Tim Johnson has surgery, remains in critical condition

Sen. Tim Johnson (D-S.D.) underwent brain surgery yesterday after suffering what’s being described as “stroke-like symptoms.” He is in critical condition.

There was no formal announcement of the South Dakota senator’s condition, The Associated Press reported, but a person in the hospital’s media relations office, who declined to be identified, said the hospital was preparing to announce that Johnson’s condition was critical. […]

Johnson spokeswoman Julianne Fisher said the senator was in the Capitol on Wednesday morning conducting a conference call with South Dakota reporters when “his speech pattern slipped off.”

Fisher said the senator was able to walk back to his office in the Hart Senate Office Building, then began having problems with his right arm. He thought he was all right, she said, and went to his desk, but came out a few minutes later and “it was apparent he needed help.”

Staffers put him on a couch in the office and called the Capitol doctor, she said. He was taken to the hospital shortly afterward. His wife, in the office to have lunch with him, rode with him, Fisher said.

“It transpired very fast,” she said, adding the senator’s staff was shaken by the incident. But, she said of the hospital, “we keep reminding ourselves, this is where they take Dick Cheney.”

As for the political implications, there’s been ample discussion, here and elsewhere, about legal and political procedures. Without rehashing the discussion from yesterday afternoon, it’s worth noting that the consensus seems to be that there is no mechanism in place to replace Johnson if he recovers but is unable to fulfill his duties during his recuperation.

There is some precedent, the NYT noted, for extended absences from the Senate for health reasons. Sen. Robert Wagner (D-N.Y.), for example, missed nearly all Senate business for three years because of a heart ailment.

There’s some additional speculation about what happens if the Senate begins with a Democratic majority, but transitions to a 50-50 Senate.

In a 50-50 Senate, Vice President Cheney could break tie votes in the GOP’s favor. But a Senate that becomes evenly split after it is in session would not necessarily fall to Republicans, Senate historians said. Rules and precedents could leave a party in charge of the chamber even after its membership falls below that of the other party.

“It’s what happens in January that counts,” said Senate associate historian Donald A. Ritchie, referring to when party leaders hash out rules governing the chamber’s organization. […]

In order to adopt new rules organizing the Senate, the two parties must reach nearly unanimous agreement. Democrats in 2001 blocked the naming of committee chairmen and members, demanding concessions before agreeing to the rules. Among those concessions: Should the numerical advantage change, all committee assignments and chairmanships would be nullified, and a new organization would have to be submitted.

That’s what happened, not because of a death but because disgruntled moderate Republican Sen. James M. Jeffords (Vt.) decided to caucus with the Democrats, giving them a 51-49 edge and the powers of the majority. Senate Republican sources said yesterday that their party is likely to press for similar concessions when negotiating the operating rules for the next Congress. But even if Johnson were incapacitated, Democratic aides say, they would resist.

On a slightly more encouraging note for our often-toxic political atmosphere, you need not check far-right sites for scurrilous comments hoping for the worst — it appears everyone’s on their best behavior. As one conservative put it, “Well, look, I want control of the Senate as much as the next Republican, but not this way: best wishes for a speedy recovery to Senator Johnson. Sheer human decency should overrule partisanship on a story like this.”

Update (9:31am): The office of Senator Tim Johnson has released the following:

Admiral John Eisold, Attending Physician of the United States Capitol said, “Subsequent to his admission to George Washington University Hospital yesterday, Senator Tim Johnson was found to have had an intracerebral bleed caused by a congenital arteriovenous malformation. He underwent successful surgery to evacuate the blood and stabilize the malformation. The Senator is recovering without complication in the critical care unit at George Washington University Hospital. It is premature to determine whether further surgery will be required or to assess any long term prognosis.”

Barbara Johnson, wife of Senator Johnson, said, “The Johnson family is encouraged and optimistic. They are grateful for the prayers and good wishes of friends, supporters and South Dakotans. They are especially grateful for the work of the doctors and all medical personnel and GWU hospital.”

“suffering what’s being described as “stroke-like symptoms.” ”

Reminds me of the scene in the movie “Dave” when the President’s men are trying to figure out how to spin his stroke and their substitution.

Seriously, give us a real medical diagnosis and stop trying to come up with obfuscations.

