The Republicans’ cowardly robo-calls

There’s a line in the movie “Serenity” in which Jayne Cobb, who’s something of a mercenary, explains a bit about his philosophy on shooting people. “Hell, I’ll kill a man in a fair fight,” Jayne said, “or if I think he’s gonna start a fair fight.”

We’d all like to think that there’s some nobility in the political process, and a fair right will produce a fair victor, but it’s important to remember that when Republicans anticipate a fair fight, they cheat.

For the second straight day yesterday, Democratic field offices [in New Hampshire] received dozens of phone calls and e-mails from frustrated voters upset about repeated automated phone calls they thought were coming from Democratic candidate Paul Hodes – though the calls were paid for by a Republican group instead.

The National Republican Congressional Committee spent nearly $20,000 on the calls last week. Depending on the rate, that could mean more than 300,000 automated phone calls into the Second Congressional District. […]

[A] spokesman for the NRCC said the automated phone calls would continue indefinitely. “The calls will continue as planned,” said Alex Burgos, a spokesman for the NRCC, the national group charged with electing Republicans to the House.

It’s quite a scheme. The NRCC has decided to make repeated [tag]robo-calls[/tag] to households late in the evening or early in the morning, when they expect people to be sleeping and most annoyed by the calls. When someone answers, they’re led to believe the call is coming from Democrat Paul Hodes’ campaign: “Hello, I’m calling with information about Paul Hodes.” Most hang up, thinking that the Hodes campaign was responsible for the call. If they keep listening, they’ll hear a dishonest smear of Hodes. At the very end of the call, which few seem inclined to sit through, it’s disclosed that the NRCC is responsible for the call.

Of course, practically no one gets that far. Instead, they’re left with the impression that the Hodes campaign keeps annoying their family. A letter-writer to the Monitor said she had been “bombarded by recorded election messages from Paul Hodes.” Marilyn Jewell of Concord wrote that she would be sure to vote for Bass, in part because “he doesn’t pester me to death.”

In other words, the Republicans’ deceitful plan is working.

There are a few angles to consider here. First, the NRCC’s calls are illegal, especially in light of the fact that some of the many harassing calls are going to households on the do-not-call registry. The New Hampshire calls are already under criminal investigation, but that won’t stop them from happening anyway.

Second, make no mistake, this isn’t just limited to [tag]New Hampshire[/tag]. We know of at least five states where this is happening, and there may be more.

Third, Republicans respond by noting that Dems make robo-calls, too. That’s true, but it’s a painfully stupid argument. As Kleiman explained, “[T]he Democrats’ calls are (1) not intended to deceive; (2) made at civilized hours; and (3) not made to numbers on the Do Not Call list.”

And finally, and most importantly, as Kevin Drum noted, let’s not forget exactly who’s responsible for this.

In every election, there have always been individual wingnuts who go over the edge with desperate campaign tactics. It happens on both sides. This time, though, the desperate tactics are coming straight from the Republican central committee. What’s more, there’s not even a hint of embarrassment. In fact, they sound pretty proud of themselves.

The NRCC is dishonest, dishonorable, and disgusting. They are shamelessly and intentionally destroying politics in the United States. They are cowards who, faced with a fair right, feel the need to cheat.

And if Americans fail to do their part tomorrow, they’ll win.

Early 21st century Republicans have the same democratic worth as the Federalists of 1814! Punkish political hackery, it seems, is what Karl Rove and his minions know best. I can only hope the results from tomorrow will show that we won’t get fooled again. Oh, I can also vote tomorrow to help get these bastards out of office. -Kevo

  • At least Mike DeWine is fighting fair… the robo-call I received merely claimed that Sherrod Brown wants every woman to have at least one partial birth abortion (or that’s what it sounded like, I only heard partial birth before erasing it from my answering machine).

  • It sounds like you guys are going to have to have push a similar law to what we have in Canada which bans push polling and all other forms of polling including popularity polls 72 hours before an election. This gives everyone a weekend break from the bullshit of any federal election.

    This was done in reaction to citizens complaining about outside groups (the Canadian Taxpayers Federation -ie: The Grover Norquists of Cannuckistan/Rich folk, the pro life folks and other assorted folks mostly of the right wing stripe) who tried to sway voters at the last minute thru various polling.

    Not to say we’re perfect either. Our pollsters are more incompetent than yours. A lot of our pollsters proclaimed that a Conservative majority was in the making and it turned out to be a con minority (small m). The only pollster that was even close was a national burger chain’s semi serious and unscientific one.

  • Wow! Someone finally caught on to the fact that Republican’ts cheat 😉

    Yes, I know I shouldn’t snark.

    I love the “It’s a crime but we’ll keep doing it” aspect. Does nothing faze these morons?

