Was Romney behind the anti-Romney calls?

One of the big stories in the Republican presidential race last week was a series of controversial survey calls in Iowa and New Hampshire that asked respondents some pointed questions about Mitt Romney. Specifically, voters in the first two Republican contests received calls with negative messages about the former governor’s religion, his Vietnam-era military deferments, his sons’ lack of military service, and the notion that Mormons believe the Book of Mormon is superior to the Bible.

The question, of course, was who was responsible for the calls. For one thing, they may have been illegal — as the Union Leader noted, “New Hampshire law requires that political advertising, including phone calls, identify the candidate being supported. No candidate was identified in the calls.” The state Attorney General’s office began an inquiry into the matter on Friday.

For that matter, there may be political consequences for this. The calls were pretty harsh, and no campaign is going to want to be tied to testing a message that targets Romney on his faith.

Since then, there’s been some question, and sporadic, inconclusive evidence, that Romney’s campaign may have been responsible for the calls, either as a way of testing the efficacy of likely attacks, or to rally some sympathy.

This report from Sam Stein complicates matters a little further.

Yet another connection, albeit an indirect one, now ties Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign to the recent spat of anti-Mormon phone calls made in New Hampshire and Iowa. […]

Marshan Roth of Fairfield, Iowa, who is paid $500 a month as a GOTV (get out the vote) consultant for the Romney campaign, received a call on this past Wednesday night. Rose Kramer of Dubuque, Iowa, who co-chairs Romney’s Iowa faith & values steering committee and is a $1,000-a-month GOTV consultant, received a call either that same day or a day earlier, depending on conflicting reports.

Roth and Kramer are now the third members of Romney’s Iowa campaign to have publicly acknowledged received the calls. Ralph Watts, a state representative in Iowa, who also backs the former governor, was one of the first people to come forward.

And yet, during subsequent press interviews, neither Roth nor Kramer disclosed the positions they held on Romney’s team. In fact, as several other reporters have pointed out, both individuals drastically downplayed their campaign associations.

Is it just a wild coincidence that paid Romney supporters all got the same anti-Romney calls? Perhaps.

There are quite a few Romney backers in Iowa, and the calls may have gone out to quite a few voters.

But Stein added:

[I]t also cannot be ignored that, even after the scandal surfaced, the actors involved were often in Romney’s camp. Justin Hart, who serves on the Romney For President National Faith And Values Steering Committee and is a blogger at MyManMitt.com, was the only person contacted by a source in Western Wats for comment.

The speculation is such that Romney was asked specifically about his campaign’s possible role in the calls this morning.

Reporter: Are you confident that no one who supports you was involved in that push-polling?

Romney: You’ve got to be kidding.

Reporter: Have you — are you confident–

Romney: Obviously, the beneficiaries of push-polling that attacks me is not me. Somebody else has obviously pushed that forward; I have no idea who that was, but I hope the Attorney General of New Hampshire finds out who that is, and we can get that resolved, and know who it was that was behind it. But you know it was a vicious attack on me, an un-American attack on me, and that’s totally inappropriate, particularly at a time like this, with Thanksgiving, recognizing that this is a nation that celebrates diversity of religious thought and belief.

Reporter: It sounds Machiavellian, but you, yourself, you know, alluded to the politics–

Romney: You know, it’s the same, I think it’s the same as the conspiracy theorists, that you’re raising, that said we brought down the World Trade Center ourselves. It just turns everything on its head. A little silly, I think.

Stay tuned.

1 in 3 people in Iowa are voting for Romney – mathematically, 1 in 3 of the calls on average would have gone to a Romney supporter

  • Justin Hart of MyManMitt tried calling different phone numbers for two hours before finally reaching someone at Western Wat for THEIR comment, NOT the other way around. Stein should get his facts straight before making such innuendos.

    This whole inhouse conspiracy just doesn’t wash.

  • Anyone else notice that Romney would not flatly deny that his campaign was behind the calls?

