Why we fight: Well, um, we’re not really sure

Guest Post by Morbo

Every now and then you read something in the paper that just causes your head to explode. I had one of those moments recently while reading a Washington Post story headlined, “U.S. Lowers Sights On What Can Be Achieved In Iraq.”

The second paragraph of this story by reporters Robin Wright and Ellen Knickmeyer reads:

The United States no longer expects to see a model new democracy, a self-supporting oil industry or a society in which the majority of people are free from serious security or economic challenges, U.S. officials say.

I wanted to hurl my toast across the room. In other words, after more than two years of war, billions of dollars and countless lives, Iraq is going to be like it was under Saddam Hussein — except without a self-sustaining oil industry.

We were told we had to invade Iraq because the country had “weapons of mass destruction.” None were found. Then we were told we invaded Iraq to bring democracy to the country, a democracy that would serve as an example to the region. Scratch that. We were also told we invaded to bring the people there a better, more secure life. Toss that too. And you know that claim about women getting a better shake in the Middle East because of the new Iraq? We’ve ditched that as well. Religious fanatics are already taking over. Many barbers, fearing assassination, no longer shave beards. Alcohol sales have been banned at Baghdad’s airport. An aide to Iraq’s transportation minister stated bluntly, “We are an Islamic country.”

To sum up: We invaded, killed hundreds of thousands of Iraqis, lost 1,800 soldiers (and climbing), generated unprecedented ill will in the region, gave terrorists new bases of operation and created an anarchistic state ruled by chaos where insurgents regularly blow up U.S. soldiers and innocent children, a state that will soon become another fundamentalist Islamic theocracy. Mission accomplished!

For a long time, the American people yawned while the gang that engineered this debacle remained in power. No one was impeached, and the American people did not take to the streets.

But that may be changing. Ominous clouds have been spotted on the border of Dubyaland. The president’s approval ratings have tanked, and polls show the public has turned decisively against the war. The parents of dead soldiers are starting to speak out, as are some returning soldiers.

No, the news is not good. The administration desperately needs a rationale for the war so dumbed down, so simplistic that anyone can grasp it. Bush and Co. need a rationale that sets the bar so low a legless ant could hop right over it.

Thus, as a free public service, I am presenting the administration with 10 reasons why we had to invade Iraq. Note that all are simple and set the bar low. The administration, which has never hesitated to rewrite recent history, should immediately adopt one of these are the reason we went to war and stick to it 24/7. Don’t worry about the compliant media, they won’t make a fuss by daring to point out that this new rationale conflicts with previous statements. Presto! No more nasty failure stories in the papers.

So, with apologies to David Letterman, I’d like to present Top Ten New Reasons Why We Went to War In Iraq:

1. We did it for the children. Won’t someone please think of the children?

2. Those people were living like animals. Most of them had never even seen “reality TV.”

3. We looked at a random sample of city hall buildings in Iraqi towns. There were NO Ten Commandments displays.

4. An American woman was over there. Some Iraqi guys said really rude things to her. Are you going to let those camel jockeys treat our women that way?

5. Someone there burned an American flag!

6. Did they even send a card after 9/11?

7. Iran is developing nuclear weapons. This means Iraq was only one letter away from having them too.

8. The Iraqi Navy had secret plans to sail up the Chesapeake Bay, sack towns along the Maryland western shore and march on Washington, setting fire to the capital and forcing President Madison Bush to flee.

9. Remember that time Janet Jackson exposed her breast during the Super Bowl and destroyed the morals of the entire nation because most people in the country had never seen one of those before? It has never been proven that the Iraqis weren’t totally responsible for that.

10. Rumor has it the Iraqi Supreme Court was on the verge of approving gay marriage.

These are just off the top of my head, and I know some of them could use fine-tuning. I need your help. As always, I welcome your suggestions.

Look at it from the Repbulican perspective — the war is the gift that keeps on giving.

Debating whether to go in delivered the 2002 congressional elections to the GOP.

Debating what to do now that we were in delivered the 2004 election.

Pulling out (Operation Heroes Homeward) should deliver the 2006 mid-terms to the GOP.

The debate over ‘Who lost Iraq’ should be enough to deliver the White House again to the GOP in 2008.

Four election cycles — only one war.

That’s ROI.

  • These are pretty good, Morbo, but Bush
    is on a five day tear through Utah, and
    my poor, beleagured state of Idaho, to
    make the case for the war in Iraq, and
    I’m betting his top ten will make yours
    wilt. In fact, I just read some excerpts
    from his radio address, and he is really
    pouring it on. They are fighting for us
    in Iraq so these savage evil people don’t
    invade and ravage the streets of our
    cities over here. An excerpt from the
    speech:

    “Our troops know that they’re fighting in Iraq,
    Afghanistan, and elsewhere to protect their fellow Americans from a savage enemy,” the president said in the recorded broadcast.

    “They know that if we do not confront these evil men abroad, we will have to face them one day in our own cities and streets, and they know that the safety and security of every American is at stake in this war, and they know we will prevail.”