I hope he gets better. Of course in all fairness they should appoint Tom Daschle as his replacement if necessary.

  • CNN reporting that Johnon suffered a brain hemorage from a congenital condition. Given that it seemed to occur in a language area (speculative?) any recovery could take some time (also speculative?).

  • It sounds like he has an aneurysm. Very rarely, would a stroke require a surgical intervention. If this is the case, recovery will likely be a long tough process, if he survives.

    I am not pleased with how people on both sides of the aisle are already talking about how this affects the balance of power in the Senate. Our first thoughts should be with the Senator’s health and subsequent recovery. We do not elect D’s or R’s, we elect people.

  • Joe Biden was out of commission for eight or nine months several years ago. Strom Thurmond was completely out of touch for the last two or three years he was there. He wasn’t allowed out without an escort. There is plenty of precedent for Johnson remaining as a Senator even if incapacitated in part or in full.

  • As I commented (very late) on yesterday’s thread, in 2001 when the Senate was 50-50 and it looked like Thurmond might have to step down, I remembered hearing some talk that SC’s governor (a Democrat) should be required to appoint a Republican to replace him. “Will of the voters”, etc. But the only citation I could find was this one from Time: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,999380,00.html. There it cites local Democrats urging a Republican be appointed. That seemed weird, until I came across a 2001 political chat thread (ain’t the web great?) which suggested they wanted the Gov to appoint a Republican state senator so the evenly divided SC state senate would swing to the Dems.

    Does anyone else remember Republican politicians & pundits bloviating about how Thurmond really ought to be replaced by another Republican?

  • We do not elect D’s or R’s, we elect people.

    kumbayah, #4, kumbayah.

    I was about to ask what world you were living in… then I noticed it’s LA. I slapped my forehead and said “Of Course!”

    Just kidding. Your comment was nice. Cute, quaint and totally unrealistic, with just a whiff of self-serving, self-gratifying, indignant self-righteous piety, but nice.

    Just kidding again. I mean when hundreds of thousands of people are being killed because of which party is in power, we should really focus on the suffering of one man, and ignore the balance in the senate, which is the reason the story has legs in the first place, and why we’re talking about it now. Totally you’re right. Good point.

    …OK Now I’m really kidding.

  • Replacing Senator Johnson with Tom Daschle would be the height of political maneuvering (as would the Republican governor’s appointing a GOP hack). The proper two-year replacement would be George McGovern. He’s as close to a statesmen with national and international experience as can be found in South Dakota, he’s the same party as Johnson (respecting the will of the people of SD and not frustrating the national election outcome) and his political ambitions would not be a question.

    I personally hope no replacement is called for.

  • Don’t count Johnson out yet. An AV malformation (the medical condition to which Admiral John Eisold) is serious, but it’s something from which one can recover. My brother had one in his mid-20s; he’s still doing fine as he approaches 50.

  • Ed,

    I am also hoping very hard that no replacement will be needed.

    If one was required, your suggestion would be a very classy way of dealing with the situation.

    Of course, these days the classy move would be the unexpected one, wouldn’t it?

  • Certainly everyone hopes Jophnson is fine, but to pretend that the ramifications of this don’t exist is just ridiculous. It’s part of the deal. It’s why the Executive Branch has a line of succession.

    One instance like this literally swings the balance of government one way or the other. Like it or not, this IS bigger than one man.

  • Perhaps this would be a good time for one of the Maine Senators to switch parties. For the good of the country–just dreaming…

  • Arlen Specter was out for a while undergoing chemo for lymphoma, Craig Thomas (R from a state with a D governor) has acute leukemia and should have started chemo by now. There is lots of precedent for extended recuperation times. Sen. Johnson may be fully functional — it depends on the size of the bleed and its location.

  • ABC News is reporting that,

    President Bush awoke Thursday to news of Johnson’s condition, said first lady Laura Bush. “We’re praying like I know all the people of South Dakota are for his very, very speedy recovery,” Mrs. Bush told CBS’s “Early Show.”

    The news concerning Johnson broke late yesterday afternoon and Bush awoke Thursday morning to the news of Johnson’s condition. This suggests that Bush may have had a few stiff belts after returning from his meeting yesterday at the Pentagon. r

  • Comments are closed.