Sometimes, virginity pledgers lie about sex

We’ve known for a while that [tag]abstinence[/tag]-only policies are costly, inaccurate, and ineffective. But in case those minor details weren’t enough, it’s also worth remembering that teenagers [tag]lie[/tag] about their [tag]sexual[/tag] history.

Teenagers who take pledges to remain [tag]virgins[/tag] until marriage are likely to deny having taken the pledge if they later become sexually active. Conversely, those who were sexual active before taking the [tag]pledge[/tag] frequency deny their sexual history, according to new study findings.

These findings imply that [tag]virginity[/tag] pledgers often provide unreliable data, making assessment of abstinence-based sex education programs unreliable. In addition, these teens may also underestimate their risk of exposure to sexually transmitted diseases.

“Teenagers do not report their past [tag]sex[/tag]ual activity accurately, with virginity pledgers giving more inaccurate reports of their past sexual activity,” study author Janet Rosenbaum, of Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, told Reuters Health.

Among those willing to admit it, more than half of the adolescents who sign abstinence pledges break the promise within a year. And since much of the other half lie about it, it’s getting increasingly difficult for any serious person to say with a straight face that abstinence-only is effective.

If only that was enough to convince Bush to stop throwing our money at this nonsense, we’d see some real progress.

Teenagers lie? Duuhhh!!

  • This is going to happen as long as American Christian Society shames girls (especially) and boys for having pre-marital, “unsanctioned and unsanctified” SEX. And we are going to have far too many abortions also, because the girls are ashamed to admit to their activities and deal with the consequencies.

    All of which, sickeningly, is do to the fact that our various Churchs can’t handle the fact that Christianity is based on the teaching of two apocalyptic ascetics who (Jesus and Paul) did not engage in sex and thought of it as something about on the level of death and sin, which would NOT be possible to practice in a Kingdom of God due to come before the end of their generation.

    So now, two millenium later, American Christian Society is still trying to stop healthy young people from engaging in a naturally enjoyable activity which is necessary for the continuation of our species because they can’t figure out how to just accept human sexual freedom.

  • Wait a minute here! People lie? People lie about sex?

    Does that mean that I’m not the best she ever had?
    Does that mean I’m not the only one?

    Oh my…

    Excuse me. Sniff. My self esteem is now as low as Tracy Henke’s!

    Too damned funny.

  • If you can stop Bush throwing money at anything, that’d be not just progress, but a bloody miracle

  • I wish congress would take a pledge not to screw the American people.

    Comment by kali — 6/2/2006 @ 10:29 am

    Ah, but they do… unfortunately, it looks like they don’t honor their pledges so much, either.

  • I did not have sex with that woman, Monica Pelolski. I swear. I took a virginity pledge didn’t I.

  • The Virgin Mary took the virginity pledge, look what happened, the Immaculate Conception.

  • Virginity Pledgers – I think its a bit unfair just to single out teenagers..

    Many Catholic Priests have made a right mess of their celebacy pledges for decades.

  • Comments are closed.