    Now how can you top that?

  • beleaguered. Damn, I can’t get a single
    posting right.

    Anyway, on Wednesday he’ll be here in
    my town, Nampa, 20 miles west of Boise.
    Canyon County went 75% for Bush in
    2004, I’m ashamed to say. Reagan came
    in second, by a write-in campaign.

    On Monday – Wednesday he’ll be staying,
    bubble-fashion, in Tamarack, the new four
    season resort playground for billionaires,
    about 100 miles north of here.

  • “Mission Accomplished.” Indeed.

    By the way, Morbo, if you’re going to “borrow” Letterman’s schtick, you have to do the Top Ten in E-S-R-E-V-E-R order!

    How about adding these to your list:

    10. See, we told you Iraq had more shit to blow up than Afghanistan!
    9. Colin made me do it!
    8. We were using Jonh Kerry’s plan.
    7. We were practicing for Iran.
    6. What? You thought we were serious about WMD?
    5. We were just testing the “Pottery Barn” rule!!
    4. Osama fooled me on 9-11; won’t get fooled again!
    3. Tax cuts for the rich lost jobs, so we had to go to war to create jobs!
    2. Chickenhawk Dick told me I could be a War President. Hot Damn!!
    1. He tried to kill my Daddy!!

    My personal favorites are #6 and #1. Although #2 has a lot going for it!

  • Analytical Liberal explained it quite well yesterday:

    Lying.
    Lying.Fucking.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.Bastards.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.Bastards.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.Bastards.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.Fucking.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.Lying.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.
    Lying.Fucking.Bastards.
    Lying.Fucking.
    Lying.

    They start out by Lying — they end by Lying — and in between they are nothing but Fucking Bastards. As my mother, God rest her, used to say, “Hell is too good for them.”

  • Vilfredo Pareto had all this down pat. The sequence of all government activity, from getting into office through staying there:

    1. achieving goals
    2. lying to cover up non-achievement
    3. repressing of those who dare to question the lies

    So far BushCo (i.e., Cheney/Rove) has been textbook perfect (though all they seem to have achieved in stage #1 was bankrupting tax giveaways).

    Historically, it’s when the repression effort backfires (Kent State, the apparently tactical error of not cooling out Cindy Sheehan) that the sheep may start to see through the lies and begin to discover their spine.

  • In addition to those offered above:
    1) Staying in Iraq is the only way to ensure that our soldiers didn’t die in vain.
    2) Failure to support the president in this crisis gives treasonous aid and comfort to the enemy,.
    3) Why do democrats hate our country?
    4) Clinton screwed up so badly that we had to do something, even if we didn’t want to, and we would have won by now if democrats hadn’t trashed the armed forces.
    5) You can’t put the squeeze on Iran without having pressure on both sides.
    6) We had heard mixed reports about Iraq’s weapons capabilities, and we needed to find out which version was true.
    7) With perfect hindsight, the original invasion may not have been the best plan, but that time is past, and now we have to stay there and win, or we will lose our national reputation and everyone will think they can walk all over us.
    8) We have to think ahead to building up forward strength in Asia to be ready to counter Chinese hegemony.

  • “Naturally the common people don’t want war. But after all, it is the leaders of a country who determine the policy, and it’s always a simple matter to drag people along whether it is a democracy or a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. This is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and for exposing the country to danger. It works the same in every country.”
    — Hermann Goering, Hitler’s Reich Marshall, at the Nuremberg
    Trials after World War II.

  • In other words, after more than two years of war, billions of dollars and countless lives, Iraq is going to be like it was under Saddam Hussein — except without a self-sustaining oil industry.

    Don’t be ridiculous. Under Saddam Hussein, women and non-Muslims weren’t second-class citizens, and the country wasn’t best pals with a nuclear-armed Iran.

  • And a couple of hundred thousand or so additional Iraqis were actually alive! I’m sure THEY’RE all downright giddy about their newfound “freedom”.

  • 1) We are in Iraq because we are in Iraq.
    2) We must succeed because we can not fail.
    3) We must stay because we cannot leave.
    4) The worst it looks shows how much more desperate they’ve become.
    5) We must have resolve because we can not falter.
    6) We must fight the terrorists our fighting has created.
    7) We must fight to open the oil spiggots our fighting have closed.
    8) We must fight to stop the suffering of the Iraqi people our fighting causes.
    9) More must die so that our soldiers did not die for nothing.
    10) We must stay because to leave would mean we were a bunch of stupid fucking idiots for unquestioningly supporting this war, and re-electing the idiot who conjured it.

  • I think you are too modest! Those are BETTER than a lot of Lettermans writers have come up with on other top ten lists!

    Really!

  • WB: Of Kurds and Crips
    Billmon:

    The Kurds are only playing by the same golden rule as everybody else in the Middle East: Do unto others before they do unto you

    Of Kurds and Crips

    Courtesy of Moon of Alabama

  • Comments are closed.