U.S. emergency care system ‘at its breaking point’

A couple of months ago, a report by the Commonwealth Fund, a private, health care policy foundation, showed that nearly 60% of all Americans of uninsured Americans with chronic conditions either skip doses of medication or go without because it’s too expensive. Of course, because they can’t afford preventative measures, those same Americans are more than twice as likely to visit an emergency room, stay in a hospital overnight, or both, than their insured counterparts.

The result is a strain on the system, which is being pushed to the limit.

Half a million times a year — about once every minute — an ambulance carrying a sick patient is turned away from a full emergency room and sent to another one farther away. It’s a sobering symptom of how the nation’s emergency-care system is overcrowded and overwhelmed, “at its breaking point,” concludes a major investigation by the influential Institute of Medicine.

That crisis comes from just day-to-day emergencies. Emergency rooms are far from ready to handle the mass casualties that a bird flu epidemic or terrorist strike would bring, the institute warned Wednesday in a three-volume report.

“If you can barely get through the night’s 911 calls, how on earth can you handle a disaster?” asked report co-author Dr. Arthur Kellerman, Emory University’s emergency medicine chief.

Maybe — and I’m just throwing this out here — if we had a public health system in which low-income families and those without insurance could get preventative health care they could afford, and not rely on emergency rooms when there’s a medical emergency, ERs wouldn’t be overwhelmed. I know; it’s a wacky idea.

Of course, the Bush administration describes the existing system as “universal care,” which leads me to believe that the White House and HHS don’t quite appreciate the scope of the problem.

Maybe we need to send Bush a copy of ER on DVD so hew can better understand the healthcare system.

  • Hey keep cutting taxes at the fed and state levels, and keep aggressively pushing against and attacking any politician who would raise taxes to pay for services. Soon all of our infrastructures will be in disastrous repair.

  • So you’re saying you favor socialized medicine, eh?

    Why can’t we get over our fear of universal health care – the kind every other modern nation provides. I’ll bet a week’s worth of Bushs’ Quagmire would cover it or at least be a great start.

  • Wait until someone Bushs cares about is refused treatment or treatment is deferred because an emergency room is so full it is faster to go to the regular doctor. These people will not do a thing until someone they actually care about is impacted by the current system. I am guessing though tha t the ‘big shots” get preferential treatment even in the ER. I don’t kn ow howm many of you have been to an ER lately, but even if you have “good” insurance you are in for a long wait.

  • Gracious,

    There are only two problems with your scenario.

    #1 As President, anyone associated with W would NEVER be refused treatment.

    #2 You are assuming that Bush CARES about anyone, other than himself.

  • The Bushites would not ‘care’ for anyone who can’t afford his own medical care.

    The system is breaking down because the Republican’t policy is to make Government ineffective and thus demonstrate their incompetence.

  • MNP – Maybe we can videotape overstretched emergency rooms so Bill Frist can give us a diagnosis of what’s wrong with the system.

    A huge part of the problem with this nation’s emergency services is that ERs are used as doctor’s offices. Many of the cases seen by ER physicians are not emergent at all, but rather could be taken care of by a regular physician. Many hospitals would be well served to offer low-cost, extended-hours healthcare for treating sick children, cases of flu and strep throat as well as minor sprains and lacerations. As we found at a hospital system I worked at, it is even cost-effective to provide free indigent care to prevent more costly ER visits and to prevent lack of routine care, such as prenatal care, from becoming a more expensive issue further down the road. Cash-only clinics might also be able to hold costs down by getting rid of the expenses of billing and collections departments and would eliminate the usual lost or underbilled charges.

    Part of why the medical system is broken is because many people no longer have a family physician nor receive routine health assessments. Plus our only solutions to any health problem is either a pill or surgery. The hospital sytem we currently have needs to rethink its business model. We need a more flexible and cost-effective system that caters to the consumer and doesn’t assume we live in Leave it to Beaver families.

  • How about extending Medicare to the entire population?

    The money can easily be found: eliminate subsidies and tax breaks to the oil and gas industry, agro-business, and pharmaceutical companies, and eliminate monies for “bridges to nowhere” and assorted pork barrel, no bid contracts to Haliburton & Co etc…

    Threaten the creeps in Congress to take away the life-long free medical benefits that they and their families enjoy at the taxpayer’s expenses upon retirement if they do not do something to fix this health care crisis…

  • Please. A medical emergency like a bird flu plague is too far-fetched to believe. I mean, who could possibly forsee something like that happening?

    It’d be like a hurricane wiping out a major US city. C’mon, as if that’s possible.

  • Threaten the creeps in Congress to take away the life-long free medical benefits that they and their families enjoy at the taxpayer’s expenses upon retirement if they do not do something to fix this health care crisis…—Comment by Devil’s Advocate

    I really like that idea. However since it is such a good idea, I doubt that any of our fearless congresspeople will even think of such a thing. Fix a problem? They aren’t here to do that are they? They think they are entitled to be in Washington and they believe they will be able to stay as long as they don’t actually do anything.

  • We already have “bureaucratized” medicine in this country! It’s called KAISER!

    We desperately need to have government-subsidised, proper single-payer health care in this country, like they do in Australia, Canada, and most of Europe.

    The HMO racket is the worst thing to happen to medicine. Small, entrepreneurial, individual doctors have been run out of business. Replacing it is a system that is bureucratic, unfeeling, and predatory. HMO’s don’t give a shit about you, only about making a profit.

  • The billions spent on that Iraq debacle would have funded a lot of low cost(to patients) health clinics.

  • Comments are closed.