This … is CNN?

Remember, conservative activists are convinced that CNN is unfriendly territory for Republicans. That is, except for all the ones the network keeps hiring. (via TP)

Frances Fragos Townsend will be announced tomorrow as a CNN contributor, joining former colleague Tony Snow. Townsend was assistant to the president for homeland security and counterterrorism and is a Yankee fan.

I’m almost surprised it’s taken this long. Townsend, Bush’s former chief terrorism adviser, joins Tony Snow (conservative), J.C. Watts (conservative), and William Bennett (conservative) on the news network that conservatives believe is biased against them.

The last we heard from Townsend, she was complaining that the Bush administration had been “crippled” because its officials are “worried about getting subpoenaed.” (Apparently, Townsend believes that Congress should go back to ignoring the administration’s scandalous, sometimes criminal, behavior, so that way the president and his aides would find it much easier to go about their business without the fear of accountability.)

Indeed, Townsend has quite a history of offering insightful comments. Last fall, Townsend defended the Bush administration’s “harsh interrogation techniques” during an interview on CNN. She assured Americans that the abuse of detainees stops “if someone becomes cooperative.” (In other words, “We stop torturing when we get what we want out of the suspect.”)

In July, Townsend appeared on NPR to talk about terrorist activities in Iraq. When the host asked if al Qaeda had any capabilities in Iraq before Bush launched his 2003 invasion, Townsend said, “I don’t know — I wasn’t at that briefing.”

Around the same time, Townsend couldn’t explain why the war in Iraq had become a boon for al Qaeda recruitment and fundraising.

And December 2006, Townsend was on CNN when she delivered one of my favorite lines of all time. CNN White House correspondent Ed Henry noted that, despite Bush’s promises, Osama bin Laden remains a free man. Henry suggested that this should probably be considered a “failure” in the war on terror. Townsend responded, “I’m not sure — it’s a success that hasn’t occurred yet.”

Now CNN is going to pay her to offer similar insights. Great.

I’d just add that this is the latest part of a strange phenomenon of rewarding the Bush gang in general with high-profile opportunities at major media outlets. The Bush White House has been, for lack of a better word, a disaster for the country. From a journalistic perspective, these guys have been a nightmare — embracing almost comical levels of secrecy, propaganda, and media manipulation. (Or, in Townsend’s case, just bizarre and incomprehensible analysis.)

And yet, the moment presidential aides leave the West Wing, media outlets jump at the chance to put them on the payroll.

Michael Gerson was picked up as a columnist for the Washington Post.

Sara Taylor, who was integrally involved in the U.S. Attorney Purge scandal and the politicization of federal agencies, became a pundit for MSNBC.

Karl Rove became a Fox News “analyst,” a columnist for Newsweek, and a columnist for the Wall Street Journal.

Tony Snow has parlayed his mendacity into a gig on CNN.

And now Frances Fragos Townsend will go from the White House to CNN, as well.

[Update: And let’s also not forget that Nicole Wallace was part of CBS News before leaving to join the McCain campaign.]

Why would a “liberal” media keep giving jobs to members of the Bush gang? Because “working the refs” works.

If you keep in mind that the ONLY thing that Wingnut Republicans bring to the Party are complaints then it’s easy to understand. Without perceived slights they cease to exist.

  • The right wing media is girding itself for a Democratic takeover in November. The Democrats may control the Executive and Legislative branches in the fall, but right wingers will control the airwaves. Let the pie fights begin. God help us all.

  • Because “working the refs” works.

    This implies there was outside pressure, and I do think that argument would apply to PBS. But not CNN. They got rid of Ted Turner and began a steady stream of murdochization.

  • It is evident that we must move quickly to rename what have laughingly been called “the news media” to something more reflective of reality. You don’t have to spend much time watching CNN or CNN “Headline News” before you realize that this network no longer employs reporters engaged in covering news beats. What it is doing is putting in its employ opinionists and prognosticators whose opinings are not grounded in anything remotely factual. This once valuable source of news around the nation and the world is now just a shameless sham of what was its purported intent when it was founded years ago.

  • I agree with petorado. They have to get the right people in place before the general election campaign.

  • Please don’t forget the neocon’s neocon, William Kristol, hired by the same NY times that had difficulty tolerating the late Molly Ivins.

  • Is there any website which tracks the pundit personalities which appear on the major news outlets?

    Recently we discovered that ex-Generals were part of a propaganda campaign, something which might have become apparent if television appearance were tracked.

    I assume this would be similar to a personality database where you could choose your guests based upon what you wanted your guests to say, or the correct demographics, etc.

    It would also be interesting to track supposed title, like democratic strategist, black preacher, etc.

    MSNBC has a Republican strategist who is black, a preacher, from PA. He was the perfect choice to bash Obama over the Wright controversy. The day after Obama’s news conference he was on a segment to talk about TV ads, which had been running for weeks. He got exclusive commentary on two Obama ads, and his response was that Obama is trying to ‘change the subject’ from Wright. So, it seemed to me that MSNBC may have been trying to milk another day out of the subject by seating this guy, but he hasn’t been back on since then. He just evaporated. Poof!

