The ‘Pharisee effect’ in Alabama

I noted a couple of weeks ago that a series of far-right candidates were seeking statewide office in [tag]Alabama[/tag], all of whom believe that the states are not bound by U.S. Supreme Court precedents or the Bill of Rights. I’m pleased to report that all of these candidates lost in the state’s primary races last week. It’s worth taking a moment to consider why.

In fact, Alabamians dealt a series of blows to the most radical GOP candidates on the ballot. Roy Moore only managed 33% support in his gubernatorial campaign, and all of his like-minded cohorts were defeated in state judicial races. Did conservative Alabama [tag]voters[/tag] suddenly shift to the center? Not at all. The same day Moore and other theocrats lost, 81% of state voters approved a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage.

So what happened? One local journalist wrote an item (brought to my attention by reader J.C.) explaining that the far-right candidates may have stumbled because of “the [tag]Pharisee[/tag] effect.”

Moore and his slate got hit with “the Pharisee effect,” said Larry Powell, a longtime pollster who had correctly predicted the outcome of Tuesday’s primary.

Powell said many voters became tired of [tag]Moore[/tag] constantly talking about religion and began to suspect he was using the issue for his own advancement.

Powell, who teaches communications at The University of Alabama at Birmingham, sees no conflict between Bible Belt voters defeating candidates on the religious right and passing a constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriages.

“The values concept is still there, but they are highly suspicious of someone who uses it for their own ambitions,” he said.

You don’t say. Voters, even in a state like Alabama where the religious right is extremely influential, have grown apprehensive about candidates who seek public office on a religious platform and who would rather talk about theology than public policy.

I wonder if Ralph Reed noticed these results?

I’m up for a jjob in Birmingham, and the thought of moving down there is daunting. I suppose this is somewhat encouraging…

  • Mr. Furious, don’t sweat it too much. I don’t know where you’d be moving from, but Birmingham is quite nice, actually. I’ve been going to Alabama twice a year for years now because my sister and her husband live in Tuscaloosa. I’ve found that like most decent sized cities in southern states, people are quite nice and there are plenty of dems/liberals around. Heck, there’s even a gay bar in Birmingham. It’s the smaller, more isolated towns you have to be a little wary of, but that’s true for almost anywhere.

    My brother-in-law’s read on the Moore situation is that Moore has become an embarassment in the state, that Moore pushes too hard and too far, regardless of how they personally feel about church/state seperation. Even in Alabama there is too much of a good thing, even when it comes to mixing politics and religion.

  • Pharisees not good. See Mt 23:1-36, especially verse 27: “Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye are like unto whited sepulchres, which indeed appear beautiful outward, but are within full of dead men’s bones, and of all uncleanness.”

    After the experience of the last five year’s I’m not even sure about “appear beautiful outward”. The unclean bones are at last beginning to show through.

  • Now that voters are becoming disenchanted with politicos using religion for personal advancement, will they next trun against political parties that constantly use 9/11 for their personal gain?

  • Wow, that’s cool, Ed. “Dead men’s bones”. Pretty much sums up the whole White House staff, doesn’t it? Good name for a rock band, too.

    And good for you, Alabama!! I knew you could do it. 🙂

  • The bigger question is how the founder of the Alabama Atheist and holocaust denier got 44% of the DEMOCRATIC primary vote for AG running on a platform of declaring martial law to protect us from an invasion of illegal aliens.

    The problem with the Moore gang is they had one note and kept playing it. Considering who they ran against, they couldn’t out christian the opposition, which is all they tried to do.

    I haven’t see any numbers yet, but the most of the liberals I know voted in the Republican primary to vote against Moore.

    Such is the joy of Alabama politics.

  • I live in Birmingham and voted in the primary and I agree with Martin — the number of Democrats that voted in the Rebublican primary mainly to vote against Moore and his gang. I know a lot of people who did this — myself included. While this cross over is a part of the defeat, I do believe Alabamians are realizing how crazy this guy is.

  • I was in the Florida panhandle last week.

    The attack ads these guys were running were something else. Glad they lost.

  • Comments are closed.