    But don’t forget, these are the guys who forced Mark Foley to run again in 2006 when all he wanted to do was drop out of elected office and make some of that money that was flowing through his hands as a lobbyst.

  • Former Dan,

    This is a good idea but if we have learned anything from campaign finance reform attempts it is that politicians will not do anything that may hurt them or their party ever. I’m sure a push polling / robo-call reform bill would have some backhanded loophole that allowed calls from 527 groups if it was an odd numbered day and the money was collected with th eexpress purpose of funding annoying calls. Americans are not serious about reforming our government. Hell, most Americans are not really serious about governing.

  • This information needs to be broadcast far and wide even after the election to let the general public know how low Republicans will go to deceive voters. Intentionally misrepresenting yourself and trying to annoy people is just disgusting.

  • “The NRCC is dishonest, dishonorable, and disgusting. They are shamelessly and intentionally destroying politics in the United States. They are cowards who, faced with a fair right, feel the need to cheat.”

    Well, considering it is led by the “deceiving and lying” Ken Mehlman, this should be no surprise.

  • First, the NRCC’s calls are illegal, especially in light of the fact that some of the many harassing calls are going to households on the do-not-call registry.

    I’ve read this bit about the do-not-call registry and I don’t quite understand it – according to the FTC rules, “calls from or on behalf of political organizations, charities, and telephone surveyors would still be permitted, as would calls from companies with which you have an existing business relationship, or those to whom you’ve provided express agreement in writing to receive their calls”.

    The NRCC, being a “poltiical organization”, would be exempt from do-not-call restrictions, wouldn’t it?

  • You have to understand that with Ken Mehlman, his whole life is a lie and deceit. Thus his much sought after expertise in lying and deceiving Americans for the Republican’t party.

  • Well let them call,first it won`t change my vote,and second the rat bastards will get the chance to prove that it`s not fraud or phone harassment. Go Dems.

  • Paging Howard Dean …

    However the election turns out, the DNC ought to sue NRCC left and right for its lies and its dishonest tactics. No more Mr. Nice Guy!

    At noon tomorrow (before the election results are known) Howard Dean should declare that “on Wednesday the DNC will begin exploring legal action against the RNCC and for its shameful, anti-democratic practices.”

  • Ah, the advantages of not having a land line–we went completely wireless with our phones over three years ago, and haven’t regretted it since. I can count on one hand the number of solicitations I’ve gotten since then.

    Nevertheless, this is a disgusting and dishonorable tactic (no surprise there), and I hope they are held accountable to the fullest extent of the law. This little smear campaign explains why more and more people refer to them as the Repugnant Party.

  • That’s a smart trick. The Democrats should do it too. The Democrats should say Republicans make it easier for Terrorists to attack. Democrats should hack the voting machines. Democrats should intimidate Republican voters, too. Democrats should buy more guns, and learn how to use them. Democrats should shout from the hilltops about how Jesus is a Democrat, and how Republicans do Satan’s bidding.

  • DDD:
    According to WMUR — a NH tv station and Assistant Attorney General Jim Kennedy:
    “While political calls are exempt from the federal Do Not Call regulations, New Hampshire modified that law when the state adopted it. It makes prerecorded political messages illegal if they’re called to people on the registry.”

    http://www.wmur.com/news/10239713/detail.html

    There are also reports of the Republican party of New Mexico calling people with Hispanic surnames and ‘informing’ them — incorrectly — that their polling place has been changed to one several miles from their home.

    The Philadelphia Daily News also reports the same tactic being used in the Murphy-Gerlach election. (The robocalls, not the polling place ones.)

    The trouble is, unless someone can get this out to the media, the tactic will work, since most people will hear the beginning of the call and think it is from the campaign being targeted. (And the local stations which are catching this tactic won’t realize that it is something going on in many places.)

    I called Jill Porter and left a message — I assume it is the work number that she lists — letting her know that this is not an isolated tactic.

  • Ricky Santorum,while in State College yesterday, had the following to say about his chances of reelection.

    I do believe that there’s a silent vote, and that we’ve got a lot of those people out there who are going to be coming out because we’ve given them a reason,” Santorum said.

    A commenter on the Centre Daily Times web site made the following observation astute observation:”…[T]here’s a silent vote” = we’re cheating. Cheating is all these jackasses know how to do, but of course this is to be expected because the Republican party is the party of business.

    So far as the robocalls go, Christy at FDL has some practical suggestion about what we can do about them.

    Also, yesterday there was some discouraging polling news. You can find some prespective on it over at Daily Kos. There is also some good polling news today from CNN.

    Democrats hold a 58 percent to 38 percent advantage over Republicans among likely voters in the survey released Monday morning, compared to the 53 percent to 42 percent advantage reflected in the poll a week ago. Pollsters asked people who identified themselves as being likely to vote which party’s candidate they would you vote for in their congressional district if the election were being held today.