    But there needs to be some effort. The framing of the debate is hard to push back on without data.

  • Before, we had more Conservatives to reflect the power balance in Washington. But starting next election, we need to speak truth to power.

  • Once large multi-national corporations consolidated their control of the main stream media, and the lines between news, commentary, and entertainment became so blurred they are now indistinguishable, the future was foretold. MSM will be corporate-friendly, right-wing, shallow, and oblivious, as well as peddling Republican propaganda.

    An anticipated shift to the Democrats in November will take the gloves off the MSM. Suddenly there will be endless investigative pieces on Democratic wrong-doing, coruption, and skull-duggery. All the questions that were never asked, but should have been, of Bushco will be asked of Clinton/Obama. It will be a never ending anti-administration tirade. Had the MSM, understandably, done that to Bush’s thugocracy, they would have been labeled unpatriotic and subversive.

    Double standards are all over the place, but you ain’t seen nothing yet.

  • Infiltrate the media in order to tear down the next administration for yrs to come. None of these people listed above are credible analysts as evidenced by their current work. It truly is corporate media, used to promote the money agenda and the grab for power by those who have taken over our country. Our laws have been twisted to sustain them and we are getting closer to having only one way of dealing with them. Will we allow our government to be privatized or will we nationalize our energy industry which we all must depend on. Will we break up the media monopolies or just stand by and tolerate corporate news. Is assassination and insurgency, serfs against kings, poor against wealthy becoming necessary because there is no longer common ground only greedy manipulation by the wealthy. If all those pundits mentioned above just disappeared never to be heard of again we would definitely notice and feel as if a great class of petty hate had disappeared from our discourse because that is all they represent never once having said anything of value.

    No corporation should last more than 40yrs. not corporation can own stock in other corporations, corporations must perform for the common good or have their charters revoked…this is the way it used to be…and now look at the results of it not being that way now. Look at the corporate media’s propaganda.

    The country is predominately liberal and progressive yet the establishment press is dominated by right wing conservatives…that’s what corporate money buys…rules by and for the elite only (the elite being the extremely wealthy who like to think of themselves as the “ruling class”) and those who try to spread their superiority through the establishment media.
    Townsend’s statements should have been enough to ensure she would never be paid for her opinions on national tv…how sick is this.

  • CNN has been the Conservative News Network since Turner left.

    Conservatives are still not happy because it is not Fox. While conservative, it still maintains some degree of jouranlistic integrity. They do not actively promote the conservative agenda the same way that Fox does, and most of the CNN conservatives are not as doctrinaire and extreme as the Fox conservatives.

  • tomj@8 – I think you’re talking of Joe Watkins. I had no idea he was a minister until he appeared on a news segment this past week, commenting on a horrendous fire at a neighboring church to his in Philadelphia.

    I see him on MSNBC quite often, so I don’t think they just pull him out every so often. I was sort of shocked, though, when it was said he was a minister; that has to be a terrible conflict of interests, somehow.

  • I stopped watching CNN a couple years ago. The corporate pay masters decided that it was just too expensive to fill 24 hours of a news network with actual news and honest exposition. It is cheaper to pay millions to co-opt a few celebrity talking heads (who will push the corporate line in ways obvious and less so) than to actually staff news bureaus with reporters. CNN is not even a “go to” spot for breaking news. I suppose part of the calculus at CNN is that people like me – who do not find the likes of Bill Bennett, Tony Snow and JC Watt particularly fair, illuminating, or scintillating – have moved to the internet (newspaper web sites and blogs and hybrids like Josh’s TPM) to find their information. So, they are left to battle Fox for the remainder, who apparently either have not yet noticed the low quality of what is being fed to them or are fans of the stable of commentators (except, maybe, Jeff Toobin). I am particularly amused that CNN continues to have a channel to which it refers as “Headline News.” This pathetic creature is the domain of Nancy Grace (there’s an ironic name if there ever was one) and Glen Beck. If I had a la carte cable, this dreck would be among the first channels I would jettison.

  • Visit any employee lunch room in any factory and 9 times out of 10, they have CNN on a television set somewhere. What better way to grab the blue collar vote than to feed them right wing disinformation while they’re feeding themselves?

  • I, too, have switched from CNN, after being a faithful viewer since it came on the air in 1980.

    I now watch MSNBC exclusively and will continue to do so til the election in November. I like the mix of liberal and conservative viewpoints. I have a few problems with the “talking heads” keeping the Wright “controversy alive, but I think, all in all, it’s the best cable news programming I’ve found. How it will change after the election, I don’t know.

    The only thing I cannot stand about MSNBC are those stupid shows about prison life and crimes. I cannot believe that the same viewers who tune in for politics also watch the crime and prison dreck, and vise-versa.

    I wonder if MSNBC will return to more “dreck” programming AFTER the election. If so, I just won’t watch.

    I do like “Morning Joe”. Unfortunately, it’s on here from 4a-7a. Since I sleep with my TV on but the sound off, I’ll sometimes wake up around 4, turn up the sound, and listen and doze for a few hours.

