The Bush administration and the fine art of planted questions

If a Democrat asks a question at a debate for Republican presidential candidates, far-right activists reflexively (and incoherently) define this as a “planted” question.

But, of course, given the meaning of the word, that doesn’t make a lot of sense. To really appreciate what a “plant” looks like, you’ll have to turn to the Bush administration.

For example, once the Bush gang’s initial rationale for the war in Iraq was exposed as a fraud, then-National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice launched a public-relations campaign to shield herself from the fiasco (Rice frequently went on national television to tout the notion that we can’t wait to be sure Iraq is a threat, because we “don’t want the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud”).

According to the WaPo’s Glenn Kessler, Rice’s strategy included ordering an aide to “plant a question” about her possible presidential ambitions.

She had a very deliberative public relations strategy when she became Secretary of State to help erase the images of how ineffective she had been as National Security Adviser. And I describe how one of her aides even planted a question with a friendly journalist to ask whether she would be interested in running for president — to give her the aura of someone who might have presidential aspirations, make her seem more powerful than she was.

And that all helped negate American memories over her very direct role in the invasion of Iraq.

See? That’s a planted question.

Speaking of shameless Bush administration propaganda, you probably won’t be surprised to learn that those responsible for a recent fake FEMA press conference have been “punished” for their mistake by receiving a promotion.

On Oct. 23, the day of FEMA’s now infamous phony news conference, the agency’s former external affairs chief, Pat Philbin, announced plans to promote a number of people in the shop as part of an effort to build a “new FEMA.”

Cindy Taylor, deputy director of public affairs, was to become head of a new Private Sector Office, Philbin said in his e-mail to staff members. And Mike Widomski would move up to replace Taylor as deputy director of public affairs.

Loop Fans might recall that both of them, posing as reporters, asked questions of acting Deputy Administrator Harvey Johnson. After our item, and an investigation of what Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff called “one of the dumbest and most inappropriate things I’ve seen since I’ve been in government,” we’re happy to announce that Taylor and Widomski appear to have been disciplined, FEMA-style.

They’ve received the promotions they were in line to get.

So, according to the External Affairs Weekly report for this week, Taylor is director of the Private Sector Division, and Widomski is deputy director of public affairs.

As unpredictable as the Bush gang can be, the one thing we can count on is that those who are caught making a mistake will, without a doubt, get promoted. The bigger the screw-up, the bigger the promotion.

Hi CB,
What is “incomprehensively”?
Howard

  • Um, aren’t planted questions really business as usual for everyone? Not that anyone should get their history from TV shows, but planted questions were pretty standard on The West Wing. And That 70’s Show had a whole episode dedicated to Red asking Gerald Ford a planted question. These were pretty uncontroversial parts of the pop culture. So, other than right wing looniness (and if you’ve listened to Rush at all this week, there is no other way to describe it), what’s the big deal?

  • Martin, I think the big deal is when all of the questions are planted so all the answers can be carefully rehearsed. But I’ve felt that most of these “debates” really are just the exchange of sound bites, not ideas. I don’t watch, particularly since SB has been doing such a fine job of rehashing the essentials for me.

  • Martin, there’s been this thing going on where the Republicans are saying if anyone worked in the past for a liberal organization or is a Democrat and asks them a question at an event, it’s not a fair question to have asked. Apparently they think they don’t have to answer questions from people who live in the country about how they do their jobs anymore.

  • Once you beomce a rich, elected ashole, that’s the end of achievement for these Republicans, I guess, and no one can question you about anything, lest they be a big poopy-head.

  • Willing to plant questions? Maybe a Freedom Medal will be your reward! This Administration is a miserable lot, with perverse ideas of what reality really is. On another note, how about those DUIs our not so beloved VP received in Wyoming. Drunk and out of control – the exact way I will remember the Bush Administration! -Kevo

  • How about the ultimate in planted questions: When Bush went anywhere and spoke with the “public”, the “public” was always well vetted as Bush supporters who would never ask him a question that would tax his tiny little pea-brain.

  • Jen and Swan:
    I agree that the Repubs are making alot of noise about it, and surely Bush is the King of the Planted question (does he ever get a question not planted?), it’s that it just seems to be a badly kept secret of both sides that questions have been planted just this side of forever. Shouldn’t someone say so? Or would that embarass the press even more?

  • Don’t forget the male prostitute who was given special access to White House press conferences without journalistic qualifications and was always called upon to provide a reliably right-wing talking point.

  • Comments are closed.