For the last several years, the conservative line on the economy was relatively straightforward: the economy was great, but the mean ol’ mainstream media refused to tell anyone about it, in part because news outlets were obsessed with Iraq.
Now, apparently, the conservative line has shifted. The economy, they say, is still great, but the mean ol’ mainstream media has confused people into thinking that the economy is souring.
Today on NBC’s “Meet the Press,” host Tim Russert pointed to a new CNBC poll showing that 83 percent of the American public rates the U.S. economy as only fair/poor. Right-wing strategist Mary Matalin tried to brush off that number, stating that most Americans are nevertheless happy about their personal finances.
When liberal strategist Bob Shrum pointed out that her statement is false, Matalin switched to the well-worn tactic of blaming the media for the problem:
MATALIN: Well, there’s an element of cognitive dissonance there, because if you ask them how their own personal finances are going, those numbers completely switch. Yes — he’s looking around. Those numbers are completely true. They absolutely switch on their own personal finances.
SHRUM: I think most people are getting very insecure about their personal finances.
MATALIN: That’s because they’re berated with these numbers.
Lest anyone think Matalin is just some random, unhinged voice, keep in mind, none other than Karl Rove made the exact same argument a couple of weeks ago on (where else?) Fox News, insisting that the “media has been beating the drum for years and years and years that the economy stinks. And after a while, that begins to color people’s attitudes.”
To suggest that the far-right is deeply out of touch with the concerns of the typical American is a dramatic understatement.
Then again, I suppose the Rove/Matalin nonsense is a step up from Sam Zell’s nonsense. Zell, the billionaire owner of newspapers like the Los Angeles Times and the Chicago Tribune, blamed the Democratic presidential candidates in an interview last week.
“Obviously what we have going on is an attempt to create a self-fulfilling prophecy,” Zell said. He continued:
“We have two Democratic candidates who are vying with each other to describe the economic situation worse. The reality is that if you live on Wall Street and you’re in the credit markets the world couldn’t be worse. If you’re a farmer and you’re getting $25 for your wheat, you’re having a great time. If you’re a CEO and you’ve got a balance sheet that’s bullet-proof, you’re in a great position. This whole thing is way out of control, way out of hand.”
The reality, of course, is that the right is desperate to pin the blame on its perceived enemies, but the economic downturn is a) real; and b) hardly a mystery. There’s a mortgage crisis, a credit crunch, a weak dollar, huge deficits, uncomfortably high inflation, weak employment numbers, and rising energy and healthcare costs.
Republicans are left with “let’s cut taxes for millionaires” as some kind of economic policy. It’s foolish, but that doesn’t justify blaming Barack Obama and the New York Times for Americans’ understandable economic insecurities.