  • I have long since stopped calling the media MSM because that is not an accurate description. I now always refer to them as CM (corporate media) for that is exactly what they are. Besides, if you look at numbers of falling print and television news readers and watchers, are they really mainstream?

    The corporate media is worried… They need a gooper in office so they are preparing the lie machine now. There is a back-scratching thing…the government needs the media as much as the corporations need their politicians. The CM must have a friend in the president – and the president needs his/her media whores. The CM sucks as much as two goopers running right now.

  • carpet …. the msm is just hell bent on proving beyond a shadow of a doubt how profoundly out of touch and irrelevant they are: not to mention creatively and intellectually bankrupt.

    it’s not even amusing pointing out their pointlessness anymore. usually, they shoot themselves in the foot incrementally, and you only gradually notice their slide into oblivion.

    sometimes: they do things that are breathtakingly stupid, and it makes the decision to leave any kind of “televised” “news” quick and easy.

    abc accelerated the demise of “tv” “news” fifty-fold with their debate fiasco. i used to occasionally watch the network evening news — and when i did: it was always abc. the morning after that debate — i shut down evening news forever …. i will never watch it again — and if i tune in to some kind of network coverage of a news event, i’ll crawl out of an iron lung to make sure my tv isn’t on ABC — i will never, ever give their news division a millionth of a neilsen point. i wonder how many others there are like me ?

    as for cnn ? pathetic … i have a close relationship with suits on the inside there, as well as at fox. for a while, i gave cnn credit for trying to take the high road against the brainless populism of fox, and for accepting that they were caught in the middle of a perfect storm of national trauma, political exploitation, and a news competitor that was, LITERALLY, being programmed by Karl Rove and the GOP. (i was at the meetings).

    but now …. NOW ? after there are signs that the cable news audience may have more intelligence than fox news gives them credit for .. ? NOW that there is clearly a backlash against superficial, propagandic-driven news coverage … NOW that cnn is slowly building an intelligenct credible audience that wants substance and relevance …. and they hire on two of the criminal syndicate’s worst apologists ? pffffffffft. bye cnn …. that’s all it takes. welcome to the scrapheap, and enjoy your slide to oblivion along with abc and the other dinosaurs. you — and what’s left of your atrophying audience — is dying. and you deserve it.

    see you never.

  • I have an easy solution: Don’t watch CNN.

    I quit watching both that network and MSNBC, and now get my news from PBS, NPR and most especially the BBC, which clearly does a far superior job of reporting U.S. news and informing its viewers and listeners about issues and events in our own country that than does our own corporate-shilling, cheerleading and bimbo-babbling mainstream American media.

  • I think reichwing conservatives should stop trying to conform our nation to their crap and just move to Utah, where they can be happy!

  • Just as the “terrorists” are winning by playing the dead-head in the White House for the incompetent war-monger that he is, so shall the “neo-con fascists” who are being allowed to take over all media outlets subvert, destroy and “win” by cramming BS down the throats of the non-thinking sheep in this Country who blindly follow the likes of rash lymphnode and his ilk. The self”right”eous hate to think for themselves. They not only want, but NEED their information (news) pulverized, purified and filtered by ingestion through the intestines of swinelike creatures whose daily talking points are written, approved, edited and distributed by the White House press rodents. God save us from the self-proclaimed, self-aggrandizing, self-righteous media mouths of the neo-con right.

  • The “terrorists” have won already by helping “w” bankrupt our Country AND the next generation as well as trashing our Constitution. The president, vice president and the vast majority of Cabinet members of this ne’er-do-well administration should all be incarcerated and relieved of their ill-gotten pensions and perks. Better yet, they should be made to live the life of an average, middle class family for the rest of their worthless lives.

  • Just a reminder – Townsend was chosen by Janet Reno to head DOJ’s Office of Intelligence Policy and Review ( the DOJ’s interface with the FISA Court), obviously during the Clinton Admin. Right wing – I think not!

  • 12. On May 4th, 2008 at 1:47 pm, jhm said:
    Q:”Is there any website which tracks the pundit personalities which appear on the major news outlets?”
    A. I think it would be a great idea to put together an informative website informing viewers were each pundit stands. This can be done by researching. I think if everybody pulls their research and information of the MSM pundits and upload it to one file, link it to a blog it will prove to be successful and useful to the public. I believe if this is to be done, it should be done as soon as possible before the general election begins. It will have a great affect on the MSM knowing that they are on watch. Me and my organization can be reached at dembocommittee@yahoo.com.

  • 12. On May 4th, 2008 at 1:47 pm, jhm said:
    Q:”Is there any website which tracks the pundit personalities which appear on the major news outlets?”
    A. I think it would be a great idea to put together an informative website informing viewers were each pundit stands. This can be done by researching. I think if everybody pulls their research and information of the MSM pundits and upload it to one file, link it to a blog it will prove to be successful and useful to the public. I believe if this is to be done, it should be done as soon as possible before the general election begins. It will have a great affect on the MSM knowing that they are on watch. My organization and I can be reached at dembocommittee@yahoo.com.

  • Comments are closed.