  • I’m waiting to see some hack driving around the polling stations tomorrow, with big ReThug signs taped to his car-doors. Maybe I’ll have to take my good friend, Mr. Crowbar, with me when I go to vote….

  • If you’re allowed to just say anything you like, pretending to be someone else, and the practice is defended by the majority party, what’s to stop the Democrats from calling hardcore Republican households at any time of day and saying, “Hi, I’m (insert name here), your Republican candidate. I noticed your kid is awful cute, and I wondered if you’d mind if I took him/her on the campaign trail with me. Of course we’d share a room, kind of keep the expenses down, because Republicans care about the taxpayer’s money. It’s true I was once brought up on pedophile charges, but it’s what you can prove that counts, not what you suspect. Oh, and by the way, vote for me”.

    Seriously, this isn’t politics, it’s mind control. If you people don’t do something to get this government out of power, there’ll come a day when no candidate dares stand against them, because it’s hopeless and at least they’ll let you have some kind of life if you don’t resist.

    That, or another civil war, this time between Republicans and their defenders, and Democrats and theirs. The options for retaking representative government are narrowing by the day.

  • Why not robo calls from the party with the robo congress and the robo president? The question is, do we also have robo citizens?
    It this tactic of obvious deception works, then it speaks volumes about the low intelligence of the electorate.

  • We’ve been getting robo-calls from both parties and from some para-party organisations as well.The Chamber of Commerce called just to remind us to go and vote tomorrow, ’cause it’s important. Fair enough. When I get a call from the candidate, fair enough — if it’s mine, I hang up really quick, since I don’t need convincing and they don’t need to be wasting money.

    But, when it’s a dirty call from the Repubs, I just put the phone down without hanging up, keeping the line open for half an hour — let them pay. It’s not as we get all that many calls, so it’s doubtful I’ll miss anything important. And, if one of us needs to make a call, then we use the cellphone.

  • I don’t have any compunctions about doing this, but this is the number you can use to harass Conquest Communications Group, the company the Republicans are using to harass voters: 804-358-0560. The number was on their website until they started this calling/harassment campaign.

    I called it and recieved an automated system. I’m not really sure what to say or try to do with the number but if anyone has any ideas I’m game.

  • “There’s a line in the movie “Serenity” in which Jayne Cobb, who’s something of a mercenary, explains a bit about his philosophy on shooting people. “Hell, I’ll kill a man in a fair fight,” Jayne said, “or if I think he’s gonna start a fair fight.” – CB

    Everybody should go and buy a copy of the ‘Serenity’ DVD and watch it. Then buy the complete first (and to date only) season of ‘Firefly’ of which the movie was an extension. They’re on Amazon.com.

    Then write to the Marxist studio heads who canceled the series way too early and demand that it be put back into production.

    Trust me. It’ll be good for you. I swear. 🙂

  • All I can say is that my disgust with the American voters will be deeply rooted if the Bush administration is allowed to continue in the same manner it has since their election.

    DO YOURSELVES AND THE WORLD A FAVOR; IMPEACH THE MURDEROUS PIG.

    Resotre my faith in being your national neighbor. Aleviate the worldwide disgust. Do the right thing and vote against the deceitful, dishonest, and destructive administration that currently governs your country.

  • Iv been watching the Cable news since 04:00 PST this election day. I have not heard one mention of Robo Calling, Calls or letters telling people that their polling places have been changed, that they will be arrested if they vote.
    The Corporate media is in the bag.
    Some mention of distrust of “Lectronic” voting machines.
    Some mention of big rain storms in Washington and Oregon
    supressing turn out. NO mention of the Oregon vote by mail
    system.

    Mike D. Oregon

  • In my opinion, “Mike D.” (and I and my housemate) are not seeing Robo Calling because, out of all the states, Oregon is the only one to have the sense to make our voting entirely by post.

    This puts both parties off balance as to how to campaign on the last few days, as a large percentage will have already voted by Election Day. (The law is based on prior laws on absentee balloting.) So not wanting to waste campaign money, they mostly don’t bother us Oregonians.

    Also, if Mike has already voted, his registered party will be notified and he will get no more campaign garbage by mail or phone. (Registration data on the outer envelope makes this possible without violating secrecy. Secrecy is enhanced by a two-envelope system that isolates signatures and addresses from ballots before counting.)

    Other bonuses of mail-in voting:
    The most populous part of our state is having a very heavy rainstorm today, lots of flooded roads and landslides. However, about 40% have already voted, so no problem for them. (The police have been deputized to collect ballots from last-minute voters if they report their need.)

    We don’t need our “Homeland Security” [hah!] to guard our polling places, because there aren’t any.

    No polling place parking problems!

    No standing in long lines in the wet!

  • Comments are closed.