    The non-denial denial has become a staple of American politics along with the passive voice; “Mistakes were made.” Both were used long before the Bush administration but Bushco’s use of either or both on a daily basis has desensitized us to them. George W. Bush has done much to turn vices into habits.

  • There are many legitimate reasons to not to vote for Mitt Romney, but his religious faith should not be one of them. Sadly, Mitt Romney has created a faith-based trap for himself. He is largely responsible for making his Mormon faith a campaign issue, first by insisting that the President must be a person of faith and then through his blurring of distinctions between his own and other Christian faiths.

    For the details, see:
    “Mitt Romney Traps Himself on Faith.”

  • That’s how conspiracies work…conspirators try to make the conspiracy unbelievable causing people to say that’s “silly” and then just quickly dismiss all the evidence without any investigation whatsoever. It’s how conspiracies succeed. “What, Brutus stabbed Caesar? That’s just silly don’t you think?”, as the blood drips from his hands.

    The only way to not know is to not want to know. The evidence is there for all to see but people like Romney will never even look. Jet fuel burned up on impact became liquid again and drained down all the steel beams and melted them in less than an hour. Just silly don’t ya think?
    Kind of like the Joe Smith story? Talk about a conspiracy.

  • What difference does it make really? Who really cares about the calls? It’s no big deal either way and doubt it will have any influence on voters. No matter how one spins it Romney is still the king of “phony-baloney” as Josh Marshall described him. None of the GOP candidates (except Ron Paul perhaps) are electable but Romney will be less embarrassing than the rest. He’s the least extreme choice and the most controllable.

    But then again the selection is really up to the press…or so they think.

  • Gee, Mr. Big Money gets endorsed by Judd Greg, the financier of Business As Usual and all people can worry about is did he call himself names. An endorsement by the person most married to the ruinous status quo that is causing rampant inflation with their crazy unlimited deficit spending and all this article mentions is sill people calling names? I think there’s a bigger story here – politicians selling out ALL voters in exchange for the corporate money that gets them elected. All but one – our Hope For America, Dr. Ron Paul. Go to RonPaul2008.,com and see what you can do to help. And PLEASE register to vote. Only thing the crazies need to win is for reasonable people to get disgusted and stay home.

  • If the NH AG does investigate the push-poll properly, the first thing to find out will be who paid Western Wats. Ought to simplify things.

  • Senator Fred Thompson is the only candidate that gets it. He makes decisions based on principles. Principles don’t change. You have to stand for something and not change who you are based on the polls. That is what Mitt Romney and Rudy Giuliani have done and all of the Democrats do it. Give me a leader that will stand by his principles anyday versus someone that stands for everything.

    I know many Republicans and conservatives that will stay home if Rudy Giuliani is the candidate. He does not represent our values as conservatives, and never will. Millionaire Mitt Romney is a Republican-in-name-only (RINO) that simply has everything else and nothing to do. “I guess I’ll just try to buy the presidency”. The White House isn’t for sale! Mike Huckabee is for illegal alien amnesty and free tuition for aliens! NO THANKS, Mushy Mike!! Conservatives will simply stay home and the Democrats will pick up additional seats in the House and probably get the 60 seats in the Senate they need to completely destroy our country. Nice picture huh?

    However, I think Fred can bring America back together, if that’s even possible. America needs a rebirth of patriotism and honor. Republicans also need a rebirth. President Reagan was our last rebirth and he can never be duplicated. Fred Thompson will bring his own down-to-earth common sense to this country. If a conservative runs as a conservative, he will win!

    Think of it this way: Eight years of another sleazy, corrupt Clinton White House? Now if that is not a sufficient enough reason to pull together as a nation, and fight this socialist liberal takeover of our government, what is?

    Folks, we are in for the fight of our lives, just as our young men and women are fighting for our freedoms in Iraq and Afghanistan, we must fight for our nation right here and now! I truly believe Fred Thompson is the one man who can pull this nation back together! Rudy Giuliani will just tear us apart.

  • Comments are closed.