshit thrown out by the GOP against the dems? How is saying stuff like “How can we trust the GOP to protect America if they can’t protect congressional pages” any different than all the things republicans said against Clinton during the Monica affair?

    Shouldn’t we be able to do better than that, dude, even if it’s Rolling Stone?

  • Shouldn’t we be able to do better than that, dude, even if it’s Rolling Stone?

    No, not really. Nor would I suggest we “elevate” the discussion by ignoring the right-wing’s sordid behavior. Republicans have set this tone for the national dialogue for by word and deed for well over a decade now. If they and their concern troll followers can’t handle being held to their own narrow standards, they should STFU and get the fuck out of politics.

    Really, dude, there are more important things at stake here than your delicate sensibilities.

  • If “Democracy is a failed experiment,” then why are any of you here doing any of the things you are doing?

    We live in great times. We get to save America the way my six-times-great Grandfather did when he crossed the Delaware with General Washington and saved the failed rebellion.

    And we can do it with the same words in our heads he heard read to him over the fire as he warmed himself before picking up his musket and climbing aboard that boat…

    THESE are the times that try men’s souls. The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will, in this crisis, shrink from the service of their country; but he that stands by it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman. Tyranny, like hell, is not easily conquered; yet we have this consolation with us, that the harder the conflict, the more glorious the triumph. What we obtain too cheap, we esteem too lightly: it is dearness only that gives every thing its value. Heaven knows how to put a proper price upon its goods; and it would be strange indeed if so celestial an article as FREEDOM should not be highly rated.

    So get off your dead asses and onto your dyin’ feet, you wussies.

  • Comments are closed.